Table 1.
Gesture | Description | Contains | PTSch | PPan | Gor | Pon |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arm(s) outa | Extend arm(s) out horizontally from the shoulder | + | ||||
Arm(s) raise | Raise hand(s) or arm(s) vertically above shoulder | Arm(s) raise with object, arm(s) up, hand(s) raise, raise arm(s) | + | + | + | + |
Arm(s) shake | Small repeated back and forth motion of arm(s) | Arm(s) shake on, arm(s) shake with object | + | + | + | |
Arm(s) swing | Large back and forth movement of arm(s) from shoulder | Arm(s) swing direction, arm(s) swing under, arm(s) swing with object, down, up | + | + | + | |
Arm(s) wave | Large back and forth movement of arm(s) raise above shoulder | Arm(s) wave with object; Straw wave | + | + | + | + |
Beckon | Hand moved in a sweep from elbow or wrist towards signaller | Beckoning, finger curl | + | + | (+) | + |
Big loud scratch | Loud exaggerated scratching movement on signaller’s own body | Self-scratch | + | + | + | |
Bipedal rockinga | Side to side or forward and back movement while standing/walking bipedal (rarely also quadrupedal) | Swagger | + | + | + | |
Bipedal stance | Standing bipedally, arms often held out to side with back arched | + | + | + | ||
Bite | Recipient’s body is held between or against lips or teeth of signaller | Kiss, mouthing/gnawing, open mouth kissing, submissive kissing | + | + | (+) | + |
Body drum | Signaller slaps body with hand(s) to make contact | Armcross, beat sides of head, body beat, body beat with object, chest beat play, chest pat, drum belly, slap cheek, slap shoulders | + | |||
Bouncea | Up and down movement of whole body flexing elbows or knees, typically while quadrupedal | (+) | + | + | ||
Bow | Signaller bends forward from waist while bipedal | Bow-extend, bowing | + | + | + | |
Chest beat | Signaller slaps chest with cupped hand(s) to make loud audible contact | 1-handed chest beat | + | |||
Clap | Palms of both hands or feet brought together with audible contact | Clap hands, feet clap, hand clap | + | (+) | + | + |
Dangle | Signaller hangs from arm(s) above another, may shake feet/legs, typically audible with movement in canopy | Dangle with feet shake, rope spinning, rope swinging, swing | + | + | + | + |
Disco arms shake | Shaking arms in rotation movement towards self | Circle hands | + | |||
Drum object | Short hard audible contact of alternating palms against object | Drum, drum object fists/palms, slap ground | + | + | ||
Drum other | Short hard audible contact of alternating palms against recipient | + | + | |||
Embrace | Signaller wraps arm(s) around recipient and maintains physical contact | Embrace full, embracing, mounting | + | + | + | + |
Feet shake | Small repeated back and forth motion of feet or leg(s) | Legs shake | + | + | ||
Finger in moutha | Finger(s) are placed into the mouth of the recipient | (+) | ||||
Gallop | Exaggerated running movement where contact of hands and feet is deliberately audible | Gallop with object, stiff gallop | + | + | + | |
Grab | Signaller hand(s) is firmly closed over part of recipient’s body | 2-handed grab, air grab, hair pulling, hands around head, head-grab, face-grab, grab-hold, grasp, restrain | + | + | + | + |
Grab-pull | As grab but closed hand(s) contact maintained and a force exerted to move recipient from current position | 2-handed grab-pull, hand in neck, hand leading, pull, pull away, pull face to face, pull hair, pull towards, lead | + | + | + | + |
Hand(s) fling | Rapid movement of hand(s) or arm(s) from the signaller towards the recipient | Arm threat, away, go, hand wave off, hitting away, flap, flapping, raise arm quickly, shoo | + | + | (+) | + |
Hand(s) on | Hand—typically palm or knuckles—placed on recipient with contact lasting >2 s | Arm on, pat off | + | + | + | + |
Hand(s) shake | Small repeated back and forth motion of hand(s) from wrist | Hand(s) shake with object, shake wrist | + | + | + | |
Head butt | Head is briefly and firmly pushed into recipient’s body | Head on | + | + | + | |
Head rub | Back and forth movement of palms of hand(s) over the signaller’s head | + | ||||
Head shake | Small repeated back and forth motion of head | Bob, chin up/nod, head bob, head nod, head rock, head shake with object, head tipping, head turn, head twirl, tip head | + | + | + | + |
