Table 2.
Case | Primary ethics committee role | Final decision maker(s) | Decision | Identify of possible SDM |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | Limit or withdraw LST | Uncle |
2 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | Limit or withdraw LST | Sibling |
3 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | Friend |
4 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Physician*, EC | DNR/DNI | Friend |
5 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Physician | Limit or withdraw LST | Adult child |
6 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | Friend |
7 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | Continue LST | Previously not identified legal guardian |
8 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | Friend |
9 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | DNR/DNI | Sibling |
10 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | Friend |
11 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | Continue LST | Adult child |
12 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Physician | Limit or withdraw LST | Sibling |
13 | Evaluated possible substitute decision-maker | Substitute decision- maker | Continue LST | Friend |
14 | Contacted previous providers | Physician | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
15 | Contacted previous providers | Physician, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
16 | Contacted previous providers | Physician, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
17 | Found ACP documents | ACP documents | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
18 | Found ACP documents | ACP documents, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
19 | Identified best interest standard | Physician | Continue LST | n/a |
20 | Identified best interest standard | Physician, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
21 | Identified best interest standard | Physician | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
22 | Identified best interest standard | Physician, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
23 | Made treatment recommendation | Physician | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
24 | Made treatment recommendation | Physician, EC | Limit or withdraw LST | n/a |
25 | Recommended reassessment of capacity | Patient | DNR/DNI | n/a |
Refers to the patient’s attending physician
EC = ethics consultants; ACP = advance care planning; DNR = do not resuscitate; DNI = do not intubate; LST = life-sustaining treatment; SDM = substitute decision maker.