Table 1. .
Authors (Year) |
Cohort Study Design |
Participant Characteristics |
Exposure Definition: Treatment Type |
|
Surgical |
Nonsurgical |
|||
Lohmander et al23 (2004) | Retrospective | Age range = 26–40 y, women only, Swedish, league soccer: identified through insurance company archive | Various reconstruction methods (62% autologous patellar tendon graft), n = 41 with radiographic data | No explanation of nonoperative treatment, n = 26 with radiographic data |
Kessler et al41 (2008) | Retrospective | Age range = 12.5–54 y, males = 62%, females = 38%, participants matched age, sex, body mass index, Tegner score, follow-up | Bone–patellar tendon–bone reconstruction, procedures performed by various practitioners, radiographic data: n = 60 | Standardized, nonoperative treatment program, carried out by various physiotherapists, radiographic data: n = 49 |
von Porat et al32 (2004) | Retrospective | Age range = 30–56 y, men only, Swedish league soccer players identified through insurance company archive | Various surgical methods (most common: patellar tendon graft) | No explanation of nonoperative treatment |
Meuffels et al25 (2009) | Retrospective | Mean age = 37.7 y, males = 76%, females = 24%, Netherlands, participants matched by age, sex, Tegner score | Bone–patellar tendon–bone reconstruction, performed by 1 of 2 surgeons, radiographic data: n = 50 | Rehabilitation program: edema reduction, range of motion, hamstrings and quadriceps strengthening exercises |
Abbreviation: KL, Kellgren-Lawrence Scale.
Maximum possible score for modified instrument = 10.