Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 13;8(23):37263–37277. doi: 10.18632/oncotarget.16146

Table 1. Characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis.

Author Year Country Ethnicity Source Cancer Case Control MAF HWE Score
BB Bb bb All BB Bb bb All
rs1047768 T>C
Shen M 2005 China Asian PB Lung 55 49 14 118 63 36 13 112 0.28 0.037 10
Zienolddiny S 2006 Norway Caucasian PB Lung 60 119 137 316 109 126 138 373 0.54 <0.001 11
Moreno V 2006 Spain Caucasian HB Colorectal 114 184 53 351 105 164 51 320 0.42 0.325 11
Garcia-Closas M 2006 Spain Caucasian HB Bladder 188 530 385 1103 222 506 366 1094 0.57 0.052 12
Xie WM 2007 China Asian PB HCC 194 195 38 427 235 196 48 479 0.30 0.451 11
Abbasi R 2009 Germany Caucasian PB Laryngeal 43 127 78 248 115 320 212 647 0.57 0.762 13
Hussain SK 2009 China Asian PB Gastric 97 61 12 170 189 168 29 386 0.29 0.173 13
Ma H 2012 USA Caucasian HB SCCHN 184 506 369 1059 179 507 379 1065 0.59 0.669 11
Sakoda LC 2012 USA Caucasian PB Lung 108 378 256 742 245 722 507 1474 0.59 0.656 15
He J 2013 China Asian HB Gastric 571 469 85 1125 610 474 112 1196 0.29 0.155 13
Paszkowska-Szczur K 2013 Poland Caucasian PB Melanoma 128 291 214 633 242 623 465 1330 0.58 0.189 13
Li X 2014 China Asian HB Laryngeal 49 101 60 210 46 97 67 210 0.55 0.333 9
Mirecka A 2014 Poland Caucasian HB Prostate 128 272 221 621 154 368 259 781 0.57 0.260 9
Li XC 2014 China Asian HB Gastric 37 95 85 217 29 93 95 217 0.65 0.414 8
Na N 2015 China Asian HB Breast 161 140 24 325 171 134 20 325 0.27 0.352 10
Paszkowska-Szczur K 2015 Poland Caucasian HB Colorectal 104 221 138 463 242 623 465 1330 0.58 0.189 9
He J 2016 China Asian HB Neuroblastoma 135 93 20 248 307 198 26 531 0.24 0.409 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Colorectal 970 758 173 1901 1023 812 142 1977 0.28 0.266 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 607 445 90 1142 625 461 87 1173 0.27 0.875 11
Li RJ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 57 92 67 216 68 87 61 216 0.48 0.004 7
Wang MY 2016 China Asian HB Prostate 491 433 80 1004 534 440 81 1055 0.29 0.461 10
Bai Y 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 41 98 55 194 32 106 87 225 0.62 0.975 6
rs2296147 T>C
Shao MH 2007 China Asian HB Lung 570 304 52 926 590 358 31 979 0.21 0.008 10
Doherty JA 2011 USA Mixed PB Endometrial 194 356 165 715 199 364 157 720 0.47 0.696 11
Duan Z 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 257 122 24 403 260 132 11 403 0.19 0.232 11
He J 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 700 371 54 1125 742 398 56 1196 0.21 0.779 13
Ma H 2012 USA Caucasian HB SCCHN 280 532 244 1056 294 543 228 1065 0.47 0.440 11
Sakoda LC 2012 USA Caucasian PB Lung 182 385 174 741 407 723 341 1471 0.48 0.565 15
Zhu ML 2012 China Asian HB ESCC 757 305 53 1115 699 368 50 1117 0.21 0.860 13
Yang WG 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 208 105 24 337 196 110 41 347 0.28 <0.001 9
Yang B 2013 China Asian HB Prostate 37 49 143 229 25 46 167 238 0.80 <0.001 8
Na N 2015 China Asian HB Breast 188 104 33 325 199 98 28 325 0.24 0.003 9
Sun Z 2015 China Asian HB NPC 119 177 76 372 111 180 80 371 0.46 0.660 11
