Table 4.
Conventional drought response indices of genotypes under moderate and severe stress conditions
| Breeding line | Moderate stress | Severe stress | ||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| REI | MRP | STI | GMP | DYI | TOL | SSI | SSSI | REI | MRP | STI | GMP | DYI | TOL | SSI | SSSI | |
| Annada | 1.005 (25) | 2.015 (24) | 0.70 (25) | 3.46 (25) | 1.43 (3) | 1.25 (3) | 1.00 (3) | −0.122 (3) | 1.083 (23) | 3.09 (23) | 0.33 (23) | 2.62 (23) | 2.49 (12) | 2.48 (9) | 0.91(12) | −0.062 (12) |
| ARB 2 | 1.085 (13) | 2.092 (13) | 0.75 (13) | 3.59 (13) | 1.45 (5) | 1.35 (6) | 1.03 (5) | −0.113 (5) | 1.203 (17) | 3.20 (17) | 0.36 (21) | 2.72 (21) | 2.53 (14) | 2.62 (13) | 0.92 (14) | −0.056 (14) |
| ARB 3 | 1.214 (4) | 2.206 (3) | 0.84 (4) | 3.80 (4) | 1.61 (18) | 1.82 (19) | 1.25 (18) | −0.046 (18) | 1.439 (6) | 3.39 (7) | 0.43 (8) | 2.97 (8) | 2.63 (16) | 2.99 (19) | 0.94 (16) | −0.04 (16) |
| ARB 4 | 0.980 (27) | 1.983 (27) | 0.68 (27) | 3.41 (27) | 1.57 (11) | 1.54 (11) | 1.20 (11) | −0.063 (11) | 1.180 (19) | 3.19 (19) | 0.38 (18) | 2.82 (18) | 2.30 (7) | 2.41 (7) | 0.86 (7) | −0.095 (7) |
| ARB 5 | 1.022 (23) | 2.031 (21) | 0.71 (23) | 3.49 (23) | 1.44 (4) | 1.29 (5) | 1.02 (4) | −0.117 (4) | 1.250 (13) | 3.25 (13) | 0.38 (19) | 2.81 (19) | 2.22 (5) | 2.30 (4) | 0.83 (5) | −0.111 (5) |
| ARB 6 | 1.054 (17) | 2.054 (17) | 0.73 (17) | 3.54 (17) | 1.72 (25) | 1.94 (22) | 1.38 (25) | −0.007 (25) | 1.179 (20) | 3.17 (20) | 0.39 (16) | 2.83 (16) | 2.69 (18) | 2.91 (17) | 0.95 (18) | −0.032 (18) |
| ARB 7 | 1.070 (14) | 2.080 (14) | 0.74 (14) | 3.57 (14) | 1.41 (2) | 1.24 (2) | 0.97 (2) | −0.133 (2) | 1.417 (7) | 3.40 (5) | 0.42 (10) | 2.94 (10) | 2.07 (3) | 2.19 (1) | 0.78 (3) | −0.143 (3) |
| ARB 8 | 1.261 (1) | 2.265 (1) | 0.88 (1) | 3.87 (1) | 1.33 (1) | 1.12 (1) | 0.83 (1) | −0.173 (1) | 1.786 (1) | 3.68 (1) | 0.47 (1) | 3.13 (1) | 2.05 (2) | 2.29 (3) | 0.77 (2) | −0.149 (1) |
| Baranideep | 1.115 (9) | 2.114 (9) | 0.77 (9) | 3.64 (9) | 1.60 (17) | 1.74 (18) | 1.25 (17) | −0.047 (17) | 1.199 (18) | 3.19 (18) | 0.37 (20) | 2.77 (20) | 2.78 (21) | 2.95 (18) | 0.97 (21) | −0.02 (21) |
