Table 1.
Retrospective and Randomized data on Surgery Alone and (neo-) adjuvant RT plus Surgery in ESTS | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author/Reference | n | RT regimen | CT regimen | R0 resections | Wound complications | Local control (@ X years) |
Cahlon [22] | 684 | 0 Gy (surgery only) | none | – | – | 53% @ 5 yrs |
Pisters [19] | 88 | 0 Gy (surgery only) | none | 84% | – | 84% @ 10 yrs |
Baldini [20] | 74 | 0 Gy (surgery only) | none | 92% | – | 93% @ 10 yrs |
Rosenberg [4] | Randomized trial n = 16 versus 27 |
0 Gy (amputation) | ACM (all cases) | 100% | – | 100% @ 4.7 yrs |
50 + 10–20 Gy | 85% | 85% @ 4.7 yrs | ||||
Pisters [23] | Randomized trial n = 78 versus 86 |
0 Gy (surgery only) | none | 82% | 10% | 69% @ 5 yrs |
42 – 46 Gy brachytherapy | none | 48% (direct afterloading) 14% (delayed afterloading) | 82% @ 5 yrs | |||
Yang [24] | Randomized trial n = 141 (for details see Legend) |
0 Gy (surgery only) | Adjuvant 5 times AC for all high grade STS | – | Trial randomized postoperative RT only | In high grade STS 78% versus 100% @ 10 yrs In low grade STS 68% versus 95% @ 10 yrs |
45 + 18 Gy postoperative | – | |||||
O’Sullivan [1] | Randomized trial n = 94 versus 96 |
50 Gy preoperative | none | 84% | 35% | 92% @ 3.3 yrs |
50 + 16 Gy postoperative | none | 86% | 17% | 93% @ 3.3 yrs |
Abbreviations: RT = radiotherapy, ESTS = extremity soft tissue sarcoma, n = number of cases, CT = chemotherapy, AC = doxorubicin and cyclophosphamide, ACM = doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide and methotrexate.