Chen YZ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 442 217 33 692 475 264 32 771 0.21 0.535 11
He J 2016 China Asian HB Neuroblastoma 160 79 9 248 343 170 18 531 0.19 0.583 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Colorectal 1169 644 88 1901 1213 692 72 1977 0.21 0.027 9
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 725 364 53 1142 746 388 39 1173 0.20 0.182 11
rs2227869 G>C
Shen M 2005 China Asian PB Lung 103 14 1 118 100 11 0 111 0.05 0.583 11
Garcia-Closas M 2006 Spain Caucasian HB Bladder 1050 91 2 1143 1046 90 0 1136 0.04 0.164 12
Huang WY 2006 USA Caucasian PB Colorectal 598 52 1 651 601 60 1 662 0.05 0.694 14
Hooker S 2008 USA African HB Prostate 234 20 0 254 274 27 0 301 0.05 0.415 7
Hussain SK 2009 China Asian PB Gastric 174 13 0 187 314 56 3 372 0.08 0.773 13
Ma H 2012 USA Caucasian HB SCCHN 987 70 2 1059 974 90 2 1066 0.04 0.958 11
Sakoda LC 2012 USA Caucasian PB Lung 1 63 680 744 2 110 1362 1474 0.96 0.886 15
Santos LS 2013 Portugal Caucasian HB Thyroid 99 6 1 106 184 27 1 212 0.02 0.993 8
Paszkowska-Szczur K 2013 Poland Caucasian PB Melanoma 567 67 2 636 1168 162 2 1332 0.06 0.137 13
Mirecka A 2014 Poland Caucasian HB Prostate 485 83 3 571 682 99 1 782 0.06 0.181 9
Paszkowska-Szczur K 2015 Poland Caucasian HB Colorectal 372 55 2 429 1168 162 2 1332 0.06 0.137 9
rs2094258 C>T
He J 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 457 518 150 1125 457 560 179 1196 0.62 0.728 13
Ma H 2012 USA Caucasian HB SCCHN 706 295 37 1038 721 291 41 1053 0.82 0.092 11
Yang WG 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 131 149 57 337 145 166 36 347 0.66 0.252 10
Zhu ML 2012 China Asian HB ESCC 414 524 177 1115 424 525 168 1117 0.61 0.793 13
Yang B 2013 China Asian HB Prostate 61 75 93 229 58 75 105 238 0.40 <0.001 9
Na N 2015 China Asian HB Breast 102 157 66 325 131 147 47 325 0.63 0.581 10
Sun Y 2015 China Asian HB Laryngeal 140 106 25 271 152 101 18 271 0.75 0.826 11
Sun Z 2015 China Asian HB NPC 209 68 95 372 211 66 94 371 0.66 <0.001 10
Chen YZ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 287 304 101 692 291 368 112 771 0.62 0.803 11
He J 2016 China Asian HB Neuroblastoma 116 93 39 248 203 254 74 531 0.62 0.701 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Colorectal 797 856 248 1901 899 881 197 1977 0.68 0.378 10
Feng YB 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 15 75 87 177 15 96 127 238 0.26 0.577 6
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 499 508 135 1142 527 524 122 1173 0.67 0.623 11
Lu JJ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 17 67 100 184 13 72 121 206 0.24 0.605 6
Ma SH 2016 China Asian HB Breast 27 136 157 320 15 96 127 238 0.26 0.577 7
Yang LQ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 71 74 10 155 121 111 14 246 0.72 0.076 6
Ying MF 2016 China Asian HB Pancreatic 87 92 16 195 117 115 22 254 0.69 0.400 7
rs751402 C>T
Shao MH 2007 China Asian HB Lung 105 429 433 967 110 425 448 983 0.67 0.544 11
Yoon AJ 2011 Taiwan Asian HB HCC 11 52 33 96 32 137 167 336 0.70 0.614 6
Duan Z 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 47 181 172 400 29 165 206 400 0.72 0.605 11
He J 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 148 491 486 1125 137 499 560 1196 0.68 0.110 13