Head stand | Signaller bends forward and places head on ground | + | + | (+) | + | |
Hide | Body part, e.g. face, genitals, is hidden by the hand(s) or arm(s) | Cover, hide face, hide playface | + | + | + | |
Hip thrusta | Sitting, crouching, or standing, the hips are thrust forward (single or repeated) | Thrust | + | + | ||
Hit with object | Signaller brings object into short hard contact with recipient’s body | Club | + | + | + | |
Jump | While bipedal both feet leave ground simultaneously with horizontal displacement | Bipedal jump | + | + | + | |
Kick | Foot/feet brought into short hard contact with recipient’s body with horizontal movement | Kick backwards | + | + | + | |
Knock object | Back of hand/knuckles brought into short hard audible contact with object | Knock, rap, rap knuckles | + | + | + | |
Leaf clip | Strips are torn from a leaf/leaves using hand or mouth, making a conspicuous rhythmic sound | Clip leaf | + | |||
Leaf drop | A leaf(s) is picked off and dropped, usually signaller is above recipient | (note: similar usage to leaf clip) | + | |||
Leg(s) flap | Sitting with knees bent, one or both legs opened and closed to the side (single or repeated) | + | ||||
Leg(s) rub | Back and forth movement of palms of hand(s) over the signaller’s leg(s) | + | ||||
Leg(s) swing | Large back and forth movement of leg(s) from hip | + | + | + | ||
Lick hand | Licking of the palm frantically and repetitively | + | ||||
Look | Signaller holds eye contact with recipient lasting >2 s | Peer, peering, putting face close, look back, wait | + | + | + | + |
Mouth stroke | Signallers palm or fingers repeatedly run over mouth area of recipient | Hand beg, rub chin | + | + | ||
Object in mouth | Signaller approaches recipient while carrying object (e.g. small branch) in the mouth | + | (+) | |||
Object move | Object is displaced in one direction, contact is maintained with object throughout | Branch dragging, drag branch, push backwards, push object, rake/scratch dead leaves, scrub, sway vegetation | + | + | + | + |
Object on head | Object is placed on head | (b) | (b) | + | + | |
Object shake | Repeated back and forth movement of an object | Branch shaking, branch rinse, flail, shake detached branch, shake object | + | + | + | + |
Pirouette | Signaller turns around their body’s vertical axis | Ice skating, Pirouette with object | + | + | + | |
Poke | Firm, brief, push of one or more fingers into recipient’s body, may be repeated | Poke at, poking, hard touch, tickling and poking | + | + | + | + |
Pounce | Signaller displaces through air to land quadrupedally on the body of the recipient | + | + | + | ||
Present body part | Body part is moved to deliberately expose an area to recipient’s attention | Back offer, belly offer, foot back, foot present, present climb-on, present groom, flexed knees, leg bending, lead forward, lie with back to another, lower/raise leg, lowering back, solicit grooming, turn face downwards | + | + | (+) | + |
Present genitals | Genitals are moved to deliberately expose them to recipient’s attention | Present, present genitals forwards/backwards, present rear, present with limbs flexed | + | + | + | + |
Punch object/ground | Movement of whole arm, with short hard audible contact of closed fist to an object or the ground | Backhand, thump | + | + | ||
Punch other | As punch object/ground but contact is with recipient’s body | Hit, wrist hit | + | + | + | |
Push | Palm(s) in contact with recipient’s body and force is exerted in attempt to displace the recipient | Back push | + | + | + | + |
Push directed | A light short non-effective push that indicates a direction of desired movement, immediately followed by the recipient moving as indicated | Direct-hand, positioning, turn head, tactile close gestures | + | + | + | + |
Reach palm | Arm is extended to the recipient with hand in open, palm exposed position (no contact) | Beg, begging with hand, extend hand, extend palm, holding hard towards another, reach, reach hand, stretch out hand, | + | + | + | + |
Reach wrista | As reach palm, but wrist or back of hand extended towards recipient with palm in sheltered position | Offer arm, reach, stretch out hand, wrist bending | + | + | + | + |
Rockinga | Large back and forth movement of body while seated or quadrupedal | + | + | + | + | |
