Table A4:
Results of Deterministic Sensitivity Analyses
| Variable | Estimate (Upper or Lower Bound) | ICER LAAC Device:Apixaban ($/QALY) | ICER LAAC Device:Dabigatran ($/QALY) | ICER LAAC Device:Rivaroxaban ($/QALY) | ICER LAAC Device:Warfarin ($/QALY) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clinical Event Rates and Treatment Costs | |||||
| Device embolization | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 210,109 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 208,268 | |
| Pericardial effusion | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 162,904 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 157,877 | |
| LAAC device implantation | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 176,767 |
| unsuccessful | Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 211,777 |
| Baseline thromboembolic event rate (by CHA2DS2VASc score) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 218,622 |
| Lower | 426,041 | 812,338 | 36,468 | 45,423 | |
| Baseline hemorrhagic stroke rate (by HAS-BLED score) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 240,387 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | |
| Baseline major bleed rate (by HAS-BLED score) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 234,201 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 209,948 | |
| OR of ischemic stroke, LAAC device: warfarin | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated |
| Lower | 71,228 | 82,185 | 14,331 | 28,414 | |
| OR of hemorrhagic stroke, LAAC device: warfarin | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 729,937 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 145,689 | |
| OR of major bleed, LAAC device: warfarin | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 143,707 | |
| Clinical Event Rates and Treatment Costs | |||||
| Probability of fatal, major, moderate, and minor ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke | – | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 290,357 |
| Utilities | |||||
| Myocardial infarction, first year | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 236,296 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 234,130 | |
| Myocardial infarction, second year | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 158,183 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 158,183 | |
| Myocardial infarction, third year | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 163,487 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 163,487 | |
| Stroke | |||||
| Major (1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 218,413 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 218,718 | |
| Major (post–1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 204,385 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 190,735 | |
| Moderate (1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 151,644 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 318,747 | |
| Moderate (post–1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 184,047 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 296,280 | |
| Minor (1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 246,114 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 314,504 | |
| Minor (post–1 month) | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 218,931 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 212,898 | |
| Costs | |||||
| Cost of device | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 270,663 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 154,148 | |
| Physician fees | Upper | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 167,800 |
| Lower | Dominated | Dominated | Dominated | 155,330 | |
Abbreviations: CHADS2DS2VASc, Congestive heart failure, Hypertension, Age ≥ 75 years (2 points), Diabetes mellitus, Stroke or transient ischemic attack symptoms previously (2 points), Vascular disease, Age 65–74 years, Sex category; HAS-BLED, Hypertension, Abnormal renal and liver function, Stroke, Bleeding, Labile international normalized ratios (INRs), Elderly, Drugs or alcohol; ICER, incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; LAAC device, left atrial appendage closure device with delivery system; OR, odds ratio; QALY, quality-adjusted life-year.