Table 2.
Sources focusing on childhood exposure to emotional abuse
Author, Country | Design (cross-sectional, longitudinal) | Sample Type (college, community, primary care, tertiary psychiatric care) | Sample Size (n) | Sample Characteristics • % Female • % Ethnic-minority • % Immigrant |
Age Range (years) | Strength of Correlation for EA |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Eating Disorders | ||||||
Utzinger et al. [33], USA* | cross-sectional | tertiary psychiatric care, college, community | n = 133 | • 100% • 3% • Unclear |
18 to 55 | > 0.85a** |
Bardone-Cone et al. [49], USA* | cross-sectional | community, tertiary psychiatric care | n = 138 | • 100% • 13% • Unclear |
18 to 55 | 0.11–0.25a** |
Kugu et al. [39] Turkey | cross-sectional | college | n = 42 | • 85.7% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 24 | 0.51–0.75c** |
Schoemaker et al. [34], Netherlands | cross-sectional | community | n = 1926 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 45 | 0.26–0.50a** |
Grilo and Masheb [37], USA* | cross-sectional | primary care, tertiary psychiatric care | n = 1, 241 | • 97.9% • 19.8% • Unclear |
18 to 65 | 0.26–0.50c |
Mullen et al. [51], New Zealand | cross-sectional | community | n = 497 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 and over | 0.26–0.50a** |
Rorty et al. [50], USA* | cross-sectional | community, college, tertiary psychiatric care | n = 120 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 35 | 0.11–0.25a** |
Eating-Disordered Behavior | ||||||
Feinson and Hornik-Lurie [32], Jerusalem | cross-sectional | primary care | n = 498 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
21 and older | 0.11–0.25a** |
Mason et al. [30], USA | longitudinal | community | n = 4, 377 | • 100% • ~ 3.2% • Unclear |
22 to 29 | 0.11–0.25ad**
0.26–0.50ae** |
Michopoulos et al. [17], USA | cross-sectional | primary care | n = 1, 110 | • 80.4% • 97.4% • Unclear |
18 to 65 | 0.11–0.25c** |
Moulton et al. [14], Scotland | cross-sectional | college | n = 142 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 46 | 0.26–0.50a** |
Brooke and Mussap [41], | cross-sectional | college | n = 299 | • 52% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 40 | 0.01–0.10cf
0.11–0.25b** 0.26–0.50a** |
Burns et al. [40], USA* | cross-sectional | college | n = 1, 254 | • 100% • 22.3% • Unclear |
18 to 22 | 0.01–0.10a
0.11–0.25a** |
Becker and Grilo [36], USA* | cross-sectional | tertiary psychiatric care | n = 137 | • 100% • 15% • Unclear |
20 to 59 | 0.01–0.10af |
Messman-Moore and Garrigus [43], USA* | cross-sectional | college | n = 289 | • 100% • 9% • Unclear |
18 to 22 | 0.26–0.50a** |
Wonderlich et al. [44], USA* | longitudinal | college, community, tertiary psychiatric care | n = 123 | • 100% • 3.3% • Unclear |
18 to 55 | 0.11–0.25a** |
Witkiewitz and Dodge-Reyome [46], USA | cross-sectional | college | n = 88 | • 100% • 1.0% • Unclear |
18 to 25 | 0.26–0.50a** |
Kent et al. [47], United Kingdom | cross-sectional | college | n = 236 | • 100% • Unclear • Unclear |
18 to 48 | 0.11–0.25a**
0.26–0.50a** |
Eating Disorders and Eating-Disordered Behavior | ||||||
Grilo and Masheb [38], USA* | cross-sectional | primary care, tertiary psychiatric care | n = 1, 270 | • 97.3% • 19.8% • Unclear |
18 to 65 | 0.11–0.25c** |
* Country of data collection not articulated. Assumption of country location was made given language used to describe participants (e.g. African American) or based upon identification of the location of the study’s Institutional Review Board
** Authors reported at least one bivariate correlation estimate to be significant at p < .05
aEstimate falls within this range among women
b Estimate falls within this range among men
cEstimate falls within this range among men and women
d Estimate computed through converting risk ratios to odds ratios, and then, to a correlation coefficient. Correlation represents strength of correlation between moderate abuse exposure prior to the age 11 years and lifetime binge eating disorder after age 11
e Estimate computed through converting risk ratios to odds ratios, and then, to a correlation coefficient. Correlation represents strength of correlation between severe abuse exposure prior to the age 11 years and binge eating disorder after age 11
f Estimate reported was non-significant