Roll over | Signaller rolls onto their back exposing stomach, can be accompanied by repeated movements of arms and/or legs | Lie down on back | + | + | (+) | + |
Rump rub | Rump area is pushed and/or rubbed with small repeated up and down movements against the body of the recipient | Rump turn | + | + | ||
Shake hands | Signaller grasps recipient’s hand/fingers in their own hand and makes small repeated back and forth movements from the wrist | Hand holding/shaking, hold hand | + | + | (+) | + |
Show | Arm holding object is partially extended towards recipient and held | + | ||||
Shrug | Shoulder is raised quickly against recipient | + | ||||
Side roulade | Body is rotated around the head-feet axis while lying on the ground | + | + | + | ||
Slap object/ground | Movement of the arm from the shoulder with hard short contact of the palm(s) to an object or the ground | Ground slap, hit ground/object, slap surface, slap–stomp | + | + | + | + |
Slap object with object | As slap object but the hand(s) which is brought into contact with an object holds another object | Banging, club ground | + | + | (+) | |
Slap other | As slap object/ground but contact is with recipient’s body | Club another, hit, poke at, simultaneous hit, slap other with object, slapping | + | + | + | + |
Somersault | Signaller’s body is curled into a compact position on the ground and rolled forwards or backwards so the feet are brought over the head | Back roll | + | + | + | + |
Stiff stance | Standing rigidly with still limbs and forelimbs held tight, usually with facial expression of tight lips | + | ||||
Stiff walk | Walk quadrupedally with a slow exaggerated movement | Play walk, stiff 3-feet walk | + | + | + | |
Stomp | Sole of the foot/feet is lifted vertically and brought into short hard contact with the surface being stood upon | Foot beat, heel kicking, multiple stomp, multiple stomp 2-feet, stamp, stamp 2-feet, stamp object, stamping, stomp 2-feet, stomp ritualized, stomping | + | + | + | |
Stomp other | As Stomp but contact is with recipient’s body | Foot stomp, jumping, stamping on the back, stomp other 2-feet | + | + | + | |
Strokea | Stroking another individual with gentle back and forth movement of the palm(s) or fingers | Brush, Stroking | + | + | + | + |
Tandem walk | Subject positions arm over the body of the recipient and both walk forward while maintaining position | Arm neck, arm round, embrace half | + | + | + | + |
Tap body | Movement of the arm from the wrist or elbow with firm short contact of the fingers to the signaller’s body (may include rhythmic repetition) | Body tapping with object, single body tap, tapping body, tapping contralateral | + | |||
Tap object | As tap body but contact is with object | Tapping object | + | + | + | |
Tap other | As tap body but contact is with recipient’s body | Tap, tapping other | + | + | + | + |
Throw object | Object is moved and released so that there is displacement through the air after release | Aimed throwing, drop branch, lift and drop, throw at, throw threat | + | + | + | |
Touch other | Light contact of the palm and/or body of the recipient, for under 2 s | Hands on shoulders, hold, light touch, touch, touch-side | + | + | + | + |
Water splash | Hand or feet moved vigorously through the water so that there is audible displacement of water | Hit water | + | + | + |
+ indicates that the gesture is present with video evidence of intentional use in our group, (+) indicates that the gesture is present but without existing video evidence of intentional use in our group, (b) indicates that the action is seen in that species but with no observations of its intentional use in our group. Gorilla gestures only produced by single captive individuals with a close history of human interaction were excluded here, but these included: face wipe, finger down lips, hand(s) between legs, hands behind back, mouth/lips, teeth, wrist glance
PTSch, Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii; PPan, Pan paniscus; Gor, Gorilla gorilla; Pon, Pongo
aA new gesture type as compared to our previous published catalogues for gorillas (Genty et al. 2009; Tanner and Byrne 1999; Tanner 1998), chimpanzees (Hobaiter and Byrne 2011a, b) and bonobos (Graham et al. 2016)