Table 2. PTSD prevalence in primary care populations.
Study | N of completed PTSD assessment | PTSD ascertainment tool | Mean questionnaire scores (SD) | Cutoff scores | Time period of PTSD symptoms measured | PTSD Prevalence | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Point | Lifetime | Medical records/claims | ||||||
Stein et al. (2000)17 | 368 | PCL-C | 29.7 (12.5) | 4 or 5 on at least 1 “B” criteria, at least 2 “C” criteria, and at least 1 “D” criteria | Past month | 9% | ||
Applegate (2001)18 | 431 | DIS-IV | N/A | N/A | Past month | 10% | 21.6% | |
Taubman-Ben-Ari et al. (2001)19 | 2,975 | PTSD Inventory from Soloman et al. 1987 59 | Not reported | Not reported | Past month | 23% | ||
Carey et al. (2003)20 | 220 | Adapted CIDI | N/A | N/A | Past month | 19.9% (16.7% male, 21.9% female) | 44.3% (42.3% male; 45.5% female) | |
Thulesius et al. (2004)21 | 1,113 | PTSS-10 and IES and 7 additional items re: hyperarousal symptoms | Not reported | >35 for IES and >5 for PTSS-10 | Past few days | 6.5% | ||
Gillock et al. (2005)22 | 232 | PCL-C plus additional items to assess DSM-IV criteria E and F “Life Events Checklist” | Not reported | If met criteria A through F | Past month | 9% full PTSD/25% partial PTSD | ||
Gomez-Benevto et al. (2006)23 | 295 | CIDI | N/A | N/A | Past month and lifetime | 9% | 14.5% | |
Kroenke et al. (2007)24 | 965 | SCID | N/A | N/A | Past month | 8.6% | ||
Liebschutz et al. (2007)25 | 509 | CIDI | N/A | N/A | “[C]urrent past 12 mo and lifetime PTSD documented from CIDI” | 23% (95% CI,19-26%) | 34% | 11% |
Peltzer et al. (2007)26 | 250 | PCL-C, interview administered; Trauma History Questionnaire | M 3.5 (SD not provided) | 3+ (“cluster scoring”) | Past month | 12.4% | ||
Cwikel et al. (2008)27 | 976 | “PTSD Checklist--21 items” | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | 2.9% | ||
Fedovskiy et al. (2008)28 | 105 | Posttraumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale “structured interview” | Not reported | ≥28 out of 49 | Past month | 19% | ||
Fogarty et al. (2008)29 | 367 | Short screen from Breslau et al.60 | Not reported | 4+ | Past month | 14.6% | ||
Duran et al. (2009)30 | 234 | CIDI | N/A | N/A | Past year | 14.5% | ||
Freedy et al. (2010)31 | 411 | CAPS (modified for telephone interview rather than face-to-face) | N/A | N/A | Past month | 32.1% (19.4% male; 34.8% female) | ||
Gaynes et al. (2010)32 | 647 | MINI | Not reported | ≥ 2 | Past month | 6.3% | ||
Wrenn et al. (2011)33 | 767 | PSS | Not reported | “A categorical variable that serves as a proxy for PTSD was created based on DSM-IV A-E criterion responses to the PSS questionnaire (A, presence of trauma; B, presence of at least 1 intrusive symptoms; C, presence of at lease 3 avoidance/numbing symptoms; and D, presence of at least 2 hyperarousal symptoms; and E, present for at least 1 month).” | Past month | 30% | ||
Vera et al. (2012)34 | 3,568 | PC-PTSD | Not reported | 3+ | Past month | 14% | ||
Bunevicius et al. (2014)35 | 988 | MINI | Not reported | Not reported | Past two weeks | 2% | ||
Preville et al. (2014)36 | 1,765 | PTSS Scale | 7.5 (9.6) | 10 | 6-months | 11.1% | ||
Bener et al. (2015)37 | 1475 | Arabic WMH-CIDI-10 (verson 3.0) | N/A | N/A | Past month | 10.5% | ||
Special Risk Populations (Refugee/Immigrant) | ||||||||
