Skip to main content
. 2017 Jun 30;83(14):e00644-17. doi: 10.1128/AEM.00644-17

TABLE 4.

Comparison of results obtained from the PCR, VIDAS, and culture methodsa

Source (no. of samples) PCR result or CT value VIDAS result Culture resultb
Cheese product plant (132) 22.49 Negative Positive
38.13 Negative Positive
37.79 Negative Negative
Cheese product company (140) 25.75 Negative Positive
26.31 Positive Positive
27.25 Positive Positive
28.84 Positive Positive
31.26 Positive Positive
34.08 Negative Positive
34.40 Negative Positive
Negative Positive Negative
Whey powder company (154) All negative 7 positives 7 of 7 negative
6 food product companies (686) 36.64 All negative 1 of 1 negative
3 dairy product companies (309) All negative All negative Not performed
2 food and cheese companies (320) All negative All negative Not performed
Total (1,741) 11 positive 12 positive 9 positive
a

A total of 1,741 environmental samples from 14 food-processing facilities were screened by PCR and VIDAS methods. Culture analyses were performed for a total of 19 samples that were positive according to the PCR or VIDAS method. Salmonella isolates were obtained from 9 of 11 PCR-positive samples and 4 of 12 VIDAS-positive samples. VIDAS failed to detect Salmonella in 5 culture-positive samples.

b

Culture analyses were performed for all samples that were positive with PCR or VIDAS screening.