Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Aug 30.
Published in final edited form as: J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2013 May;131(5):1306–1311. doi: 10.1016/j.jaci.2013.03.014

Table I. SCID subtypes and transplantation-related characteristics.

Phenotype/syndrome Genetic defect Characteristics related to transplantation
TBNK ADA deficiency ERT or gene therapy (on a research study) might be available and considered if MRD transplants are not available for HCT.
ERT should be held before nonconditioned transplantation.
Fifty percent of patients have marked neurologic and cognitive abnormalities after transplantation or with ERT.5,6
B-cell function is usually recovered after unconditioned MRD transplantation.7

TBNK+ RAG1 or RAG2 mutation There is increased risk of nonengraftment and graft rejection in nonconditioned mismatched HCT.3,4 No radiation sensitivity is present.
B-cell function recovers in a minority (17%) of nonconditioned patients.3 There is a frequent need for boost transplants in nonconditioned HCT (83%).3

Artemis deficiency (DCLRE1C) DNA repair defects are seen (alkylating agents and radiation sensitivity).
There are frequent late effects after transplantation with alkylating agents.2
Reconstitution of B-cell function is rare (<20%) in patients receiving MSD transplants without myeloablation.1

Ligase IV deficiency A DNA repair defect is seen.
There are limited transplantation data.

TB+NK Common γc (IL-2Rγ, X-linked SCID) There are no barriers to engraftment, even with mismatched donors.3,4 Gene therapy is successful in correcting immune deficiency, but there is a high risk of malignant transformation in an early gene-therapy study.8
Reconstitution of B-cell function develops in 30% to 40% of patients after nonconditioned transplantation with MMRD transplants.3,4 There are few long-term problems except for cutaneous warts.2

Jak3 There are no barriers to engraftment.
There is reconstitution of B-cell function in up to 50% of nonconditioned patients with MMRD transplants.3 Warts are seen late after transplantation.2

TB+NK+/− CD45 deficiency Limited data are available.

TB+NK+ IL-7Rα There are good long-term outcomes and chance of B-cell function recovery without conditioning (70%).3

TB+NK+ CD3γ, CD3δ, CD3ε, CD3ζ Limited data are available. The degree of immunodeficiency and need for transplantation depend on specific mutation.

ZAP-70 deficiency ZAP-70 CD8 lymphopenia and high IgE levels are seen.
A case report indicates that conditioning might not be needed in closely matched transplants.9

Omenn syndrome Hypomorphic RAG1, RAG2, or other SCID mutations Autoreactive T cells causing inflammatory and allergic symptoms are found.
Conditioning was historically used even with MRD transplants, although there are no data to suggest that it should be treated differently than the underlying genetic defect.

Reticular dysgenesis AK2 deficiency Defective maturation of lymphoid and myeloid cells (stem cell defect) defect in mitochondrial adenylate kinase 2 Limited transplantation data are available. Full myeloablative conditioning might be needed before mismatched transplantation.10

ERT, Enzyme replacement therapy; ZAP-70, ζ chain–associated protein of 70 kDa.