Table 1.
Author, Year | Study Type | Age (Years) Median (IQR) |
Population | N | Sex (% Male) | Measured CrCl (mL/min)—Otherwise Specified | Intervention | Main Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Barletta et al. [4], 2017 | Retrospective observational | 48 ± 19 | ICU trauma patients where measured SCr available and SCr < 115 µmol/L | 133 | 76 | 168 ± 65 | ARCTIC (Augmented Renal Clearance in Trauma Intensive Care) Scoring system suggested |
|
Naeem et al. [5], 2017 | Prospective observational | ARC: 37 ± 16 Non-ARC: 34 ± 14 |
ICU patients with SCr < 115 µmol/L | 50 | ARC: 70 Non-ARC: 60 |
ARC: 214 ± 46 Non-ARC: 112 ± 11 |
The effects of ARC on enoxaparin determined; Patients received enoxaparin 40 mg SC daily; Anti-Xa activity measured and compared among patients with and without ARC; measured 24 h CrCl |
|
Udy et al. [6], 2017 | Prospective observational (sub-study of BLING II RCT) | ARC: 52 (33–60) Non-ARC: 65 (55–73) |
ICU patients with severe sepsis | 254 | ARC: 73 Non-ARC: 57 |
ARC: 165 (144–198) Non-ARC: 56 (27–83) |
Conducted to determine the effect of ARC on patient outcome; patients randomized to receive beta lactam antibiotics (piperacillin/tazobactam, ticarcillin/clavulanic acid or meropenem) by intermittent or continuous infusion; measured 8 h CrCl |
|
Udy et al. [7], 2017 | Prospective observational | 37 (24–49) | ICU (TBI patients with SCr < 120 µmol/L) | 11 | 82 | Median (day 1): 201 (76–289) |
Measured 8-h CrCl, cardiac output and ANP were determined and correlated |
|
Barletta et al. [8], 2016 | Retrospective observational | 48 ± 18 | ICU (trauma) | 65 | 74 | 169 ± 70 | Measured 12-h CrCl compared with CG method, CKD-EPI, and MDRD-4 |
|
Chu et al. [9], 2016 | Retrospective observational | Group A: 63 ± 15 Group B: 59 ± 14 Group C: 44 ± 16 |
Patients treated with vancomycin | 148 | 66 | Estimated by CG Group A: 54 ± 17 Group B: 106 ± 15 Group C: 188 ± 50 |
Vancomycin 1000 mg IV Q12H regimen given; vancomycin levels drawn pre 4th or 5th dose; levels compared across three groups: A (CrCl < 80), B (CrCl 80–129), C (CrCl ≥ 130; ARC) |
|
Declercq et al. [10], 2016 | Prospective observational | Abdominal Surgery: 63 (51–71) Trauma Surgery: 62 (46–75) |
Non-critically ill surgery patients | 232 | Abdo. Surgery: 74 Trauma Surgery: 58 |
Abdominal Surgery: 109 (82–135) Trauma Surgery: 109 (85–142) |
Aim to assess the prevalence of ARC in non-critically ill surgical patients; Measured 8-h CrCl |
|
Hirai et al. [11], 2016 | Retrospective observational | 4.4 (range 1–15) | Pediatric ICU patients with normal renal function (Japan) |
109 | 59 | eGFR estimated by Schwartz formula 160 ( range 90–323) mL/min/1.73 m2 |
Vancomycin 40–60 mg/kg per day given in 2–4 divided doses; vancomycin clearance estimated |
|
Kawano et al. [12], 2016 | Prospective observational | 67 (53–77) | ICU (Japan) | 111 | 56 | Not reported | Measured 8-h CrCl |
|
Roberts et al. [13], 2016 | Prospective PK study | 61 ± 17 | Patients treated with levofloxacin | 18 | 67 | Estimated using CG 70 ± 67 | Doses of levofloxacin 500 and 750 mg daily have been used; Monte-Carlo simulation conducted to determine PTA in ICU cohort compared to non ICU ones |
|
