Table 1.
Characteristics of studies on telerehabilitation reviewed.
| First author, date, reference | Type of article | Rehabilitation area | Sample size | Article key points | Positive aspects | Barriers and limitations |
| Ackerman, 2010 [1] | Original research | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | Next-generation telehealth tools | Devices are available at home; electronic health record available for each person; interaction of multiple systems. | People and technological systems are not ready (data flow and incompatibility between telerehabilitation systems). |
| Rogante, 2010 [2] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | Overview of telerehabilitation literature | Provides some techniques at a distance. | Health care providers are not ready; comprehensive studies are lacking. |
| Zampolini, 2008 [3] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | Overview of telerehabilitation literature and a study | The possibilities of using telerehabilitation as standard in the future. | Technologies, patients, and health care providers are not ready. |
| Carey, 2007 [4] | Original research | Physiotherapy | Literature review | Cortical reorganization after stroke | Telerehabilitation may be effective in improving performance in patients with chronic stroke. | No clear advantage produced over the same amount of practice of random movements. |
| Parmanto, 2008 [5] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | Telerehabilitation from informatics perspective | Information technology and telerehabilitation are the future. | Health care providers are not ready to manage an everyday telerehabilitation approach. |
| Mani, 2016 [6] | Review article | Physiotherapy | Literature review | Telerehabilitation in musculoskeletal disorders | Telerehabilitation-based physiotherapy assessment is technically feasible. | Telerehabilitation-based physiotherapy assessment was not feasible or reliable for lumbar spine posture, orthopedic special tests, neurodynamic tests, and scar assessment. |
| Gal, 2015 [7] | Original research | Physiotherapy | Literature review | Kinect-based system in physiotherapy | Kinect can greatly help people in rehabilitation. | Not present. |
| Jagos, 2015 [8] | Clinical trial | Cardiac rehabilitation | 5 patients | Rehabilitation after stroke | The system used could be used for further analysis. | Not present. |
| Keshner, 2007 [9] | Original research | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | VRaas a treatment intervention | VR should be used more in the future. | People are not ready. |
| Larson, 2014 [10] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | VR treatment | VR is effectively used for telerehabilitation. | Further studies are needed to optimize the techniques. |
| Kenyon, 2004 [11] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | VR treatment | The virtual environment can be a valuable tool for therapeutic interventions that require adaptation to complex, multimodal environments. | Not present. |
| Lewis, 1997 [12] | Review article | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | VR treatment and human factors | VR has many potentialities in health care. | Some users experienced adverse effects during and after exposure to VR environments (ocular problems, disorientation and balance disturbances, and nausea). |
| Burdea, 2013 [13] | Case study | Physiotherapy and neurological rehabilitation | Literature review | Cerebral palsy motor control improvement | Game-based robotic training of the ankle benefits gait in children with cerebral palsy. | Additional studies are needed to quantify the level of benefit and for comparing different approaches. |
| Busch, 2009 [14] | Clinical trial | Cardiac rehabilitation | 4 patients | Electrocardiography, blood pressure, and oxygen saturation in cardiac patients | The system shown is acceptable. | Electrocardiogram connection (27%) and blood pressure reading problems (23%); more reliability is needed. |
| Dinesen, 2012 [15] | Case study | Multiple rehabilitation areas | 60 patients | Telehealth in pulmonary disease patients | Not present. | Future work requires large-scale studies of prolonged home monitoring with more extended follow-up. |
| Giansanti, 2013 [18] | Original research | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | Validation of a portable care system | Very low costs compared with optoelectronic solutions and other portable solutions; very high accuracy, also for patients with imbalance problems; good compatibility with any rehabilitative tool. | Not present. |
| Kairy, 2016 [19] | Clinical trial | Physiotherapy | 104 patients | Upper limb through VR | This approach can enhance continuity of care once patients are discharged from rehabilitation. | Not present. |
| Myers, 2003 [20] | Original research | Cardiac rehabilitation | Literature review | Cardiology overview | Not present. | Not present. |
| Piotrowicz, 2012 [21] | Clinical trial | Cardiac rehabilitation | 75 patients | Home-based cardiac rehabilitation in heart failure patients | The system used is reliable. | Further studies are required. |
| Fletcher, 2001 [22] | Original research | Cardiac rehabilitation | Literature review | Exercise standards for testing and training | Not present. | Not present. |
| Piotrowicz, 2010 [23] | Clinical trial | Cardiac rehabilitation | 152 patients | Home-based telemonitoring system | The system is effective and usable. | Not present. |
| Rose, 2005 [24] | Review article | Neurological rehabilitation | Literature review | VR in brain damage | VR has the potential to assist current rehabilitation techniques and will be an integral part of cognitive assessment and rehabilitation in the future. | Brain damage rehabilitation is still a relatively undeveloped field. |
| Satava, 1995 [25] | Original research | Multiple rehabilitation areas | Literature review | VR | Not present. | Not present. |
| Rizzo, 2005 [26] | Original research | Neurological rehabilitation | Literature review | VR, brain, and therapy | VR has many potentialities in medicine. | VR rehabilitation is still in an early phase of development characterized by successful proof of concept. |
| Linder, 2015 [27] | Clinical Trial | Neurological rehabilitation | 99 patients | Improving quality of life and depression after stroke | A robot-assisted intervention may be a valuable approach for improving quality of life. | Not present. |
| Holst, 2017 [28] | Original research | Neurological rehabilitation | Literature review | Depression treatment | Internet-mediated cognitive behavioral therapy is an attractive alternative for some, but not all, patients with depression in primary care. | Lack of face-to-face meeting and human contact. |
| Vaughan, 2016 [29] | Review article | Neurological rehabilitation | Literature review | State-of-the-art of VR | VR could be used to treat neurological patients. | Not present. |
aVR: virtual reality.