Table 1.
Treatment modality for BVFP | Indication | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|
Tracheostomy | Acute dyspnea; temporary management of BVFP | Immediate relief of airway obstruction; greater improvement of ventilation compared to static procedures; no revision surgery required | Destructive of normal tissues; psychosocial impairment; scar formation; daily care of open wound required; decreased quality of life |
Arytenoidectomy | Permantant management of BVFP; patients who want to be decannulated or avoid tracheostomy | Quick, effective enlargement of glottis to return breathing through mouth without dyscosmesis; can be combined with cordotomy; more cost-effective than tracheostomy | Irreversible; deterioration of voice; scar or granuloma formation; aspiration; may need revision surgery |
Cordotomy | Permantant management of BVFP; patients who want to be decannulated or avoid tracheostomy | Quick, effective enlargement of glottis to return breathing through mouth without dyscosmesis; can be combined with arytenoidectomy; more cost-effective than tracheostomy; less tendency for aspiration than arytenoidectomy | Irreversible; deterioration of voice; scar or granuloma formation; aspiration; may need revision surgery |
Laterofixation | Temporary management of the airway, with expectation of recovery of laryngeal function or avoidance of tracheostomy | Reversible; alternative to tracheostomy; greater improvement of airway, better voice quality, and less revision rate than arytenoidectomy and cordotomy; may be performed with other endoscopic procedures | Complications such as hoarseness, need for adjustment, remedialization, dysphagia or aspiration |
Reinnervation | Patients that have non-atrophic viable muscles maintained through synkinetic reinnervation | A promising procedure that may allow return of spontaneous vocal fold abduction; non-distructive and doesn’t impair adductory functions | Technically more difficult; human trials are limited; potential diaphragmatic paralysis |
Laryngeal pacing | Patients that have non-atrophic viable muscles maintained through synkinetic reinnervation | Greater ventilatory improvement reported than any other approach; no compromise of voice or swallowing | Still experimental with only 2 human trials; complicated procedure; more expensive than enlargement or lateralization approaches; device has to be replaced every 5–10 years |
Botox injection | Temporary management of synkinetic larynx | Less invasive; short-term improvement in ventilation; little effect on voice or swallowing | Repeated injections are required; human trials are limited |
Neuromodulation | Recently injured RLNs; muscles still denervated and nerve regenerating prior to synkinetic reinnervation | From canine studies, electrical neuromuscular conditioning promotes selective reinnervation of muscles, minimizes synkinesis and restores ventilation to normal | Experimental; no human trial |
Gene therapy | BVFP caused by neurodegenerative diseases | Less invasive; could promote nerve regeneration and prevent muscle atrophy | Experimental; no human trial; not effective in preventing synkinesis; neuronal damage by viral vectors |
Stem cell therapy | BVFP caused by neurodegenerative diseases | Could promote nerve regeneration and prevent muscle atrophy | Experimental; no human trial; not effective in preventing synkinesis; issues associated with issolation, culture and survival of stem cells |
BVFP, bilateral vocal fold paralysis; Botox, botulinum toxin; RLN, recurrent laryngeal nerve.