De Cock et al. [14], 2015 | Prospective PK study | 2.6 (range 0.08–15) | Pediatric ICU | 50 | 60 | Not reported | Population PK of amoxicillin/clavulanate in pediatric ICU population; Conventional dosing of 25–35 mg/kg every 6 h was tested. |
|
De Waele et al. [15], 2015 | Retrospective observational | 62 (50–72) | ICU | 1081 | 63 | ARC: 178 (140–243) Non-ARC: 54 (32–82) |
Measured 24-h CrCl and ARC risk factors determined |
|
Dias et al. [16], 2015 | Retrospective observational | Mean 42 (range 20–66) | ICU (TBI patients) | 18 | 89 | CG method 199 (Range 62–471) | Cerebrovascular pressure reactivity index (PRx) correlated with CrCl |
|
Huttner et al. [17], 2015 | Prospective observational | ARC: 41 ± 12 Non-ARC: 51:10 |
ICU with CrCl ≥ 60 mL/min | 100 | 75 | Estimated with CG ARC: 166 (145–200) Non-ARC: 103 (87–113) |
They determined the influence of ARC on patient outcome; Standard dose antibiotic regimens given (imipenem/cilastatin 500 mg IV QID; meropenem 2 g IV TID; piperacillin/tazobactam 4.5 g IV TID; cefepime 2 g IV BID) |
|
Morbitzer et al. [18], 2015 | Retrospective observational | CN: 44 (29–52) TH/PI: 48 (40–62) |
ICU (TBI) | 27 | 63 | Estimated using CG CN: 119 (91–166) TH/PI: 129 (100–156) |
Vancomycin pharmacokinetics compared in patients with CN (T = 36–37 C), TH (T=33–34 C) or pentobarbital infusion |
|
Ruiz et al. [19], 2015 | Prospective observational | ARC: 39 ± 16 No ARC: 55 ± 19 |
ICU (patients with normal SCr) | 360 | ARC: 75 No ARC: 65 |
ARC: 173 ± 44 No ARC: 79 ± 30 |
Measured 24-h CrCl compared with 4 formulas to estimate CrCl/GFR (CG, Robert, MDRD and CKD-EPI methods) |
|
Spadaro et al. [20], 2015 | Retrospective observational | Group A: 63 ± 11 Group B: 71 ± 10 |
ICU | 348 | Group A: 73 Group B: 69 |
Group A: 106 ± 41 Group B: 37 ± 16 |
Vancomycin administration protocol based on measured 24 h CrCl and vancomycin serum measurements; levels compared between two groups: A (CrCl > 50) and B (CrCl ≤ 50) Vancomycin serum trough target: 15–25 mg/L |
|
Steinke et al. [21], 2015 | Prospective observational | 66 (57–74) | ICU | 100 | 61 | 73 (47–107) | Measured CrCl compared with estimated CrCl using serum cystatin C Hoek formula, CG, and CKD-EPI |
|
Adnan et al. [22], 2014 | Prospective observational | 34 (24–47) | ICU patients with SCr < 120 µmol/L) | 49 | 76 | ARC: 173 (141–223) Non-ARC: 91 (64–112) |
Measured 24-h CrCl compared with CG method |
|
Akers et al. [23], 2014 | Prospective observational | 45 ± 19 | ICU | 13 | 62 | Not reported | They determined the ability of the ARC score to predict piperacillin/tazobactam clearance; Piperacillin/tazobactam doses given were (3.375 g IV Q6H or 4.5 g Q6H) |
|
Baptista et al. [24], 2014 | Prospective observational | ARC: 49 ± 15 No ARC: 60 ± 18 |
ICU patients with normal SCr | 54 | ARC: 64 No ARC: 36 |
ARC Patients: 161 ± 28 Non-ARC Patients: 105 ± 16 |
Measured 8-h CrCl compared with CG method, CKD-EPI, and MDRD |
|
Baptista et al. [25], 2014 | Prospective observational (Group 1 data were retrospectively collected) | Group 1: 58 ± 16 Group 2: 60 ± 17 |
ICU | G 1: 79 G 2: 25 |
Group 1: 66 Group 2: 68 |
Group 1: 125 ± 67 mL/min/1.73 m2 Group 2: 121 ± 54 mL/min/1.73 m2 |
Continuous infusion Vancomycin dosing nomogram based on 8h measured CrCl was suggested Group 1: retrospective data Group 2: prospective assessment of the nomogram Target vancomycin level: 20–30 mg/L |
