Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 21;7:9005. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-09382-z

Table 2.

Environmental variables selected using Generalized Additive Models (Rockall Bank and Acesta Wall) or Generalized Linear Models (Coral Wall): Structure from Motion reconstruction (SfM), ROV and AUV multibeam echosounder (MBES). The superscripts indicate the number of samples (n) and folds used. TRI: Terrain Ruggedness Index, TPI: Topographic Position Index, G. Roughness: Gaussian roughness as calculated from CloudCompare, SA Ratio: Surface-Area Ratio, MSE: Mean square error.

Site Model Variables Selected R2 MSE
Abundance  (log + 1) Rockall Bank SfM1 SA Ratio and Slope 0.05 m 0.29 0.89
MBES ROV1 Slope 10 m, Roughness 50 m, Northness 50 m, TRI 05 m and G. Roughness 25 m 0.65 0.74
Coral Wall SfM2 SA Ratio, Slope 0.02 m, G. Roughness 0.02 m and Northness 0.1 m 0.77 0.19
MBES ROV3 ROV TPI 05 m and G. Roughness 25 m 0.39 0.55
MBES AUV3 TPI 50 m 0.23 0.44
Acesta Wall SfM4 Eastness 0.02 m, Slope 0.02 m and Northness 0.05 m 0.55 0.95
MBES ROV5 Slope 10 m, G. Roughness 50 m, Entropy 25 m, Eastness 05 m and Northness 25 m 0.64 0.69
MBES AUV5 Slope 25 m, Entropy 10 m, Northness 10 m and Eastness 05 m 0.63 0.84
Number of Species Rockall Bank SfM1 G. Roughness 0.05 m, Eastness 0.02 m and Slope 0.1 m 0.28 10.49
MBES ROV1 Depth, Eastness 50 m, Northness 5 m and G. Roughness 05 m 0.58 6.06
Coral Wall SfM2 SA Ratio and G. Roughness 0.1 m 0.40 10.44
MBES ROV3 TRI 25 m, G. Roughness 25 m and G. Roughness 10 m 0.51 8.30
MBES AUV3 Not Significant NA NA
Acesta Wall SfM4 G. Roughness 0.05 m, Northness 0.02 m and Eastness 0.05 m 0.64 6.01
MBES ROV5 Slope 25 m, Roughness 25 m, Northness 50 m, G. Roughness 10 m and Northness 10 m 0.71 4.87
MBES AUV5 Slope 10 m, Eastness 10 m, Entropy 10 m and G. Roughness 25 m 0.71 4.82
Diversity (1/D) Rockall Bank SfM1 Eastness 0.1 m, SA Ratio and Northness 0.05 m 0.37 0.03
MBES ROV1 TPI 50 m, Eastness 50 m, Northness 05 m and TRI 25 m 0.44 0.03
Coral Wall SfM2 Slope 0.02 m, G. Roughness 0.02 m And Eastness 0.05 m 0.51 0.02
MBES ROV3 TRI 25 m, Roughness 25 m and Northness 50 m 0.44 0.05
MBES AUV3 Not Significant NA NA
Acesta Wall SfM4 Northness 0.02 m, Slope 0.02 m and Northness 0.1 m 0.35 0.05
MBES ROV5 TRI 05 m, G. Roughness 10 m and TPI 50 m 0.44 0.03
MBES AUV5 Roughness 25 m, Eastness 50 m, TRI 25 m and Depth 0.47 0.03

1n = 94, folds = 5, 2n = 24, folds = 3, 3n = 28, folds = 3, 4n = 225, folds = 10, 5n = 175, folds = 8.