Table 1.
Study or Subgroup | Sinrin-yoku Total |
Control Total |
Weight (%) | Mean Difference IV, Fixed |
95% CI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ogushi et al., 2000 [18] | 37 | 20 | 1.0 | −5.00 | −14.58 - 4.58 |
Takayanagi & Hagihara, 2005 [19] | 12 | 12 | 0.6 | −6.10 | −19.02 - 6.82 |
Tsunetsugu et al., 2007–2 [20] | 11 | * | 3.2 | −6.20 | −11.65 - -0.75 |
Tsunetsugu et al., 2007–1 [20, 40] | 9 | * | 3.3 | −2.50 | −7.87 - 2.87 |
Furuhashi et al., 2007 [22] | 12 | * | 7.8 | −3.90 | −7.37 - -0.43 |
Kozaki et al., 2007–1 [21] | 11 | * | 1.0 | −1.00 | −10.62 - 8.62 |
Kozaki et al., 2007–2 [21] | 11 | * | 1.2 | −1.30 | −7.60 - 10.20 |
Takeda et al., 2009–2 [30–35] | 8 | * | 1.3 | −10.00 | −18.35 - -1.65 |
Takeda et al., 2009–1 [30–35] | 11 | * | 0.5 | 1.10 | −12.64 - 14.84 |
Park et al., 2010–2 [23] | 75 | * | 20.9 | −2.16 | −4.28 - -0.04 |
Park et al., 2010–1 [23] | 268 | * | 35.4 | −2.16 | −3.79 - -0.53 |
Li et al., 2011 [10] | 16 | * | 0.9 | −3.00 | −13.33 - 7.33 |
Lee et al., 2011 [24] | 48 | * | 11.0 | −3.00 | −5.92 - -0.08 |
Kondo et al., 2011a [27, 29] | 8 | * | 2.9 | −4.00 | −9.66 - 1.66 |
Kondo et al., 2011b [28, 29] | 8 | * | 3.4 | −4.00 | −9.23 - 1.23 |
Sung et al., 2012 [25] | 28 | 28 | 1.5 | −8.70 | −16.48 - -0.92 |
Mao et al., 2012 [26] | 12 | 12 | 0.7 | −11.50 | −22.87 - -0.13 |
Kondo et al., 2014–1 [16] | 7 | * | 0.8 | −10.40 | −21.43 - 0.63 |
Kondo et al., 2014–2 [16] | 6 | * | 1.1 | −5.50 | −14.73 - 3.73 |
Lee & Lee, 2014 [11] | 43 | 19 | 1.4 | −12.25 | −20.36 - -4.14 |
Total | 641 | 91** | 100.0 | −3.15 | −4.12 - -2.18 |
CI, confidence interval; df, degrees of freedom
*Cross-over design (same number as in Shinrin-yoku)
**Total number excluding the cross-over design