Zavras AI 2012 Taiwan Mixed HB OSCC 31 110 98 239 32 137 167 336 0.70 0.614 9
Meng X 2013 China Asian HB Salivary gland 11 63 59 133 23 55 64 142 0.64 0.065 8
Na N 2015 China Asian HB Breast 45 152 128 325 41 147 137 325 0.65 0.872 10
Sun Z 2015 China Asian HB NPC 237 118 17 372 235 117 19 371 0.21 0.377 11
Wang H 2016 China Asian HB Breast 1 10 90 101 11 39 51 101 0.70 0.398 9
Chen YZ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 93 313 286 692 89 331 351 771 0.67 0.416 11
He J 2016 China Asian HB Neuroblastoma 38 114 96 248 82 241 208 531 0.62 0.380 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Colorectal 248 860 792 1900 301 952 724 1977 0.61 0.680 10
Guo BW 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 22 73 47 142 21 136 117 274 0.68 0.029 5
Feng YB 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 24 83 70 177 28 107 101 236 0.65 0.967 6
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 161 555 426 1142 189 551 433 1173 0.60 0.537 11
Li RJ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 22 106 88 216 18 103 95 216 0.68 0.174 8
Lu JJ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 24 91 69 184 22 97 87 206 0.66 0.510 6
Ma SH 2016 China Asian HB Breast 43 150 127 320 28 101 107 236 0.67 0.580 7
Yang LQ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 33 73 49 155 32 111 103 246 0.64 0.807 6
Wang MY 2016 China Asian HB Prostate 104 458 442 1004 111 467 477 1055 0.67 0.834 10
Zhou RM 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 61 196 174 431 46 193 193 432 0.67 0.827 12
rs873601 G>A
Shao MH 2007 China Asian HB Lung 260 493 220 973 277 494 217 988 0.47 0.907 11
He J 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 274 560 291 1125 327 605 264 1196 0.47 0.616 13
Ma H 2012 USA Caucasian HB SCCHN 66 427 565 1058 83 411 572 1066 0.73 0.445 11
Sakoda LC 2012 USA Caucasian PB Lung 51 299 392 742 107 584 783 1474 0.73 0.894 15
Yang WG 2012 China Asian HB Gastric 96 163 78 337 91 164 91 346 0.50 0.333 10
Zhu ML 2012 China Asian HB ESCC 314 566 235 1115 311 565 241 1117 0.47 0.601 13
Na N 2015 China Asian HB Breast 99 156 70 325 109 150 66 325 0.43 0.276 10
Zhao F 2015 China Asian HB Pancreatic 105 111 30 246 118 107 21 246 0.30 0.637 8
Chen YZ 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 172 333 187 692 205 396 170 771 0.48 0.415 11
He J 2016 China Asian HB Neuroblastoma 70 112 66 248 137 270 124 531 0.49 0.686 10
Wang B 2016 China Asian HB HCC 163 271 104 538 271 408 214 893 0.47 0.014 12
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Colorectal 476 954 471 1901 550 1025 402 1977 0.46 0.057 10
Hua RX 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 311 557 274 1142 323 598 252 1173 0.47 0.424 11
Zhou RM 2016 China Asian HB Gastric 115 215 101 431 132 200 100 432 0.46 0.152 12

Abbreviations: HB, hospital-based; PB, population-based; PCR-RFLP, polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism; MAF, minor allele frequency; HWE, Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium; HCC, hepatocellular carcinoma; SCCHN, squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck; ESCC, esophageal squamous cell carcinoma; OSCC, oral squamous cell carcinoma; NPC, nasopharyngeal carcinoma.