Table 1.
Feature | Narrative review | Systematic review |
---|---|---|
Research question | Broad and informal (often not explicitly specified) | Specified and specific |
Literature sources and search | Usually not specified | Comprehensive sources (more than one database) and explicit search strategy |
Study selection | Usually not specified | Explicit selection criteria |
Quality assessment of included studies | Usually not present or informal (not explicitly specified) | Critical appraisal on the basis of explicit criteria |
Synthesis | Often a qualitative summary | Qualitative and sometimes also a quantitative summary (meta-analysis) |
Time | Monthsa | >1 year (usually) |
Required expertise | Science | Science, systematic review, literature searches, data analysis (including meta-analysis) |
Costs | Lowa | Moderate to high |
Note that these are just generalized estimates and true costs are likely to be variable for both narrative and systematic reviews
aNarrative reviews of authorities may take years, which are associated with high costs