Table 3.
Reasons for Changing the Diagnosis.
| Case Number | Gene(s) | Variant(s) | Testing Laboratory | Laboratory Case-Level Classification | Clinical Geneticist Clinical-Level Classification | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cases That Were Demoted by the Clinical Geneticist | ||||||
| WES002 | HEXA / VPS13B | c.1073+1G>AIVS9+1G>A / c.11256_11290+10del, IVS58+10delC | B | Definitive | Unlikely | Hexosaminidase A activity was normal and clinical phenotype is not consistent with Tay Sachs / Lack of a second mutation in VSP13B and phenotype is not consistent with Cohen syndrome |
| WES003 | PANK2 | c.1561G>A, p.G521R | B | Definitive | Unlikely | Brain MRI and clinical course are not consistent with PANK2-related phenotype |
| WES069 | UPB1 / GAMT | c.917-1G>A, IVS8-1G>A / c.327G>A, p.K109K | B | Definitive | Unlikely | Negative biochemical studies for creatine deficiency syndromes and pyrimidine metabolism defects |
| WES090 | DPYD | c.1905+1G>A, IVS14+1G>A; c.1679T>G, p.I560S | G | Definitive | Possible | Biochemical studies were consistent but clinical phenotype did not fit with the phenotype of dihydropyrimidine dehydrogenase deficiency |
| WES091 | DMD | Deletion of exons 45-51 | G | Definitive | Possible | The neurological and cardiac phenotypes, normal muscle histopathological findings, and normal CK are not consistent with the expected clinical findings of this in-frame DMD deletion |
| Cases That Were Promoted by the Clinical Geneticist | ||||||
| WES013 | SCYL1 | c.1039C>T, p.Q347* | A | Possible | Definitive | Clinical phenotype of the patient matched a newly described syndrome 2 years after initial analysis |
| WES015 | UBE3B | c.2990G>C, p.R997P | A | Possible | Definitive | Facial features and clinical phenotype of the patient matched published syndrome |
| WES019 | GRIN2B | c.1916C>T, p.A639V | A | Possible | Definitive | Clinical phenotype of the patient matched neurological findings reported in patients with GRIN2B mutations |
| WES028 | ATP2B3 / LAMA1 | c.1445G>A, p.R482H / c.6074C>T, p.T2025M; c.1741C>T, p.R2381C | G | Possible | Definitive | In vitro functional studies showed impaired PMCA3 pump function and data supported a synergistic effect with LAMA1 mutations17 |
| WES030 | ARID1B / FGFR3 | c.2281G>A, p.G761S / c.445+(2_5)delTAGG, IVS4+(2_5)delTAGG | G | Possible | Definitive | The blended phenotype in the patient matched published syndromes related to these genes |
| WES038 | CTBP1 | c.991C>T, p.R331W | G | Candidate | Definitive | The patient was one of 4 patients described with a new genetic syndrome15 |
| WES050 | CYB5R3 | c.250C>T, p.R84X | G | Possible | Definitive | Follow up measurement of NADH to cytochrome b5 activity and methemoglobin level in blood were consistent with CYB5R3 deficiency |
| WES052 | GABRB2 | c.909G>T, p.K303N | G | Candidate | Definitive | Subsequent publication of new syndrome in other patients12; the patient is part of an ongoing study on a series of patients to define the phenotype |
| WES070 | GALNS / SUFU | c.1485C>G, p.N495K; c.539T>C, p.V180A / c.794_808del15, p.N265_V269del | G | Possible | Definitive | Clinical phenotype of the patient matched the two published syndromes |
| WES079 | TELO2 | c.1100G>T, p.C367F; c.2296G>A, p.V766M | G | Candidate | Definitive | The patient was 1 of 6 patients described with a new genetic syndrome16 |
| WES121 | COQ4 | c.245T>A, p.L82Q; c.473G>A, p.R158Q | G | Candidate | Definitive | The patient was 1 of 4 patients described with a new CoQ10 deficiency syndrome13 |
| WES122 | SNX27 | c.510C>G, p.Y170X; c.1295G>A, p.C432Y | G | Candidate | Definitive | Brain MRI and neurological phenotype were consistent with newly described syndrome11 |
| WES126 | ATM | c.3993+1G>A, IVS26+1G>A; c.5763-1050A>G, IVS39-1050A>G | G | Possible | Definitive | Re-sequencing of ATM detected a second mutation; elevated AFP and neurological findings matched the diagnosis |
| WES129 | PGAP1 | c.1546_1549delGTCA, p.V516KfsX4; c.1077T>G, p.Y359X | G | Possible | Definitive | Clinical and neurological phenotype of the patient matched published syndrome |
| WES131 | DNMT3A | c.2645G>A, p.R882H | G | Possible | Definitive | Clinical phenotype of the patient was consistent with a newly described syndrome18 |
| WES148 | POLR3B | c.2570+5G>A, IVS22+5G>A; c.3317T>C, p.I1106T | G | Possible | Definitive | Brain MRI and clinical phenotype of the patient matched published syndrome |
G: GeneDx, B: Baylor Genetics, A: Ambry Genetics.