Table 1.
Source | Comparisona | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SD/HC | SD/SND | SND/HC | PD/HC | SD/PD | SD/PND | PD/PND | PND/HC | |
Andreou et al49 | g b | |||||||
Andreou et al50 | g | |||||||
Baskak et al51 | g | |||||||
Bentall et al21 | g | g | g | g | g | |||
Buck et al52 | r | |||||||
Colbert et al53 | g | g | g | |||||
Conway et al54 | g | |||||||
Corcoran et al22 | g | g | g | g | g | g | g | g |
Dudley et al13 | g | g | g | |||||
Dudley et al55 | g | g | g | |||||
Dudley et al56 | g | |||||||
Fear and Healy57 | g | g | g | |||||
Fraser et al37 | g | g | g | |||||
Garety et al58 | g | g | g | g | g | g | ||
Huq et al9 | g | g | g | |||||
Jacobsen et al36 | g | g | g | |||||
Langdon et al59 | ρ | ρ | ||||||
Langdon et al19 | r | |||||||
Lim et al60 | r | |||||||
Lincoln et al61 | g | g | g | |||||
Menon et al25 | g | g | g | |||||
Menon et al39,c | g | |||||||
Menon et al26 | g | |||||||
Moritz & Woodward62 | g | g | g | g | g | |||
Mortimer et al63 | r | |||||||
Peters & Garety38,c | g | g | g | g | g | |||
Peters et al64 | g | |||||||
Ross et al40 | g | |||||||
So & Kwok65 | g | |||||||
Startup et al66 | g | |||||||
van der Gaag et al20 | r | |||||||
Waller et al41 | r | |||||||
Warman et al67 | g | |||||||
Warman et al68 | r | |||||||
Wittorf et al69 | r | g | ||||||
Total participants (n) | 1131 | 834 | 385 | 152 | 86 | 409 | 123 | 558 |
Total studies (k) | 21 | 20 | 7 | 4 | 2 | 10 | 3 | 12 |
Heterogeneity variance (I2) | 58.2% | 0.0% | 47.3% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 15.7% | 22.1% |
Heterogeneity significance (P) | .000 | .530 | .077 | .792 | .951 | .669 | .306 | .227 |
Note: JTC, jumping to conclusions.
aSD = schizophrenia with current delusions, HC = healthy controls, SND = schizophrenia without current delusions, PD = other psychiatric illnesses with current delusions, PND = other psychiatric illnesses without current delusions.
b g = Hedges’ g reported or calculated; r, ρ = correlation or Spearman’s correlation reported.
cLongitudinal data.