Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 24;10:2031–2040. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S141366

Table S1.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria for study subjects

pCAP group sCAP group Pulpitis group Abscess group Control group
Inclusion criteria
Age at least 10 years Age at least 10 years Age at least 10 years Age at least 10 years Age at least 10 years
Tooth with AP lesion without RCF Tooth with AP lesion with RCF Tooth without AP lesion Tooth with AP lesion Excellent oral health
Objective and subjective criteria for AP Objective and subjective criteria for AP Objective and subjective criteria for pulpitis Objective and subjective criteria for abscess of endodontic origin Excellent oral hygiene
Lesion on X-ray with PAI >2 Lesion on X-ray with PAI >2 No lesion on X-ray (PAI<2) Lesion on X-ray with PAI >2 Intact teeth
Excellent general health Excellent general health Excellent general health Good general health Excellent general health
Exclusion criteria
Age <10 years Age <10 years Age <10 years Age <10 years Age <10 years
Diseased primary teeth Diseased primary teeth Diseased primary teeth Diseased primary teeth Bad oral hygiene
Vertical root fracture Vertical root fracture Vertical root fracture Vertical root fracture Any kind of tooth disease
Horizontal root fracture Horizontal root fracture Horizontal root fracture Horizontal root fracture Any kind of gingival or periodontal disease
Tooth with endo-perio lesion Tooth with endo-perio lesion Tooth with endo-perio lesion Tooth with endo-perio lesion Restored teeth
Tooth with peri-endo lesion Tooth with peri-endo lesion Tooth with peri-endo lesion Tooth with peri-endo lesion Any kind of general acute disease
Other conditions and clinical situations that require RCT Other conditions and clinical situations that require RCT Other conditions and clinical situations that require RCT Other conditions and clinical situations that require RCT Any kind of chronic general disease
Tooth with gingival pocket >3.5 mm Tooth with gingival pocket >3.5 mm Tooth with gingival pocket >3.5 mm Tooth with gingival pocket >3.5 mm Any kind of infectious disease in present or past history
Unrestorable tooth (deeply fractured or highly carious tooth which is impossible to restore and therefore must be extracted) Unrestorable tooth (deeply fractured or highly carious tooth which is impossible to restore and therefore must be extracted) Unrestorable tooth (deeply fractured or highly carious tooth which is impossible to restore and therefore must be extracted) Unrestorable tooth (deeply fractured or highly carious tooth which is impossible to restore and therefore must be extracted)
Tooth that has undergone apical surgery with or without retrograde filling Tooth that has undergone apical surgery with or without retrograde filling Tooth that has undergone apical surgery with or without retrograde filling
Any type of smoking or tobacco abuse Any type of smoking or tobacco abuse Any type of smoking or tobacco abuse Any type of smoking or tobacco abuse Any type of smoking or tobacco abuse
Antibiotic or any other medicament usage in previous 3 months Antibiotic or any other medicament usage in previous 3 months Antibiotic or any other medicament usage in previous 3 months Antibiotic or any other medicament usage in previous 3 months Antibiotic or any other medicament usage in previous 6 months
Diabetes I or II Diabetes I or II Diabetes I or II Diabetes I or II Diabetes I or II
Immune suppressed person (HIV, AIDS, chemotherapy) Immune suppressed person (HIV, AIDS, chemotherapy) Immune suppressed person (HIV, AIDS, chemotherapy) Immune suppressed person (HIV, AIDS, chemotherapy)

Abbreviations: HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; AIDS, acquired immunodeficiency syndrome; pCAP, primary chronic apical periodontitis; sCAP, secondary chronic apical periodontitis; AP, apical periodontitis; RCF, root canal filling; RCT, root canal treatment; PAI, periapical index.