Table 1. DBS effects on non-motor symptoms as a whole and non-motor fluctuations in PD patients.
Author | Year | Outcome measure | Type of study | No. of patients | Main outcome after bilateral STN DBS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dafsari et al.33 | 2016 | Primary: NMS as a whole NMSS: 9 domains NMSQuest PDQ-8 | Multicenter, open, 6-month prospective study | 60 | Overall NMSS improved, showing significant improvement in 4 domains: sleep/fatigue, perceptual problems/hallucinations, urinary and miscellaneous. |
Wolz et al.24 | 2012 | Primary: NMS as a whole Semi-structured questionnaire VAS | Cross-sectional study | 34 | No major immediate effects on frequencies, but improves severity of most NMS, particularly psychiatric symptoms (depression, anxiety, and fatigue). |
Reich et al.21 | 2011 | Primary: NMS as a whole NMSS | 3–6 months prospective study | 10 | Shows holistic and selective beneficial effect on aspects of NMS. Especially on 5 particular domains: sleep, mood/cognition, urinary, sexual, and miscellaneous. Other domains show no change. |
Nazzaro et al.22 | 2011 | Primary: NMS as a whole NMSQuest, PDQ-39 | 1-year prospective study | 24 | NMS decreased significantly when assessed with a NMSQuest and significant improvement in QoL. |
Zibetti et al.71 | 2007 | Primary: NMS as a whole Clinical Interview | 12–24 months prospective study | 36 | Ameliorates sleep and constipation. |
Ortega-Cubero et al.27 | 2013 | Primary: NMF Questionnaire | 2-year prospective study | 20 | NMF severity and frequency related to the off-state were reduced. |
Witjas et al. 26 | 2007 | Primary: NMF Questionnaire | 1-year prospective study | 40 | Alleviation of NMF seen, with significant positive effects on sensory, dysautonomic, and cognitive fluctuations. Less consistent in psychic response. |
Abbreviations: DBS, deep brain stimulation; NMS, non-motor symptoms; NMF, non-motor fluctuations; NMSS, Non-Motor Symptoms Scale; NMSQuest, non-motor symptoms questionnaire; QoL, quality of life; PD, Parkinson’s disease; VAS, Visual Analog Scale; PDQ, Parkinson’s disease questionnaire.