TABLE 1.
First author [ref.] | Study population | Methods compared | Findings |
Asbestosis | |||
Kipen [15] | 138 deceased insulation workers with primary lung carcinoma | Radiology, biopsy and autopsy | False-negative: 18.1% |
Sluis-Cremer [20] | 172 deceased asbestos mineworkers | Radiological findings of three readers and autopsy | 67 (39.0%) autopsy-diagnosed asbestosis cases; for readers 1, 2 and 3, respectively:# true-positive: 38, 18 and 30; false-positive: 25, 5 and 21; false-negative: 29, 49 and 36; true-negative: 80, 100 and 84; sensitivity: 56.7%, 26.9% and 45.5%; specificity: 76.2%, 95.2% and 80.0% |
Akira [17] | 7 deceased asbestos workers with radiologically diagnosed asbestosis | HRCT, biopsy and autopsy | Good correlation between HRCT and autopsy findings |
Mizell [16] | 273 deceased asbestos workers with radiologically diagnosed asbestosis | Radiology and autopsy | True-positive: 36.8% (89 out of 242 in study group); false-positive: 63.2% (153 out of 242 in study group) |
Mesothelioma | |||
Yates [19] | 272 deceased cases with suspected or confirmed mesothelioma | Clinical features, radiology and autopsy | True-positive: 99.2% (265 out of 267 autopsies) |
Takeshima [18] | 382 deceased cases with clinically diagnosed mesothelioma | Clinical features, radiology, pathology and autopsy | True-positive: 74.3% for males and 59.2% for females |
HRCT: high-resolution computed tomography. #: values derived from Sluis-Cremer et al. [20].