Table 1.

Suggested framework for student assessment of the VHC exercise.

Attribute	% Marks
The dilemma is accurately articulated.	10
All issues are identified.	10
The priority given to each issue is clearly argued.	10
The values, ethical and moral positions are articulated in a professional and non-emotional manner.	30
The conclusion of the discussion is clearly presented.	10
Any obstacles to reaching a consensus position are clearly presented.	10
Your reflections include any changes in your positon as a result of the discussion.	10
Areas of animal welfare and ethics you wish to explore further are defined.	10