Table 3.
Test set | Partner scoring function | Standard model of KGS2 | Variation model 1 | Variation model 2 | Variation model 3 | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Average reduced errorb | Applicable samples | Average reduced errorb | Applicable samples | Average reduced errorb | Applicable samples | Average reduced errorb | Applicable samples | ||
HIV-1 protease (N = 303) |
X-Score | 0.41 | 227 | 0.41 | 227 | −0.11 | 137 | 0.17 | 266 |
ChemPLP | 0.45 | 227 | 0.46 | 227 | −0.12 | 137 | 0.11 | 266 | |
ASP | 0.38 | 227 | 0.36 | 227 | −0.22 | 137 | 0.08 | 266 | |
GoldScore | 0.26 | 227 | 0.25 | 227 | −0.29 | 137 | 0.03 | 266 | |
Carbonic anhydrase 2 (N = 230) |
X-Score | −0.05 | 189 | −0.05 | 189 | 0.25 | 75 | −0.04 | 203 |
ChemPLP | −0.13 | 189 | −0.13 | 189 | 0.25 | 75 | 0.00 | 203 | |
ASP | −0.10 | 189 | −0.10 | 189 | 0.21 | 75 | −0.02 | 203 | |
GoldScore | −0.10 | 189 | −0.09 | 189 | 0.22 | 75 | 0.04 | 203 | |
Beta-secretase 1 (N = 223) |
X-Score | 0.12 | 162 | 0.12 | 162 | −0.09 | 9 | −0.04 | 184 |
ChemPLP | 0.13 | 162 | 0.13 | 162 | −0.15 | 9 | −0.07 | 184 | |
ASP | 0.14 | 162 | 0.14 | 162 | −0.04 | 9 | −0.07 | 184 | |
GoldScore | 0.29 | 162 | 0.30 | 162 | 0.45 | 9 | 0.03 | 184 | |
Beta-Trypsin (N = 196) |
X-Score | 0.33 | 157 | 0.33 | 157 | 0.37 | 66 | 0.05 | 164 |
ChemPLP | 0.47 | 157 | 0.46 | 157 | 0.55 | 66 | 0.24 | 164 | |
ASP | 0.43 | 157 | 0.44 | 157 | 0.57 | 66 | 0.26 | 164 | |
GoldScore | 0.59 | 157 | 0.60 | 157 | 0.71 | 66 | 0.39 | 164 | |
Checkpoint kinase 1 (N = 61) |
X-Score | 0.00 | 37 | 0.00 | 37 | −0.67 | 3 | −0.10 | 48 |
ChemPLP | 0.00 | 37 | 0.00 | 37 | −0.71 | 3 | −0.00 | 48 | |
ASP | 0.05 | 37 | 0.04 | 37 | −0.70 | 3 | 0.06 | 48 | |
GoldScore | −0.01 | 37 | −0.01 | 37 | −0.61 | 3 | 0.07 | 48 |
aThe similarity cutoff used in reference selection was 0.35 for all models listed in this table
bAverage reduced error (in logK a units) after application of KGS2, e.g. error by X-Score minus error by X-Score + KGS2. This value was computed among all applicable samples at the given similarity cutoff