Table 3.
Extracted qualitative data (Authors G-Z) from the 35 included papers.
Author | Country | Target demographica | Comparison to control demographic |
Harris ML (2015) [34] | Australia | 18-23 years | Partly representative; higher proportion of female and tertiary education |
Jones R (2015) [23] | United States | 18-29 years, female, in a sexual relationship with at least one man in past 3 months | Partly representative; higher proportion of education |
Kappa JM (2013) [36] | United States | 35-49 years, female | No comparison made |
Miyagi E (2014) [37] | Japan | 16-35 years, female | Partly representative; higher proportion of 26-35 age group and a low BMIb, and lower proportion of 16-21 age group |
Moreno MA (2017) [14] | United States | 14-18 years | No comparison made |
Morgan AJ (2015) [16] | Australia | No other criteria | No comparison made |
Musiat P (2016) [38] | Australia | 18-25 years | No comparison made |
Nelson EJ (2014) [24] | United States | 18-30 years, lives in metropolitan area | Partly representative; higher proportion of HPVcvaccination |
Parkinson S (2013) [39] | Australia | 18-25 years | Partly representative; higher proportion of females, university education, unemployed and high income rate, and lower proportion of full time employment |
Pedersen ER (2014) [25] | United States | 18-34 years, previously served in the US Air Force, Army, Marine Corps, Navy | Partly representative; higher proportion of Hispanic or Latino and lower proportion of black or African American |
Ramo DE (2014) [40] | United States | 18-25 years, smoker | Partly representative; higher proportion of white and males |
Ramo DE (2012) [41] | United States | 18-25 years | Partly representative; higher proportion of white and males |
Raviotta JM (2016) [11] | United States | 18-25, male, student, lives in Pittsburgh | Partly representative; higher proportion of homo or bisexual and social media use |
Remschmidt C (2014) [42] | Germany | 18-25 years | Representative |
Schumacher KR (2014) [26] | United States | 15-18 years, parents of <15 years, Fontan-associated protein losing enteropathy, plastic bronchitis | Representative |
Schwinn T (2017) [43] | United States | 13-14 years, female | Partly representative; higher proportion of African American and less reported parents completing high school. Smoking, drinking, and drugs use was representative |
Staffileno BA (2016) [13] | United States | 18-45 years, prehypertension | No comparison made |
Subasinghe AK (2016) [12] | Australia | 18-25 years, in Victoria who had not been vaccinated against HPV | Representative |
Yuan P (2014) [27] | United States | HIVdpositive | No comparison made |
aAssume all are over 18 years and English speaking unless otherwise stated.
bBMI: body mass index.
cHPV: human papillomavirus.
dHIV: human immunodeficiency virus.