Table 3.
Measure | BD |
TLE |
Pre- to post- surgical | Laterality effects | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Use in studies, number of participants BD | BD < HC sig | Use in studies, number of participants TLE | sig | ↑ | ↓ | ||
Executive function | |||||||
WCST | 12 studies | 11 | 2 studies | 1 | ↑1 | ||
BD n = 859, healthy controls (HC) n = 676 | Right temporal lobe (RTL) n = 44, left temporal lobe (LTL) n = 49, HC n = 22 | ||||||
COWAT(FAS) | 5 studies | 2 | 2 studies | 2 | ↑1 | Higher score LTL group pre- assoc. with greater impairment post-surg | |
RTL n = 33, LTL n = 38 | |||||||
BD n = 133, HC n = 130 | |||||||
TMT-B | 9 studies | 7 | |||||
BD n = 513, HC = 339 | |||||||
Stroop | 10 studies | 7 | |||||
BD n = 895, HC = 642 | |||||||
Hayling Sentence Completion Test | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 25, HC n = 73 | |||||||
CANTAB: Intra Extra Dimensional Set Shifting | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
CANTAB: Stockings Problem | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
Verbal memory | |||||||
CVLT | 5 studies | 3 | 7 studies | 6 | ↓6 | Post-surg LTL decline 6 | |
BD n = 233, HC n = 153 | RTL n = 158, LTL n = 215, HC n = 10 | RTL > LTL 1 | |||||
RAVLT | 3 studies | 2 | 5 studies | 5 | ↓5 | Post-surg LTL decline 5 | |
BD n = 141, HC = 79 | RTL n = 78, LTL n = 176, HC n = 28 | ||||||
Verbal comprehension: WAIS Vocab | 4 studies | 0 | |||||
BD n = 187, HC n = 173 | |||||||
WMS-R: Logical Memory | 6 studies | 4 | ↑3 | ↓1 | LTL < RTL 1 | ||
RTL n = 206, LTL n = 256, HC n = 28 | |||||||
WMS-R: Verbal Paired Associates | 4 studies | 4 | ↑2 | ↓1 | LTL < RTL 1 | ||
RTL n = 119, LTL n = 151, HC n = 28 | |||||||
Token Test | 2 studies | 1 | ↑1 | Post-surg LTL improved 1 | |||
RTL n = 34, LTL n = 47 | |||||||
VLMT: Verbaler Lern- und Merkfähigkeitstest | 2 studies | 2 | ↓2 | ||||
RTL n = 83, LTL n = 82 | |||||||
Visuospatial memory | |||||||
ROCFT | 2 studies | 0 | 3 studies | 2 | ↑1 | LTL < RTL 1 | |
BD n = 65, HC n = 47 | RTL n = 25, LTL n = 62, HC n = 36 | ||||||
WMS: Visual reproduction | 3 studies | 0 | 2 studies | 0 | |||
BD n = 105, HC n = 78 | RTL n = 27, LTL n = 29 | ||||||
CANTAB: Spatial recognition memory | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
CANTAB: Pattern Recognition Memory | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
CANTAB: Paired Associates Learning | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
WMS-R: Design Memory | 4 studies | 2 | ↑1 | ↓1 | RTL decline 1 | ||
RTL n = 78, LTL n = 93, HC n = 28 | |||||||
WMS-R Visual Reproduction | 5 studies | 2 | ↑1 | ↓1 | RTL decline 1 | ||
RTL n = 241, LTL n = 484, HC n = 28 | |||||||
WMS-III: Face Test | 1 study | 1 | ↓1 | RTL decline 1 | |||
RTL n = 16, LTL n = 10 | |||||||
Graduate Hospital Facial Memory | 3 studies | 3 | ↑1 | RTL < LTL 2 | |||
RTL n = 71, LTL n = 46, HC n = 10 | |||||||
Benton Visual Retention | 2 studies | 0 | |||||
RTL n = 31, LTL n = 72 | |||||||
Diagnosticum für Cerebralschädigung | 3 studies | 2 | ↓1 | ||||
RTL n = 83, LTL n = 253 | |||||||
Spatial ability | |||||||
WAIS: Block design | 4 studies | 0 | |||||
BD n = 124, HC n = 109 | |||||||
Attention span | |||||||
WAIS: Digit Span | 3 studies | 2 | 4 studies | 0 | |||
BD n = 103, HC n = 89 | RTL n = 93, LTL n = 150, HC n = 15 | ||||||
TMT-A (also processing speed) | 10 studies | 8 | |||||
BD n = 513, HC = 339 | |||||||
WAIS: Digit Symbol (also processing speed) | 3 studies | 3 | |||||
BD n = 91, HC = 86 | |||||||
CANTAB: Rapid Visual Information | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
Adult Memory and Information Processing Battery (AMIPB) | 2 studies | 2 | ↑1 | ↓1 | |||
RTL n = 279, LTL n = 334 | |||||||
Sustained attention | |||||||
CPT | 4 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 84, HC n = 84 | |||||||
Working memory | |||||||
SWMT | 2 studies | 0 | |||||
BD n = 30, HC n = 30 | |||||||
N-Back | 2 studies | 0 | |||||
BD n = 45, HC n = 47 | |||||||
WAIS: Letter Number Sequencing | 3 studies | 3 | |||||
BD n = 126, HC n = 126 | |||||||
WMS-III: Letter Number Sequencing | 2 studies | 3 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 | |||||||
CANTAB: Spatial Working Memory | 2 studies | 2 | |||||
BD n = 140, HC n = 78 |
↑ refers to an increase, ↓ a decrease from pre- to post-surgery, sig refers to the number of studies with a significant result, laterality comments only significant main effects or interactions are discussed.