Skip to main content
. 2017 Jul 31;10:1831–1839. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S134745

Table 2.

Included studies

Study Design N (Females) Sample Induction method Target disorder/symptom Outcome
Aslaksen and Lyby3 Mixed design 111 (76) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significantly larger nocebo hyperalgesic effect on pain report in females than in males
Aslaksen et al4 Within subjects design 33 (17) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significant placebo effect on pain unpleasantness and the P2 component in the EEG in males, but not in females
Bjørkedal and Flaten44 Mixed design 23 (7) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significant placebo effect on the P2 component in males, but not in females
Aslaksen and Flaten43 Within subjects design 63 (32) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significant placebo effect on pain intensity in males, but not in females
Flaten et al48 Mixed design 84 (47) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significant placebo effect on pain tolerance in males, but not in females
Butcher and Carmody5 Within subjects design 20 (10) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Significant placebo effect on pain tolerance in males, but not in females
Krummenacher et al52 Between-groups design 49 (23) Healthy volunteers (Children) Verbal information Pain Placebo effect on heat pain threshold in boys and girls, but larger effect in girls compared to boys
Theysohn et al56 Within-subjects design 30 (15) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Placebo effect on pain report in both males and females Significantly larger placebo effect on neural modulation in males compared to females
Colloca et al29 Between-groups design 109 (54) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Pain Placebo response enhanced and cortisol levels decreased significantly by vasopressin in females, but not in males
Swider and Babel6 Between-groups design 84 (42) Healthy volunteers Conditioning Pain Nocebo effect in males and females, but significantly larger nocebo effect on pain report in females than in males
Oken et al22 Between-groups design 40 (20) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Cognitive performance Significant placebo effect on choice reaction time in males, but not in females
Haltia et al23 Within-subjects design 24 (12) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Dopaminergic functioning Significant placebo effect on reported drug effect in females, but not in males
Kelley et al50 Between-groups design 289 (216) Patients with IBS Verbal information IBS symptoms Significantly larger placebo effect on IBS symptoms in females than in males
Klosterhalfen et al24, experiment 1 Within-subjects design 48 (24) Healthy volunteers Conditioning Nausea Significant nocebo effect on rotation tolerance in females, but not in males
Klosterhalfen et al24, experiment 2 Within-subjects design 48 (24) Healthy volunteers Verbal information Nausea Significant nocebo effect on rotation tolerance in males, but not in females
Faasse et al47 Between-groups design 82 (51) Healthy volunteers Conditioning Symptoms associated with intake of an inert medication (participants was informed that the medication was a beta-blocker, but in fact they received a placebo). Significant nocebo effect on total reported symptoms and symptoms attributed to medication in females, but not in males
Lorber et al53 Mixed design 86 (51) Healthy volunteers Conditioning Symptoms associated with inhalation of an inert environmental toxin (participants was informed that the medication was a suspected environmental toxin, but, in fact, it was a placebo) Significant nocebo effect on symptom report in females, but not in males
Abrams and Kushner25 Between-groups design 41 (25) Participants were diagnosed with social phobia Verbal information Mental distress, fear of negative evaluation Significant placebo effect on mental distress in males only

Abbreviations: EEG, electroencephalogram; IBS, irritable bowel syndrome