Table 1.
Author (year) [reference] | Method | Sample | Paradigm | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|
STRUCTURAL | ||||
Kim et al. (2010) [39] | VBM | N=19 (19 postpartum women with minimal to moderate depression at 2–4 weeks and 3–4 months) |
Prospective longitudinal study (during postpartum period) | In postpartum women across postpartum period:
|
Hoekzema et al. (2017) [41] | fMRI | N=81 (25 primiparous women pre-pregnancy, early postpartum and at 2 years postpartum 20 nulliparous women at time period comparable to primiparous women 19 first time fathers prior to and following partner’s pregnancy 17 control men without children) |
Prospective longitudinal study (before pregnancy v. postpartum) | In postpartum scans v. prepartum scans:
|
FUNCTIONAL | ||||
Bannbers et al. (2013) [53] | BOLD activation | N=26 (13 healthy postpartum women at 48 hours and 4–7 weeks postpartum 13 healthy non-pregnant women during luteal and follicular phase) |
Go/NoGo response inhibition task | In postpartum women v. non-pregnant women:
|
Gingnell et al. (2015) [54] | BOLD activation | N=28 (13 healthy postpartum women at 48 hours and 4–6 weeks postpartum 15 healthy non-pregnant women during luteal and follicular phase) |
Adult emotional face matching task | In postpartum women v. non-pregnant women:
Insula and inferior frontal gyrus activity ~ state anxiety In late postpartum period: Insula and inferior frontal gyrus activity ~ depression |
Silverman et al. (2007) [55] | BOLD activation (pilot study) | N=8 (4 PPD women 7–8 weeks postpartum 8 healthy women 7–8 weeks postpartum) |
Word/non-word task for emotionally valanced words (positive, negative threat/non-threat, neutral) | In PPD v. healthy women:
|
Silverman et al. (2011) [56] | BOLD activation | N=17 (6 PPD women 6–8 weeks postpartum 11 healthy women 6–8 weeks postpartum) |
Word/non-word task for emotionally valanced words (positive, negative threat/non-threat, neutral) | In PPD v. healthy women:
|
Moses-Kolko et al. (2010) [61] | BOLD activation | N=30 (14 PPD women 4–13 weeks postpartum 16 healthy women 4–13 weeks postpartum) |
Adult emotional face matching task | In PPD v. healthy women:
|
Moses-Kolko et al. (2011) [62] | BOLD activation | N=24 (12 PPD women <10 weeks postpartum 12 healthy women <10 weeks postpartum) |
Card guessing task with monetary reward | In PPD v. healthy women: No difference in initial left ventral striatum activity with reward
|
Barrett et al. (2012) [51] | BOLD activation | N=22 (22 healthy women at initial recruitment, 2 months and 3 months postpartum) |
Emotional face affect rating task (positive and negative images of own and other infant) | In depressed, anxious subjects:
|
Wonch et al. (2016) [65] | BOLD activation | N=45 (28 PPD women 2–5 months postpartum 17 healthy women 2–5 months postpartum) |
Positive emotional affect rating task (positive own infant face, other infant face, non-infant images) | In PPD v. healthy women:
|
Deligiannidis et al. (2013) [27] | BOLD resting state | N=17 (8 PPD women < 9 weeks of delivery 9 healthy women < 9 weeks of delivery) |
Resting state | In PPD vs. healthy women:
|
Chase et al. (2014) [76] | BOLD resting state | N=37 (14 PPD women <12 weeks postpartum 23 healthy women <12 weeks postpartum) |
Resting state | In PPD v. healthy women:
|
MOLECULAR | ||||
Sacher et al. (2010) [85] | PET | N=30 (15 healthy women 4–6 days postpartum 15 healthy non-postpartum women) |
PET scan w/carbon-11 harmine | In healthy postpartum women v. healthy non-postpartum women:
|
Sacher et al. (2015) [86] | PET | N= 57 (15 PPD women <18 months postpartum 12 healthy postpartum women who cry due to sad mood <18 months postpartum 15 asymptomatic healthy postpartum women <18 months postpartum 15 healthy non-postpartum women) |
PET scan w/carbon-11 harmine | In PPD women v. healthy postpartum women:
|
Moses-Kolko et al. (2012) [88] | PET | N=63 (13 postpartum unipolar depressed women early postpartum 7 postpartum bipolar depressed women early postpartum 13 healthy postpartum women early postpartum 10 non-postpartum unipolar depressed women early follicular phase 7 non-postpartum bipolar depressed women early follicular phase 13 non-postpartum healthy early follicular phase) |
PET scan w/carbon-11 raclopride | In unipolar depression and all postpartum patients v. healthy non-postpartum and non-postpartum bipolar depressed:
|
Moses-Kolko et al. (2008) [92] | PET | N=16 (9 PPD women 4 to 13 weeks postpartum 7 healthy postpartum 4 to 13 weeks postpartum) |
PET scan w/carbon-11 WAY100635 | In PPD women v. healthy postpartum:
|
Epperson et al. (2006) [100] | MRS | N=33 (9 PPD women <6 months postpartum prior to re-starting of menstruation 14 postpartum healthy women <6 months postpartum prior to re-starting of menstruation 10 healthy women during follicular phase of menstruation) |
MRS to measure occipital cortex GABA concentration | In PPD women and healthy postpartum women v. healthy follicular phase women:
|
McEwen et al. (2012) [103] | MRS | N=24 (12 PPD women 3 weeks to 3 months postpartum 12 healthy postpartum women 3 weeks to 3 months postpartum) |
MRS to measure MPFC glutamate concentration | In PPD women v. healthy postpartum women:
|
Abbreviations: ACC- anterior cingulate cortex, AMYG- amygdala, BOLD- blood-oxygen-level-dependent, DLPFC- dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, fMRI- functional magnetic resonance imaging, GABA- γ-aminobutyric acid A, GM- grey matter, HIPP- hippocampus, MAO-A- monoamine oxidase-A, MFC- medial frontal cortex, MPFC- medial prefrontal cortex, MRS- magnetic resonance spectroscopy, PET- positron emission tomography, PFC- prefrontal cortex, PPD- postpartum depressed, VBM- voxel based morphometry.