Skip to main content
. 2017 May 11;8(38):64358–64372. doi: 10.18632/oncotarget.17825

Table 1. The characteristics of the included studies.

Study Year Country TP FP FN TN Detection Method Cut-off (ng/ml)
Body(a) 1992 Belgium 79 6 18 94 RIA 11.7
Body(b) 1992 Belgium 86 11 11 89 RIA 9.2
Burghuber 1990 Austria 63 53 18 299 RIA 12.3
Dienemann 1994 Germany 42 26 13 163 ELISA 13.7
Dilmaghani-Marand 2013 Germany 50 0 0 90 ELISA 29.5
Ebert 1996 Germany 95 34 35 348 RIA 13.8
ESSCHER 1985 Sweden 74 4 29 368 RIA 25
Feng 2010 China 4 72 4 192 ECSIA 15.2
FRANJEBIC 2012 Croatia 201 10 127 195 ECSIA NA
Gruber 2008 Germany 78 2 116 316 RIA 35
Han 1994 China 10 14 8 31 ELISA 20
HOLDENRIEDER 2010 Germany 44 2 9 38 ECSIA NA
Jaques 1993 Japan 75 0 146 87 RIA 25
Keller 1998 Germany 52 50 8 302 ELISA 18
Lamy 2000 France 110 4 36 55 ELISA 17
Li 2003 China 18 5 12 55 ELISA 8
Molina 2008 Spain 78 32 18 385 ELISA 25
Molina 2009 Spain 114 50 61 577 ELISA 25
Muley 2003 Germany 138 71 50 744 ECSIA 21.6
Niklinski 1993 Poland 30 0 18 15 ELISA 15
NISMAN 2009 Japan 18 15 19 110 ELISA 22
Pan 2002 China 19 51 5 99 ELISA 13
Pinson 1997 Belgium 47 20 17 96 RIA 12.5
Poposka 2004 Macedonia 24 11 9 79 RIA 16.6
Scagliotti 1989 Italy 44 5 18 42 RIA 12
Shibayama 2001 Japan 49 3 65 103 ELISA 7.5
Stieber 1993 Germany 34 14 28 259 RIA 18
STIEBER(a) 1999 Japan 39 4 48 70 RIA 11.9
STIEBER(b) 1999 Japan 25 1 61 73 RIA 23.1
Takada 1996 Japan 73 6 28 108 ELISA 10.6
Yang 2000 China 18 5 12 55 ELISA 8
Yang(a) 2005 China 14 41 7 103 ECSIA 16.3
Yang(b) 2005 China 40 16 23 65 ECSIA 16.3
Zhang 2002 China 6 22 2 106 RIA 20
Zhou 1995 China 16 13 4 72 ELISA 20.8

ELISA: enzyme linked immunosorbent assay; ECSIA: electro-chemiluminescence; Immunoassay assay; RIA= radioimmunoassay assay; TP=true positive; FP: false positive; FN: false negative; TN=true negative.