Skip to main content
. 2017 Jul 23;18(7):1597. doi: 10.3390/ijms18071597

Table 2.

Toolkit of bio-ink formulation.

Materials Crosslinking Advantages Disadvantages Encapsulated Cells References in Other Techniques References in Bioprinting
Agarose thermal crosslinking at 26–30 °C, extruded agarose solidifies by bioprinting onto a surface of which temperature is lower than the thermal crosslinking temperature simple and non-toxic crosslinking process, good mechanical properties, and stability of printed construct not degradable, poor cell adhesion, impaired cell viability due to high temperature to dissolve agarose bone marrow stem cells(BMSC), adipose stem cells (ASC) [75,76,77] [78]
Alginate ionic crosslinking with divalent cations rapid gelation, high printability, biocompatible, good stability, and integrality of printed construct poor cell adhesion, this disadvantage can be overcome by modifying alginate with arginyl glycyl aspartic acid, Collagen type I or oxygenation BMSC, ASC, chondrocytes [79,80,81] [82]
Methylcellulose thermal crosslinking below 37 °C, silanized hydroxypropyl methylcellulose can be synthesized to be crosslinked by changing pH good printability, biocompatibility partially degrade when culturing in cell culture media and therefore not suitable for long-term culturing chondrocytes [83,84,85] [35]
Chitosan ionic or covalent crosslinking biocompatibility, antibacterial slow gelation rate and poor mechanical properties without modification BMSC [86,87,88] [89]
Gellan gum thermal crosslinking or ionic crosslinking with divalent cation biocompatible, high printability poor cellular adhesion ASC, nasal chondrocytes [90,91,92] [93,94]
Hyaluronic acid ionic or covalent crosslinking, functionalized with methacrylate to be photocrosslinkable promote cell proliferation, fast gelation, high printability with suitable modification, have lubricating properties fast degradation, poor mechanical properties and stability without modification BMSC, chondrocytes, fibroblasts [95,96,97,98] [99]
Gelatin thermal crosslinking, photocrosslinkable polymers can be obtained by functionalization withmethacrylamide side groups to make it stable at 37 °C biocompatibility, high cell adhesion support cell viability and proliferation poor mechanical properties and stability, low printability BMSC, fibroblasts, chondrocytes [100,101,102] [69,72,103]
Collagen pH crosslinking (7–7.4) at 37 °C or thermal crosslinking biocompatibility, high cell adhesion, promote cell proliferation and serve as a signal transducer, high printability low gelation rate, poor mechanical properties and stability BMSC, fibroblasts, chondrocytes [104,105,106] [107,108]
Fibrin enzymatic crosslinking, gels when combining fibrinogen, Ca2+ and thrombin at room temperature biocompatibility, high cell adhesion, rapid gelation limited printability and poor mechanical properties BMSC, chondrocytes [109] [110,111,112]
Matrigel irreversible thermal crosslinking at 24–37 °C biocompatibility, support cell viability and differentiation, high printability slow gelation and poor stability BMSC, chondrocytes [113,114] [115]
Pluronic® F127 thermal crosslinking biocompatibility, high printability, support cell viability weak stability and mechanical properties, fast degradation, slow gelation BMSC, fibroblasts [74,116,117] [118]
Poly(ethylene glycol) radiation crosslinking or free radical polymerization biocompatibility, support cell viability, can be easily modified with various functional groups poor cellular adhesion, low cell proliferation rate BMSC, chondrocytes [119,120] [121]