Table 1. Randomized controlled trials of the most widely-studied and commonly-used obesity medications in youth.
Population | Dose | Study Length and Design | Weight Loss a | Attrition | Side Effects | Cost / Month b | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Metformin | |||||||
| |||||||
9 - 18 yr old; Obese; IR n = 12 (drug) ; n = 14 (placebo) |
500 mg (2× / day) |
3 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.01 kg/m2 | 16.2% | None different than placebo | $42.23 | (38) |
10 - 16 yr old; Obese n = 41 (drug) ; n = 42 (placebo) |
500 mg (3× / day) |
12 weeks; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.60 kg/m2 Δ waist circumference = -1.7 cm |
8.9% | Gastrointestinal discomfort and loose stool | $63.34 | (39) |
13 - 18 yr old; Obese; NGT n = 15 (drug); n = 12 (placebo) |
500 mg (3× / day) |
4 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -2.0 kg/m2 Δ body weight = -3.9 kg |
18.0% | Gastrointestinal and stomach discomfort | $63.34 | (40) |
12 - 19 yr old; Obese n = 14 (drug) ; n = 17 (placebo) |
500 mg (2× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.73 kg/m2 | 10.4% | Mild abdominal discomfort and diarrhea | $42.23 | (41) |
12 - 19 yr old; Obese; IR n = 60 (drug) ; n = 25 (placebo) |
850 mg (2× / day) C |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.79 kg/m2 | 24.0% | Gastrointestinal discomfort | $72.00 | (42) |
9 - 18 yr old; Obese n = 28 (randomized) |
1000 mg (2× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC; Crossover | Δ BMI = -1.26 kg/m2 Δ BMI Z-score = -0.12 |
21.5% | None different than placebo | $86.41 | (43) |
10 - 17 yr old; Obese n = 36 (drug) ; n = 34 (placebo) |
500 mg (2× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = +0.38 kg/m2 | 10.0% | None different than placebo | $42.23 | (44) |
6 - 12 yr old; Severe Obesity; IR n = 53 (drug); n = 47 (placebo) |
1000 mg (2× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -1.09 kg/m2 Δ BMI Z-score = -0.07 |
15.0% | Gastrointestinal discomfort | $86.41 | (45) |
8 - 17 yr old; Obese; NAFLD n = 57 (drug); n = 58 (placebo) |
500 mg (2× / day) |
96 weeks; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.60 kg/m2 Δ BMI Z-score = -0.06 |
13.1% | None different than placebo | $42.23 | (46) |
13 - 18 yr old; Obese n = 39 (drug); n = 38 (placebo) |
XR 2000 mg (1× / day) |
52 weeks; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -1.10 kg/m2 Δ BMI Z-score = -0.08 |
26.0% | None different than placebo | $89.40 | (47) |
8 - 18 yr old; Obese; IFG or IGT n = 74 (drug); n = 77 (placebo) |
500 / 1000 mg (2× / day)d |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -1.07 kg/m2 Δ BMI Z-score = -0.1 |
27.0% | Gastrointestinal discomfort | $64.33 | (19) |
7 - 18 yr old; Obese; NGT n = 35 (drug + lifestyle); n = 31 (lifestyle) |
Up to 1000 mg (2× / day) e |
6 months; RCT; Open Label | Δ BMI = -1.30 kg/m2 Δ body weight = -3.2 kg |
36.0% | None different than placebo | $86.41 | (18) |
| |||||||
Orlistat | |||||||
| |||||||
14 - 18 yr old; Overweight n = 20 (drug); n = 20 (placebo) |
120 mg (3× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.50 kg/m2 | 15.0% | Soft stools, oily spotting, oily evacuation, liquid stools | $614.53 | (48) |
12 - 16 yr old; Obesity n = 357 (drug); n = 182 (placebo) |
120 mg (3× / day) |
6 months; RCT; DBPC | Δ BMI = -0.86 kg/m2 Δ waist circumference = -1.45 cm |
3.6% | Gastrointestinal discomfort, oily spotting, oily evacuation | $614.53 | (28) |
| |||||||
Exenatide | |||||||
| |||||||
12 - 19 year old; Severe Obesity n = 12 (drug); n = 10 (placebo) |
10 μg (2× / day) f |
3 months; RCT; DBPC | % change in BMI = - 2.70% Δ body weight = -3.26 kg |
15.0% | Mild: Nausea, abdominal pain, diarrhea, headache, vomiting. | $619.93 | (20) |
8 - 19 year old; Severe Obesity n = 12 (randomized) |
10 μg (2× / day) f |
6 months; Randomized, Crossover Open Label | % change in BMI = - 4.92% Δ body weight = -3.90 kg |
8.3% | Mild: nausea, vomiting, headache, and abdominal pain | $619.93 | (49) |
Abbreviations (order of appearance): IR = insulin resistance; RCT = randomized controlled trial; DBPC = double-blind, placebo-controlled; BMI = body mass index; NGT = normal glucose tolerance; NAFLD = non-alcoholic fatty liver disease; XR = extended release; IFG = impaired fasting glucose; IGT = impaired glucose tolerance
: Weight-loss is placebo/control-subtracted unless otherwise noted.
: Cost / Month is reflective of average wholesale price (AWP) plus dispensing fees.
: Started at 500 mg once daily. At 1 month, the dose increased to 500 mg twice daily, followed by an increase to 850 mg twice daily at 2 months.
: 1000 mg taken 1× / day in the morning, 500 mg taken 1× / day in the evening.
: Initiated at a dose of 250mg (2× / day), then increased to 500 mg (2× / day) and if older than 12 increased to 1000 mg (2×/day) if tolerated.
: Initiated at a dose of 5 μg, subcutaneously, twice per day. After 1 month, exenatide was uptitrated to 10 μg twice per day for the remaining 2 months.