Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 15;67(662):e634–e642. doi: 10.3399/bjgp17X692321
Total cohort
n = 14 610
Patients who completed diaries and where prescribing strategy known
n = 1512


Not given antibiotics Given antibiotics Delayed antibiotics Not given antibiotics Given antibiotics Delayed antibiotics
Clinical assessment

Number in cohort 6057 6089 2464 587 728 197

Severity of sore throat/difficulty swallowing on a 4-point Likert scale, mean (SD) 2.93 (0.72) 3.32 (0.63) 3.06 (0.70) 2.93 (0.68) 3.35 (0.63) 3.01 (0.68)

Severity of all baseline symptomsa on 4-point Likert scale, mean (SD) 1.89 (0.39) 2.19 (0.39) 1.99 (0.40) 1.88 (0.40) 2.21 (0.38) 1.95 (0.36)

Mean FeverPAIN score, mean (SD) 0.33 (0.58) 1.21 (1.09) 0.72 (0.84) 0.26 (0.52) 1.19 (1.11) 0.73 (0.84)

Prior duration in days, mean (SD) 4.96 (6.48) 4.61 (4.10) 4.29 (3.34) 4.75 (4.14) 4.57 (3.39) 4.17 (3.15)

Age in years, mean (SD) 34.72 (15.44) 32.65 (14.18) 34.07 (14.57) 37.61 (15.47) 36.04 (13.85) 35.68 (14.15)

Female sex, n/N (%) 3610/5243 (68.85) 4147/6269 (66.15%) 1770/2501 (70.77%) 443/587 (75.47%) 521/728 (71.57%) 147/197 (74.62%)

Smoker, n/N (%) 1016/5212 (19.49) 1445/6240 (23.16%) 481/2484 (19.36%) 89/594 (15.24%) 127/726 (17.49%) 22/194 (11.34%)

Fever in last 24 hours, n/N (%) 2279/4852 (46.97) 4109/5704 (72.04%) 1268/2317 (54.73%) 261/585 (44.62%) 515/724 (71.13%) 113/197 (57.36%)

Temperature ºC (SD) 36.66 (0.61) 37.00 (0.75) 36.77 (0.62) 36.64 (0.61) 36.99 (0.74) 36.74 (0.50)

Pus on tonsils, n/N (%) 376/5213 (7.21) 3751/6232 (60.19%) 654/2495 (26.21%) 30/581 (5.16%) 418/721 (57.98%) 50/197 (25.38%)

Severely inflamed tonsils, n/N (%) 86/4923 (1.75) 1418/5855 (24.22%) 178/2344 (7.59%) 6/572 (1.05%) 181/720 (25.14%) 12/191 (6.28%)

Number of prior medical problems 0.22 (0.49) 0.24 (0.51) 0.17 (0.43) 0.28 (0.55) 0.24 (0.51) 0.17 (0.39)

Return within 4 weeks with new or worsening symptoms, n/N (%) 803/4974 (16.14) 864/5932 (14.57%) 222/2382 (9.49%) 107/564 (18.97%) 101/694 (14.55%) 24/186 (12.90%)

Return within 4 weeks with complications, n/N (%) 75/4974 (1.51) 78/5932 (1.31%) 21/2382 (0.88%) 12/564 (2.13%) 8/694 (1.15%) 3/186 (1.15%)

Individual complications, n/N (%)
  Quinsy 11/4974 (0.22) 30/5932 (0.52%) 6/2382 (0.26%) 4/564 (0.71%) 3/694 (0.43%) 1/186 (0.54%)
  Sinusitis 23/4974 (0.46) 12/5932 (0.21%) 3/2382 (0.13%) 2/564 (0.35%) 0/694 0/186
  Otitis media 31/4974 (0.62) 27/5932 (0.47%) 11/2382 (0.47%) 5/564 (0.89%) 5/694 (0.72%) 2/186 (1.08%)
  Celluliltis/impetigo 10/4974 (0.20) 9/5932 (0.16%) 1/2382 (0.04%) 1/564 (0.18%) 0/694 0/186
a

Baseline severity comprised of: sore throat, difficulty swallowing, feeling generally unwell, headache, disturbed sleep, muscle ache, fever during illness, fever in the last 24 hours, abdominal pain, diarrhoea, cough during illness, vomiting, runny nose, earache, inflamed pharynx, inflamed tonsils, cervical glands.