Table 1. Baseline characteristics of the trials included in the meta-analysis.
Study/Year | No. Patients | Male/female | Type of HIE | Main intervention | Treatment | Outcome | Follow-up | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(GM1/Con) | (GM1/Con) | Mild | Moderate | Severe | GM1 Group | Control group | Duration | Measures | (months) | |
Xiang JJ et al 2005 [15] | 36/30 | 20/16 17/13 |
— | 38 | 28 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 7–14 days | ①+②+③+④+⑦ | 12 months |
Lu YD et al 2008 [16] | 44/42 | 29/15 28/14 |
— | 58 | 28 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 20–28 days | ⑤+⑥+⑦ | 12 months |
Sun YF 2009 [17] | 46/43 | NP | — | NP | NP | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 20 days | ①+⑦ | 6 months |
Zeng L 2009 [18] | 40/40 | 23/17 23/17 |
— | 30 | 50 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 7 days | ① | 12 months |
Zhang ZY et al 2009 [19] | 43/40 | 21/22 18/22 |
42 | 33 | 8 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + citicoline + UT | Citicoline + citicoline + UT | 20–30 days | ①+⑤+⑥+⑦ | 6 months |
Zhang B et al 2010 [20] | 42/40 | 23/19 21/19 |
— | 58 | 24 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 14 days | ⑤+⑥+⑦ | 12 months |
Yin FM et al 2010 [21] | 31/30 | 18/13 17/13 |
— | 34 | 27 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 20 days | ⑤+⑥+⑦ | 4 months |
Shi WH 2013 [22] | 46/46 | NP | — | 42 | 50 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 30–60 days | ②+③+④ | 15 months |
Zhang JJ 2013 [23] | 36/34 | 19/17 18/16 |
37 | 28 | 5 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + UT | UT | 14 days | ①+②+③ | 12 months |
Jiang L 2014 [24] | 39/39 | 21/18 22/17 |
17 | 33 | 28 | GM1 20g/d, qd, IV drop + citicoline + UT | Citicoline + citicoline + UT | 14 days | ①+②+③ | 12 months |
Abbreviations: Con, control; NBNA, neonatal behavioral neurological assessment; HIE, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy; NP, not provided; UT, usual therapy; FDP, fructose-1,6-diphosphate GM1, monosialotetrahexosylganglioside; IV, intravenous injection. ①Major neurological disability; ②Cerebral palsy; ③Mental retardation; ④Epilepsy; ⑤Mental development index; ⑥Psychomotive development index; ⑦Neonatal behavioral neurological assessment.