Table 3.
Selection of currently available experimental platforms that are used to delineate the role of passive and active cues in the context of optimizing key scaffold properties.
Key Scaffold Properties | Mechanostimulation | Technique to Study | Variables | Current Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|
Passive | ||||
fibre diameter, fibre topography | • microgrooves | • groove width (nm–m) • shape |
groove-depth as confounding parameter | |
• dimension/topography | ||||
• micropatterning | • pattern size (m) • shape • protein gradients |
range of pattern-size | ||
fibre stiffness, macroscopic stiffness, scaffold density | • substrate stiffness | • polyacrylamide gels (2D) [119] | • 1 Pa–100 kPa | unable to capture fibrous 3D morphology |
• hydrogels (3D) [120,121] | • <1 Pa–few kPa • stiffness gradients (2D) • non-linearity |
low stiffness magnitude | ||
Active | ||||
anisotropy, geometry | • shear stress | • parallel plates [122] | • shear stress (<1 Pa–few Pa) | pressure as confounding parameter |
• orbital shaker [122] | • shear stress (<1 Pa–few Pa) | temporal and spatial variations in shear stress | ||
anisotropy, geometry, macroscopic stiffness | • strain | • motor/pressure driven distensible membrane [122] | • strain (1–20%) | spatial variations in strain |
anisotropy, geometry, macroscopic stiffness | • shear stress & strain | • mock artery [122] | • shear stress (<1 Pa) • strain (1–10%) |
no independent control of variables |
• microfluidic device [123,124,125] | • shear stress (<1 Pa–few Pa) • strain (1–10%) |
lack of 3D environment | ||
Passive and active | ||||
fibre diameter, anisotropy, pore size | • scaffold + shear stress | • parallel plates in mesofluidic device [126] | • shear stress (<1 Pa–few Pa) • scaffold properties |
pressure as confounding parameter |
anisotropy, pore size, connectivity, macroscopicstiffness, degradation rate | • scaffold + strain | • motor/pressure driven distensible membrane [99,127] | • strain (1–20%) • scaffold properties |
spatial variations in strain |
fibre diameter, anisotropy, pore size, connectivity, macroscopic stiffness, degradation rate | • scaffold + shear stress & strain | • perfusion bioreactor [128] | • shear stress (<1 Pa–few Pa) • strain (1–5%) • scaffold properties |
no independent control of active variables |