Eisenman et al. (2003)38 | 512 | PCL-C | Not reported | Not reported | Past month | 12.5% (18% if exposed to violence, 8% if not exposed) | ||
Eytan et al. (2007)39 | 101 | Adapted MINI | 1st criteria 83%, 2nd criteria 59%, 3rd avoidance 28%, 4th criteria 24%, 5th criteria 24% | Not reported | Past month | 23.8% | ||
Aragona et al. (2013)40 | 391 | Harvard Trauma Questionnaire | Not reported | 2.5 | Past month | 10.2% | ||
Veterans | ||||||||
Dobie et al. (2002)41 | 282 | CAPS | N/A | N/A | Past month | 36% | ||
Mori et al. (2003)42 | 309 | BAI-PC | BAI-PC mean 4.27 range 0-21 | BAI-PC cutoff 5 and above; PCL ≥50 | “Current PTSD” | 12% | ||
Prins et al. (2003)43 | 167 | CAPS | N/A | N/A | Past month | 24.5% | ||
Escalona et al. (2004)44 | 264 (134 veterans and 130 non-veteran controls) | CIDI | N/A | N/A | Lifetime | 27% | ||
Magruder et al. (2005)45 | 746 | CAPS | N/A | N/A | Past month | 11.5% | ||
Spiro et al. (2006)46 | 2,262 | PCL-M | PTSD+ M=56.1, SD=12.3, range 31-85 (does not list these measures for the group as a whole) | Not reported | Past month | 20% | ||
Seal et al. (2007)47 | 103,788 | Medical record review, ICD-9 code | N/A | N/A | Diagnosis present in the medical record | 13% | ||
Funderburk et al. (2008)48 | 10,043 | PC-PTSD | Not reported | ≥3 means “at risk” | Past month | 3.5% | ||
Kinder et al. (2008)50 | 35,715 | ICD-9 or self-report | N/A | N/A | Lifetime | 12.1% | ||
Andersen et al. (2010)51 | 4,416 | Medical record review, ICD-9 dx by primary care provider | N/A | N/A | Past month symptoms, screen given yearly, diagnosed within 6 years of the study | 14.5% | ||
Haskell et al. (2010)52 | 1,129 | PC-PTSD | Not reported | ≥3 means “at risk” | Past month | 31.1% (33% male; 21% female) | ||
McDevitt-Murphy et al. (2010)53 | 151 | PCL-M | Not reported | 50 | Past month | 39.1% | ||
Zivin et al. (2010)54 | 2,536,727 | Medical record review, dx method not reported | N/A | N/A | Diagnosis present in the medical record | 4.2% | ||
Mitchell et al. (2014)55 | 492 | Medical record review, ICD-9 code | N/A | N/A | Diagnosis present in the medical record | 26.8% | ||
Mohanty et al. (2015)56 | 78,435 | Medical record review, ICD-9 code | N/A | N/A | Diagnosis present in the medical record | 29.2% | ||
Trivedi et al. (2015)57 | 4,461,208 | Medical record review, ICD-9 code | N/A | N/A | Diagnosis present in the medical record | 9% | ||
Wingenfeld et al. (2015)58 | 613 | CAPS | N/A | N/A | Past month and lifetime | 32.5% | 48.8% |
Abbreviations: BAI-PC: Beck Anxiety Inventory-Primary Care; BPHQ: Brief Patient Health Questionnaire; CAPS: Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale; CIDI: Composite International Diagnostic Interview; DIS-IV: diagnostic interview schedule for DSM-IV; DSM-IV: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, fourth edition; Dx: diagnosis; ICD-9: International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision; IES: Impact of Event Scale; MINI: Mini-international Neuropsychological Interview; PC-PTSD: Primary Care PTSD Screen; PCL-C: PTSD checklist-civilian; PCL-M: PTSD checklist-military; PTSS: Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome; PCL: PTSD checklist; PTSD: Posttraumatic stress disorder; PTSS-10: Posttraumatic Stress Syndrome-10; SCID: Structured Clinical Interview; VA: Veterans Affairs; WMH: World Mental Health