| CB 0-15-24 | 1.066 (15) | 2.070 (15) | 0.74 (15) | 3.56 (15) | 1.51 (8) | 1.48 (10) | 1.12 (8) | −0.085 (8) | 1.388 (9) | 3.37 (8) | 0.43 (9) | 2.97 (9) | 2.18 (4) | 2.37 (6) | 0.82 (4) | −0.12 (4) |
| CB 2-458 | 0.939 (32) | 1.941 (31) | 0.65 (32) | 3.34 (32) | 1.94 (32) | 2.26 (32) | 1.61 (32) | 0.060 (32) | 0.852 (28) | 2.85 (28) | 0.32 (26) | 2.55 (26) | 3.32 (27) | 3.25 (27) | 1.06 (27) | 0.039 (27) |
| DGI 237 | 0.960 (30) | 1.961 (30) | 0.67 (30) | 3.38 (30) | 1.60 (16) | 1.61 (13) | 1.25 (16) | −0.047 (16) | 0.800 (30) | 2.79 (31) | 0.27 (30) | 2.35 (30) | 3.33 (28) | 2.99 (20) | 1.06 (28) | 0.039 (28) |
| DGI 307 | 1.189 (7) | 2.181 (7) | 0.83 (7) | 3.76 (7) | 1.71 (24) | 2.03 (26) | 1.37 (24) | −0.010 (24) | 1.414 (8) | 3.37 (9) | 0.44 (6) | 3.00 (6) | 2.67 (17) | 3.08 (23) | 0.95 (17) | −0.034 (17) |
| DGI 75 | 1.193 (6) | 2.186 (6) | 0.83 (6) | 3.77 (6) | 1.86 (31) | 2.37 (33) | 1.53 (31) | 0.037 (31) | 1.439 (5) | 3.39 (6) | 0.46 (2) | 3.09 (2) | 2.76 (20) | 3.27 (28) | 0.96 (20) | −0.023 (20) |
| DSL 104-1 | 1.215 (3) | 2.205 (4) | 0.84 (3) | 3.80 (3) | 1.66 (20) | 1.95 (23) | 1.32 (20) | −0.026 (20) | 1.166 (22) | 3.16 (22) | 0.35 (22) | 2.69 (22) | 3.31 (26) | 3.42 (33) | 1.06 (26) | 0.037 (26) |
| DSU 4-7 | 0.939 (31) | 1.939 (32) | 0.65 (31) | 3.34 (31) | 1.83 (29) | 2.05 (27) | 1.51 (29) | 0.030 (29) | 0.843 (29) | 2.84 (29) | 0.30 (27) | 2.50 (27) | 3.26 (25) | 3.14 (24) | 1.05 (25) | 0.033 (25) |
| IR36 | 0.582 (36) | 1.535 (36) | 0.40 (36) | 2.63 (36) | 2.18 (34) | 2.11 (28) | 1.80 (34) | 0.118 (34) | 0.170 (39) | 1.83 (39) | 0.08 (39) | 1.32 (39) | 8.63 (39) | 3.44 (34) | 1.34 (39) | 0.224 (39) |
| IR55419-04 | 1.093 (12) | 2.097 (12) | 0.76 (12) | 3.60 (12) | 1.49 (7) | 1.44 (7) | 1.08 (7) | −0.097 (7) | 1.520 (3) | 3.49 (2) | 0.46 (4) | 3.07 (4) | 2.05 (1) | 2.25 (2) | 0.77 (1) | −0.149 (1) |
| IR64 | 0.900 (33) | 1.917 (33) | 0.63 (33) | 3.27 (33) | 2.31 (35) | 2.81 (35) | 1.88 (35) | 0.142 (35) | 0.598 (33) | 2.58 (33) | 0.25 (33) | 2.26 (33) | 4.85 (33) | 3.94 (37) | 1.20 (33) | 0.133 (33) |
| IR66873-R-11-1 | 0.873 (34) | 1.889 (34) | 0.61 (34) | 3.22 (34) | 2.35 (36) | 2.83 (36) | 1.90 (36) | 0.150 (36) | 0.373 (35) | 2.32 (35) | 0.16 (38) | 1.81 (38) | 7.47 (38) | 4.28 (38) | 1.31 (38) | 0.206 (38) |
