Table 2.
First Author (year) |
Sample and Setting |
Race/Ethnicity of Sample | Areas of Qualitative Findings Related to Reproductive Coercion | Quality Rating |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||||||||
Reproductive Coercion |
Pregnancy Coercion |
Birth Control Sabotage |
Abortion Coercion |
Unintended Pregnancy |
Resistance Strategies |
Clinical Interventions |
||||
Hathaway (2005) | 38 women ages 23–62 participating in a hospital-based IPV program Massachusetts | 47% White | X | X | X | X | QII | |||
42% Latina | ||||||||||
Herrman (2007) | 12 teen mothers with a repeat pregnancy ages 16–19 Not listed | 69% Black | X | X | QII | |||||
6% Hispanic | ||||||||||
25% not described | ||||||||||
Miller (2007) | 53 sexually active adolescent females, ages 15–20, with history of IPV United States | 37.7% Latina | X | X | X | X | X | QI | ||
37.7% White | ||||||||||
20.8% Black | ||||||||||
1.9% Asian/ Pacific Islander | ||||||||||
1.9% multiple/ other | ||||||||||
Moore (2010) | 71 women ages 18–49 with history of IPV Midwestern and Eastern united States | 53% Black | X | X | X | X | X | QI | ||
33% White | ||||||||||
11% Hispanic | ||||||||||
1% American Indian/Alaska Native | ||||||||||
1% other | ||||||||||
Thiel de Bocanegra (2010) | 53 women age 18 and older, living in an IPV shelter San Francisco, California | 45% Hispanic | X | X | X | X | QI | |||
26% White | ||||||||||
17% Asian | ||||||||||
9% Black | ||||||||||
2% Native Amer. | ||||||||||
Teitelman (2011) | 64 adolescent girls ages 14–17, sexually active Northeastern United States | 100% Black | X | X | X | QI | ||||
Miller (2012) | 20 women ages 18–34, with gang involvement Los Angeles, California | 100% Latina | X | X | X | QI | ||||
Borrero (2015) | 66 low-income women, ages 18–45 Western Pennsylvania | 55% White | X | X | X | QI | ||||
45% Black | ||||||||||
Burton (2015) | 47 providers Virginia | 53.2% White | X | QI | ||||||
31.9% Black | ||||||||||
6.4% Hispanic/ Latino | ||||||||||
4.3% Other | ||||||||||
2.1% Multiracial | ||||||||||
2.1% Asian | ||||||||||
Nikolajski (2015) | 66 low-income women, ages 18–45 Western Pennsylvania | 55% White | X | X | X | X | X | QI | ||
45% Black |
Note:
Quality ratings for qualitative studies are as follows (Cesario et al., 2002)
QI: Total score of 22.5–30 indicates that 75% to 100% of the total criteria were met.
QII: Total score of 15–22.4 indicates that 50% to 74% of the total criteria were met.
QIII: Total score of less than 15 indicates that less than 50% of the total criteria were met.