Agarose |
thermal crosslinking at 26–30 °C, extruded agarose solidifies by bioprinting onto a surface of which temperature is lower than the thermal crosslinking temperature |
simple and non-toxic crosslinking process, good mechanical properties, and stability of printed construct |
not degradable, poor cell adhesion, impaired cell viability due to high temperature to dissolve agarose |
bone marrow stem cells(BMSC), adipose stem cells (ASC) |
[75,76,77] |
[78] |
Alginate |
ionic crosslinking with divalent cations |
rapid gelation, high printability, biocompatible, good stability, and integrality of printed construct |
poor cell adhesion, this disadvantage can be overcome by modifying alginate with arginyl glycyl aspartic acid, Collagen type I or oxygenation |
BMSC, ASC, chondrocytes |
[79,80,81] |
[82] |
Methylcellulose |
thermal crosslinking below 37 °C, silanized hydroxypropyl methylcellulose can be synthesized to be crosslinked by changing pH |
good printability, biocompatibility |
partially degrade when culturing in cell culture media and therefore not suitable for long-term culturing |
chondrocytes |
[83,84,85] |
[35] |
Chitosan |
ionic or covalent crosslinking |
biocompatibility, antibacterial |
slow gelation rate and poor mechanical properties without modification |
BMSC |
[86,87,88] |
[89] |
Gellan gum |
thermal crosslinking or ionic crosslinking with divalent cation |
biocompatible, high printability |
poor cellular adhesion |
ASC, nasal chondrocytes |
[90,91,92] |
[93,94] |
Hyaluronic acid |
ionic or covalent crosslinking, functionalized with methacrylate to be photocrosslinkable |
promote cell proliferation, fast gelation, high printability with suitable modification, have lubricating properties |
fast degradation, poor mechanical properties and stability without modification |
BMSC, chondrocytes, fibroblasts |
[95,96,97,98] |
[99] |
Gelatin |
thermal crosslinking, photocrosslinkable polymers can be obtained by functionalization withmethacrylamide side groups to make it stable at 37 °C |
biocompatibility, high cell adhesion support cell viability and proliferation |
poor mechanical properties and stability, low printability |
BMSC, fibroblasts, chondrocytes |
[100,101,102] |
[69,72,103] |
Collagen |
pH crosslinking (7–7.4) at 37 °C or thermal crosslinking |
biocompatibility, high cell adhesion, promote cell proliferation and serve as a signal transducer, high printability |
low gelation rate, poor mechanical properties and stability |
BMSC, fibroblasts, chondrocytes |
[104,105,106] |
[107,108] |
Fibrin |
enzymatic crosslinking, gels when combining fibrinogen, Ca2+ and thrombin at room temperature |
biocompatibility, high cell adhesion, rapid gelation |
limited printability and poor mechanical properties |
BMSC, chondrocytes |
[109] |
[110,111,112] |
Matrigel |
irreversible thermal crosslinking at 24–37 °C |
biocompatibility, support cell viability and differentiation, high printability |
slow gelation and poor stability |
BMSC, chondrocytes |
[113,114] |
[115] |
Pluronic® F127 |
thermal crosslinking |
biocompatibility, high printability, support cell viability |
weak stability and mechanical properties, fast degradation, slow gelation |
BMSC, fibroblasts |
[74,116,117] |
[118] |
Poly(ethylene glycol) |
radiation crosslinking or free radical polymerization |
biocompatibility, support cell viability, can be easily modified with various functional groups |
poor cellular adhesion, low cell proliferation rate |
BMSC, chondrocytes |
[119,120] |
[121] |