Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Int J Nurs Stud. 2017 Mar 28;71:97–114. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2017.03.012

Table 2.

Study Quality: Potential Bias

Study Methods for Selecting Participants Statistical Methods and Control of Confounding Methods for Measuring Exposure Methods for Measuring Outcome Variable Conflict of Interest Notes and Quality Appraisal
Compton et al.28 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting
Moderate: Nurses who were
not specially trained
identified pressure injuries
LQS
Strength: Used an independent cohort to validate model
Cox20 Note on events for analysis: The author included a power analysis indicating there were enough events. Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries HQS
Cox & Roche17 HQS
Cremasco et
al.1
Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting
Moderate: Non-independent factors included in the analysis without appropriate
adjustment
Major: No criteria for designation of wound as a pressure injury
Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries
Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable
VLQS
Eachempati et al.31 Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients with LOS>6 days)
Moderate: Unclear inclusion/exclusion criteria
Major: Clearly incorrect statistical methods
Moderate: Inappropriate strategy for model building
Major: No criteria for designation of wound as a pressure injury
Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries
Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable
VLQS
Fife et al.29 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting
Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable LQS
Frankel et al.2 Indeterminate: Individuals appear to have been excluded from the study but the inclusion/exclusion criteria are not defined Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries LQS
Kaitani et al.23 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: >15% lost to follow up or missing records/inadequate data collection
Moderate: Inappropriate strategy for model building
Moderate: Variable operation is unclear LQS
Manzano et al.21 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Indeterminate: No reporting of missing data for predictor variables despite high likelihood of missing data MQS
Nijs et al.22 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: Problematic statistical methods with moderate implications for study findings
Indeterminate: Potential temporal ambiguity (it is possible that the predictor variable occurred after the pressure ulcer event) MQS
O’Brien et al.19 Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries HQS
Sayar et al.24 Moderate: Sampled from “high-risk” patients on a risk-assessment scale and then included attributes of the same scale as predictor variables Moderate: Non-independent factors are included in the analysis without proper adjustment
Moderate: Selective reporting of results
Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting
LQS
Slowikowski & Funk4 Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable HQS
Suriadi et al.18 Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting HQS
Tayyib et al.25 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment
Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries LQS
Theaker et al.26 Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis
Moderate: >15% lost to follow up or missing records
Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment
Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable LQS
Ulker Efteli & Yapucu Gunes27 Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients with LOS>6 days) Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries LQS
Yepes et al.30 Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients on mechanical ventilation and vasopressor support) Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment
Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting
Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries LQS