| IR67469-R-1-1 | 0.470 (38) | 1.442 (39) | 0.33 (38) | 2.36 (38) | 3.29 (38) | 2.98 (38) | 2.31 (38) | 0.272 (38) | 0.268 (36) | 2.01 (36) | 0.18 (35) | 1.94 (35) | 4.86 (34) | 3.41 (32) | 1.20 (34) | 0.134 (34) |
| IR72667-16-1-B | 1.028 (22) | 2.030 (22) | 0.71 (22) | 3.50 (22) | 1.57 (12) | 1.59 (12) | 1.20 (12) | −0.061 (12) | 1.213 (16) | 3.21 (16) | 0.39 (17) | 2.83 (17) | 2.40 (110 | 2.56 (12) | 0.88 (11) | −0.076 (11) |
| IR74371-3-1-1 | 1.059 (16) | 2.058 (16) | 0.74 (16) | 3.55 (16) | 1.81 (28) | 2.14 (29) | 1.49 (28) | 0.024 (28) | 1.175 (21) | 3.17 (21) | 0.40 (14) | 2.86 (14) | 2.79 (22) | 3.06 (21) | 0.97 (22) | −0.019 (22) |
| IR74371-46-1-1 | 1.040 (19) | 2.040 (19) | 0.72 (19) | 3.52 (19) | 1.77 (27) | 2.03 (25) | 1.44 (27) | 0.010 (27) | 1.236 (15) | 3.23 (15) | 0.42 (12) | 2.93 (12) | 2.55 (15) | 2.84 (16) | 0.92 (15) | −0.052 (15) |
| IR74371-54-1-1 | 1.155 (8) | 2.153 (8) | 0.80 (8) | 3.71 (8) | 1.56 (10) | 1.67 (15) | 1.19 (10) | −0.064 (10) | 1.374 (10) | 3.34 (10) | 0.41 (13) | 2.92 (13) | 2.52 (13) | 2.80 (15) | 0.91 (13) | −0.057 (13) |
| IR74371-70-1-1 | 1.255 (2) | 2.240 (2) | 0.87 (2) | 3.86 (2) | 1.75 (26) | 2.18 (30) | 1.42 (26) | 0.003 (26) | 1.522 (2) | 3.45 (3) | 0.46 (3) | 3.09 (3) | 2.72 (19) | 3.23 (26) | 0.96 (19) | −0.027 (19) |
| IR 74371-78-1-1 | 1.211 (5) | 2.201 (5) | 0.84 (5) | 3.80 (5) | 1.69 (22) | 2.02 (24) | 1.36 (22) | −0.015 (22) | 1.370 (11) | 3.33 (11) | 0.42 (11) | 2.94 (11) | 2.83 (23) | 3.19 (25) | 0.98 (23) | −0.014 (23) |
| Kallurundaikar | 1.006 (24) | 2.006 (26) | 0.70 (24) | 3.46 (24) | 1.70 (23) | 1.86 (20) | 1.37 (23) | −0.012 (23) | 1.278 (12) | 3.28 (12) | 0.43 (7) | 2.98 (7) | 2.30 (8) | 2.55 (11) | 0.86 (8) | −0.095 (8) |
| Khiradhan | 0.997 (26) | 2.010 (25) | 0.69 (26) | 3.44 (26) | 2.18 (33) | 2.75 (34) | 1.79 (33) | 0.117 (33) | 0.494 (34) | 2.51 (34) | 0.19 (34) | 1.97 (34) | 6.65 (37) | 4.32 (39) | 1.29 (37) | 0.189 (37) |
| MTU 1010 | 1.042 (18) | 2.043 (18) | 0.72 (18) | 3.52 (18) | 1.85 (30) | 2.21 (31) | 1.53 (30) | 0.037 (30) | 0.964 (24) | 2.97 (24) | 0.33 (24) | 2.62 (24) | 3.36 (29) | 3.37 (31) | 1.06 (29) | 0.042 (29) |
