Table 5.
Calculated overall cost per ongoing pregnancy after hysteroscopic polypectomy (office or operative) versus expectant management based on the pregnancy rates from three IVF/ICSI studies.
Office Procedure | IVF/ICSI | |||||||
| ||||||||
Hysteroscopic Polypectomy | Expectant Management | |||||||
| ||||||||
Study | Ongoing Pregnancy Rate | Treatment Cost | Cost per Ongoing Pregnancy | Ongoing Pregnancy Rate | Treatment Cost | Cost per Ongoing Pregnancy | Cost Savings | |
| ||||||||
Lass et al. | 28.6% | €16,1831 | €56,584 | 16.3% | €15,4502 | €94,788 | €38,204 | |
$18,183 | $63,577 | $17,360 | $106,503 | $42,926 | ||||
| ||||||||
Isikoglu et al. | 45.0% | €16,1831 | €35,962 | 46.7% | €15,4502 | €33,084 | −€2,878 | |
$18,183 | $40,407 | $17,360 | $37,173 | −$3,234 | ||||
| ||||||||
Ghaffari et al. | 30.2% | €16,1831 | €53,586 | 27.9% | €15,4502 | €55,378 | €1,792 | |
$18,183 | $60,209 | $17,360 | $62,222 | $2,013 | ||||
| ||||||||
Average | 35.6% | €16,1831 | €45,458 | 25.2% | €15,4502 | €61,311 | €15,854 | |
$18,183 | $51,076 | $17,360 | $68,889 | $17,813 | ||||
| ||||||||
Operative Procedure | Hysteroscopic Polypectomy | Expectant Management | ||||||
| ||||||||
Study | Ongoing Pregnancy Rate | Treatment Cost | Cost per Ongoing Pregnancy | Ongoing Pregnancy Rate | Treatment Cost | Cost per Ongoing Pregnancy | Cost Savings | |
| ||||||||
Lass et al. | 28.6% | €19,4623 | €68,048 | 16.3% | €15,4502 | €94,788 | €26,740 | |
$21,867 | $76,458 | $17,360 | $106,503 | $30,045 | ||||
| ||||||||
Isikoglu et al. | 45.0% | €19,4623 | €43,248 | 46.7% | €15,4502 | €33,084 | −€10,164 | |
$21,867 | $48,593 | $17,360 | $37,173 | −$11,420 | ||||
| ||||||||
Ghaffari et al. | 30.2% | €19,4623 | €64,442 | 27.9% | €15,4502 | €55,378 | −€9,064 | |
$21,867 | $72,407 | $17,360 | $62,222 | −$10,185 | ||||
| ||||||||
Average | 35.6% | €19,4623 | €54,667 | 25.2% | €15,4502 | €61,311 | €6,644 | |
$21,867 | $61,424 | $17,360 | $68,889 | $7,465 |
IVF=in vitro fertilization
ICSI=intracytoplasmic sperm injection
Calculated cost of IVF/ICSI with office hysteroscopic polypectomy
Calculated cost of IVF/ICSI
Calculated cost of IVF/ICSI with operative hysteroscopic polypectomy
€=Converted 2016 Euros; $=2016 US Dollars
Cost savings is expectant management cost minus polypectomy cost and favors polypectomy