Table 4.
Experimentally determined bilayer bending moduli from Figure 2 expressed as a percent difference from the simulation values, , and the corresponding literature references.
Bilayer | Flicker | Pipette Asp. | ED | X-ray | NSE | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KC% | T | Ref. | KC% | T | Ref. | KC% | T | Ref. | KC% | T | Ref. | KC% | T | Ref. | |
POPC | 57 | 25 | [12] | −76 −44 |
22 24 |
[14] [73] |
−19 | 30 | [66] | −23 | 22 | [19] | |||
DLPC | −34 | 24 | [74] | −77 | 22 | [14] | −63 | 30 | [68] | ||||||
DPPC | 0 | 50 | [74] | −56 | 50 | [75] | −71 | 60 | [18] | ||||||
SOPC | 17 17 2 |
24 24 24 |
[9] [76] [76] |
17 44 |
18 25 |
[11] [13] |
−70 | 21 | [73] | −17 | 30 | [69] | |||
DOPC | 42 | 23 | [15] | 15 | 18 | [11] | 20 −18 −78 |
23 23 21 |
[15] [73] [73] |
2 | 30 | [71] | |||
DEPC | 7 | 18 | [11] | ||||||||||||
TOCL | 25 | 30 | [52] | ||||||||||||
DMPC | −11 | 30 | [74] | −63 | 29 | [11] | −51 | 30 | [68] | −60 | 28 | [18] | |||
DLiPC | −33 | 18 | [11] |
Shown also are the respective temperatures (T) of the experimental measurements in units of Celsius. Note that in the calculation all experimental values have been rounded from those reported in the original publications. The different techniques are designated as follows: Flicker – flicker spectroscopy; Pipette Asp. – pipette aspiration; ED – electrodeformation; X-ray – low angle diffuse X-ray scattering; NSE – neutron spin-echo.