Table 8.
Authors | Intervention & Study | N, Response Rate & Method | Exposure Levels | Change in Levels and Distribution of Change across Participants | Outcome Measure(s) before and after Outcomes | Did Outcome Change with Change in Exposure? YES/NO (Significance Tested?) |
Before/after Outcome Change Compared to that Estimated from an ERF | Comments | Confounders Adjusted for in Analyses | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nature | Design | Before | After | ||||||||
Amundsen, Klaeboe & Aasvang (2013) [28] | See Table 4 | LAeq,24 h, –7 dB for indoor noise levels for all Ps in target group |
Several sleep questions, but ‘sleep disturbed’ based on Yes/No response to either of: ‘I am disturbed by traffic noise’ or ‘I wake up because of traffic noise’ B: 45% disturbed A: 22% disturbed |
YES %Sleep Disturbed dropped after intervention (p < 0.0005 McNemar’s test) No change in control group Results stayed the same two years after |
n.a. | Overall sleep quality also assessed (top two points of 5-point sleep quality scale = ‘poor sleep’ Intervention resulted in less ‘poor sleep’ similar to change in %Sleep Disturbed |
Gender, age, education level, marital status, access to a bedroom on the quiet side of the building, and noise sensitivity | ||||
Bendtsen, Michelsen & Christensen (2011) [29] | See Table 4 | Lden Reductions in extent of exposure 60–65 & 55–60 bands but increase in lower two bands |
Unclear. Appears to be based on binary response to two questions: ‘difficulties in falling asleep’ & ‘wake up at night’ | Yes Ps. Reported sleep disturbance (both questions) dropped B: 14 & A: 7% No statistical tests |
n.a. | No data presented of change in exposure of those reporting change in sleep |