| NDR 1098-6 | 0.970 (28) | 1.977 (28) | 0.67 (28) | 3.40 (28) | 1.45 (6) | 1.27 (4) | 1.03 (6) | −0.113 (6) | 0.871 (27) | 2.88 (27) | 0.27 (29) | 2.38 (29) | 2.95 (24) | 2.70 (14) | 1.00 (24) | 0.001 (24) |
| PM 1011 | 1.112 (10) | 2.111 (10) | 0.77 (10) | 3.64 (10) | 1.59 (15) | 1.69 (17) | 1.22 (15) | −0.055 (15) | 0.904 (26) | 2.92 (26) | 0.28 (28) | 2.40 (28) | 3.65 (31) | 3.32 (29) | 1.10 (31) | 0.066 (31) |
| PMK 1 | 0.466 (39) | 1.489 (37) | 0.32 (39) | 2.35 (39) | 4.04 (39) | 3.56 (39) | 2.50 (39) | 0.329 (39) | 0.240 (38) | 2.00 (37) | 0.18 (36) | 1.94 (36) | 5.96 (36) | 3.94 (36) | 1.26 (36) | 0.172 (36) |
| PMK 2 | 0.483 (37) | 1.449 (38) | 0.34 (37) | 2.40 (37) | 3.09 (37) | 2.85 (37) | 2.24 (37) | 0.253 (37) | 0.242 (37) | 1.95 (38) | 0.16 (37) | 1.81 (37) | 5.45 (35) | 3.44 (35) | 1.24 (35) | 0.156 (35) |
| Poornima | 0.856 (35) | 1.853 (35) | 0.59 (35) | 3.19 (35) | 1.57 (13) | 1.46 (8) | 1.21 (13) | −0.060 (13) | 0.930 (25) | 2.94 (25) | 0.32 (25) | 2.59 (25) | 2.39 (10) | 2.33 (5) | 0.88 (10) | −0.079 (10) |
| R 1027-2282-2-1 | 1.028 (21) | 2.028 (23) | 0.71 (21) | 3.50 (21) | 1.69 (21) | 1.86 (21) | 1.36 (21) | −0.015 (21) | 0.793 (31) | 2.80 (30) | 0.26 (32) | 2.33 (32) | 3.83 (32) | 3.36 (30) | 1.12 (32) | 0.078 (32) |
| RF 5329 | 1.035 (20) | 2.039 (20) | 0.72 (20) | 3.51 (20) | 1.52 (9) | 1.48 (9) | 1.13 (9) | −0.082 (9) | 1.245 (14) | 3.24 (14) | 0.39 (15) | 2.83 (15) | 2.33 (9) | 2.47 (8) | 0.86 (9) | −0.09 (9) |
| RR 272-21 | 0.967 (29) | 1.968 (29) | 0.67 (29) | 3.39 (29) | 1.63 (19) | 1.67 (16) | 1.28 (19) | −0.038 (19) | 0.791 (32) | 2.79 (32) | 0.26 (31) | 2.34 (31) | 3.43 (30) | 3.07 (22) | 1.07 (30) | 0.048 (30) |
| Tripuradhan | 1.104 (11) | 2.104 (11) | 0.77 (11) | 3.62 (11) | 1.58 (14) | 1.67 (14) | 1.21 (14) | −0.058 (14) | 1.455 (4) | 3.42 (4) | 0.45 (5) | 3.04 (5) | 2.24 (6) | 2.52 (10) | 0.84 (6) | −0.107 (6) |
REI = relative efficiency index, MRP = mean relative performance, STI = stress tolerance index, GMP = geometric mean productivity, DYI = drought yield index, TOL = tolerance index, SSI = stress susceptibility index, SSSI = Schneider’s stress susceptibility index.
The numbers in parentheses indicate the genotype ranks for each index.