Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Bioeth Inq. 2017 Mar 6;14(2):241–250. doi: 10.1007/s11673-017-9773-1

Table 2.

Consultation characteristics of unrepresented patients with ethics consultations (n=25)

Case Primary ethics committee role Final decision maker(s) Decision Identify of possible SDM
1 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker Limit or withdraw LST Uncle
2 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker Limit or withdraw LST Sibling
3 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker, EC Limit or withdraw LST Friend
4 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Physician*, EC DNR/DNI Friend
5 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Physician Limit or withdraw LST Adult child
6 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker, EC Limit or withdraw LST Friend
7 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker Continue LST Previously not identified legal guardian
8 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker, EC Limit or withdraw LST Friend
9 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker DNR/DNI Sibling
10 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker, EC Limit or withdraw LST Friend
11 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker Continue LST Adult child
12 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Physician Limit or withdraw LST Sibling
13 Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker Substitute decision- maker Continue LST Friend
14 Contacted previous providers Physician Limit or withdraw LST n/a
15 Contacted previous providers Physician, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
16 Contacted previous providers Physician, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
17 Found ACP documents ACP documents Limit or withdraw LST n/a
18 Found ACP documents ACP documents, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
19 Identified best interest standard Physician Continue LST n/a
20 Identified best interest standard Physician, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
21 Identified best interest standard Physician Limit or withdraw LST n/a
22 Identified best interest standard Physician, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
23 Made treatment recommendation Physician Limit or withdraw LST n/a
24 Made treatment recommendation Physician, EC Limit or withdraw LST n/a
25 Recommended reassessment of capacity Patient DNR/DNI n/a
*

Refers to the patient’s attending physician

EC = ethics consultants; ACP = advance care planning; DNR = do not resuscitate; DNI = do not intubate; LST = life-sustaining treatment; SDM = substitute decision maker.