Table 2.
Program Description | Task Shared or New Task |
Control / Comparison Group |
Primary Process and /or Health Outcome Measures Reported |
Author (Yr) and Countrya |
---|---|---|---|---|
Telemedicine-based collaborative care mental health support located off- site to enable outreach to small rural clinics that may not be able to support an on-site psychiatrist |
Primary care depression treatment shared between local clinic and remote expert team |
Usual care + educational materials to providers and patients, and depression screening result in electronic medical record |
↑ adherence, mental health status, quality of life and satisfaction and ↓ depression |
Fortney 2007 U.S. |
Telemedicine-based collaborative care off-site mental health support to clinics including nurse care manager, pharmacist, psychologist, and psychiatrist |
Primary care depression treatment shared between local clinic and remote expert team |
On-site PCP and nurse care manager |
↓ depression which appeared to be attributed to higher fidelity in the telemedicine intervention |
Fortney 2013 U.S. |
Rural clinics were included in a large effectiveness study of collaborative care but not separated from urban clinics in analysis of effectiveness |
Primary care depression treatment shared between PCPs, care manager and consulting psychiatrist |
NA | NA |
Unutzer 2002 U.S. |
Shared care / collaborative care in a rural clinic setting worked to improve communication between general practitioners (GP) and psychiatric consultants |
Psychiatrist consults with GPs through regular meetings and videoconference while also travels to 1 rural clinic a day, 3 days a week |
NA | ↑ GP satisfaction with mental health services over 5 years of program |
Samy 2007 Australia |
Consultation models and collaborative models which both involve primary care providers are described as a means to leverage specialists in child and adolescent psychiatry |
Psychiatrist consults with PCPs |
NA | NA |
Szeftel 2011 U.S. |
Therapists trained in cognitive behavioral therapy (high- intensity) and computerized CBT guided self-care and psychoeducation groups (low-intensity therapists) integrated into primary care clinics to offer stepped care for depression and anxiety |
High-intensity face-to-face CBT therapists and low- intensity therapists called psychological wellbeing practitioners work with primary care |
NA |
Gyani 2013: Among patients with 2 sessions, 40.3% recovered, 63.7% improved, and 6.6% deteriorated. Compliance with IAPT model appeared to enhance recovery rates. |
Clark 2011; Gyani 2013 U.K. |
Specialist-guided videoconferencing consults with rural primary care providers offer mental health and substance abuse consultation while also creating a community of practice among rural providers for continued learning and support |
Psychiatrist consults with PCPs, and PCPs support one another through building a community of practice |
NA | On topics of addiction and psychiatry, 16 clinics, 239 clinicians and 105 patients were reached through this program |
Scott 2012 U.S. |
Consult service using telephone contact for PCPs who want to consult a child psychiatrist |
Psychiatrist consults with PCPs |
NA | PCPs consulted on medication and psychosocial treatment; satisfaction was high |
Hilt 2013 U.S. |
Televideoconferencing to support psychiatrist in the care team for children with special health care needs in rural areas which can include direct care with the child / family and/or consultation and supervision of community mental health providers |
Psychiatrist consults with PCPs |
NA | Three urban psychiatrists saw 159 patients via telepsychiatry and 210 face-to-face |
Sulzbacher 2006 U.S. |
Telepsychiatry with team (eg, parent, teacher, social worker, nurse, principal) supporting students at rural K - 12 schools |
Psychiatrist consults with team at the schools |
NA | NA |
Knopf 2013; Saeed 2011 U.S. |
Telepsychiatry with team supporting students at more rural universities (eg, local psychologist) |
Psychiatrist consults with team in mental health at the university |
NA |
Khasanshina 2008: Those referred to consult were more distressed and needing psychotropic medication; satisfaction lower at first as they worked out technology challenges |
Saeed 2011; Khasanshina 2008 U.S. |
Multidisciplinary rural mental health care delivery program involving a psychiatric nurse, social worker, occupational therapist, Maori mental health worker, alcohol and drug counselor, psychologist, and forensic psychiatry nurse utilizes telepsychiatry consults in primary care and home visits and an off- hours on- call services for emergencies |
Multidisciplinary program providers shared care. Psychiatrist visits weekly and a child and adolescent psychiatrist and psychogeriatrician visit monthly to work with GPs. Tele-psychiatry also used for case review. |
NA | NA |
Mahmood 2001 New Zealand |
Group psychotherapy for PTSD treatment trial offered via televideoconferencing from a doctoral-level mental health specialist and included an on-site clinical observer to safeguard against undue emotional escalations |
On-site support person helps with technology difficulties and helps safeguard participants |
NA | NA |
Moreland 2009 U.S. |
All articles were peer reviewed.