Table 2.
Study | Methods for Selecting Participants | Statistical Methods and Control of Confounding | Methods for Measuring Exposure | Methods for Measuring Outcome Variable | Conflict of Interest | Notes and Quality Appraisal |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Compton et al.28 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting |
– | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries |
– | LQS Strength: Used an independent cohort to validate model |
Cox20 | – | Note on events for analysis: The author included a power analysis indicating there were enough events. | – | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | HQS |
Cox & Roche17 | – | – | – | – | – | HQS |
Cremasco et al.1 |
– | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting Moderate: Non-independent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment |
– | Major: No criteria for designation of wound as a pressure injury Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable |
– | VLQS |
Eachempati et al.31 | Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients with LOS>6 days) Moderate: Unclear inclusion/exclusion criteria |
Major: Clearly incorrect statistical methods Moderate: Inappropriate strategy for model building |
– | Major: No criteria for designation of wound as a pressure injury Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable |
– | VLQS |
Fife et al.29 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting |
– | Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable | – | LQS |
Frankel et al.2 | Indeterminate: Individuals appear to have been excluded from the study but the inclusion/exclusion criteria are not defined | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis | – | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | LQS |
Kaitani et al.23 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: >15% lost to follow up or missing records/inadequate data collection Moderate: Inappropriate strategy for model building |
Moderate: Variable operation is unclear | – | – | LQS |
Manzano et al.21 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis | Indeterminate: No reporting of missing data for predictor variables despite high likelihood of missing data | – | – | MQS |
Nijs et al.22 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Problematic statistical methods with moderate implications for study findings |
Indeterminate: Potential temporal ambiguity (it is possible that the predictor variable occurred after the pressure ulcer event) | – | – | MQS |
O’Brien et al.19 | – | – | – | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | HQS |
Sayar et al.24 | – | Moderate: Sampled from “high-risk” patients on a risk-assessment scale and then included attributes of the same scale as predictor variables | Moderate: Non-independent factors are included in the analysis without proper adjustment Moderate: Selective reporting of results Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting |
– | – | LQS |
Slowikowski & Funk4 | – | – | – | Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable | – | HQS |
Suriadi et al.18 | Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting | – | – | HQS | ||
Tayyib et al.25 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment |
– | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | LQS |
Theaker et al.26 | – | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis Moderate: >15% lost to follow up or missing records Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment |
– | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries Moderate: Limited description of the outcome variable | – | LQS |
Ulker Efteli & Yapucu Gunes27 | Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients with LOS>6 days) | Major: Inadequate number of events for analysis | – | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | LQS |
Yepes et al.30 | Moderate: Restricted sampling (included only patients on mechanical ventilation and vasopressor support) | Moderate: Nonindependent factors included in the analysis without appropriate adjustment Moderate: Unclear statistical reporting |
– | Moderate: Nurses who were not specially trained identified pressure injuries | – | LQS |