|
Campassi et al. [26], 2014 | Prospective observational | ARC: 48 ± 15 Non-ARC: 65 ± 17 |
ICU patients with SCr < 115 µmol/L | 363 | ARC: 48 Non-ARC: 47 |
ARC: 155 ± 33 Non-ARC: 78 ± 25 |
CrCl measured by 24 h urine collection; Vancomycin loading dose 15 mg/kg followed by continuous infusion 30 mg/kg/day was given Target trough 15–25 mg/L |
|
Hites et al. [27], 2014 | Prospective observational | 61 (18–84) | Non-ICU obese (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m2) patients treated with antibiotics | 56 | 50 | 107 (6–389.0) | They assessed the adequacy of serum concentrations of antimicrobials when given to obese individuals; Standard doses of antibiotics given (Cefepime 2 g TID, Piperacillin/tazobactam 4 g QID, Meropenem 1 g TID); Measured 24-h CrCl determined |
|
Udy et al. [28], 2014 | Prospective observational | Mean 37 (95% CI 29 –44) | ICU patients with SCr < 120 µmol/L and age ≤ 60 | 20 | 60 | Mean: 168 (95% CI 139–197) | Measured 24-h CrCl determined; various exogenous markers given to detect changes in nephron physiology |
|
Udy et al. [29], 2014 | Prospective observational | Mean 54 (95% CI 53–56) | ICU patients with SCr < 120 µmol/L | 281 | 63.3 | Mean: 108 (95% CI 102–115) | Measured 8-h CrCl determined daily |
|
Carlier et al. [30], 2013 | Prospective observational | 56 (48–67) | ICU | 61 | 85 | 125 (93–175) | Meropenem or piperacillin/tazobactam were given as extended IV infusions; antibiotics concentrations measured; measured 24 h CrCl determined; Meropenem dose: an IV loading of 1 g over 30 min then 1 g Q8H as extended infusion over 3 h; Piperacillin/tazobactam dose: an IV loading of 4.5 g over 30 min then 4.5 g Q6H extended infusion over 3 h. |
|
Claus et al. [31], 2013 | Prospective observational | ARC: 54 (44–61) Non-ARC: 66 (57–77) |
ICU patients receiving antimicrobial therapies | 128 | ARC: 73 Non-ARC: 61 |
98 (57–164) mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 8 h-CrCl determined; measuring the effect of ARC on antimicrobial therapy failure |
|
Minkute et al. [32], 2013 | Retrospective observational | ARC: 46 (21–66) Non-ARC: 54 (22–86) |
Patients treated with vancomycin | 36 | 80 | Estimated CG ARC: 151 (131–324) Non-ARC: 103 (90–127) |
Vancomycin level comparison between ARC and non-ARC groups |
|
Roberts and Lipman [33], 2013 | PK study (analysis of Phase III trial data) | 58 ± 15 | ICU patients with pneumonia | 31 | 93 | Estimated by CG 137 ± 71 |
Population PK of doripenem in critically ill. |
|
Shimamoto et al. [34], 2013 | Retrospective observational | Non-SIRS: 64 SIRS-2: 54 SIRS-3: 49 SIRS-4: 42 |
ICU (Septic patients on vancomycin) | 105 | 66 | Using CG No-SIRS: 121 ± 51 SIRS-2: 160 ± 65 SIRS-3: 195 ± 70 SIRS-4: 191 ± 77 |
Identified patients who had SIRS and categorized based on the number of SIRS criteria they had (non-SIRS, SIRS-2, 3 and 4); vancomycin CL and CrCL (CG) determined |
|
Udy et al. [35], 2013 | Prospective observational | 42 ± 17 | ICU (trauma, septic, SCr < 110 µmol/L) | 71 | 63 | Mean: 135 ± 52 | They determined the prevalence and risk factors of ARC |
|
Udy et al. [36], 2013 | Prospective observational | 51 ± 17 | ICU patients with SCr < 121 µmol/L | 110 | 64 | Mean: 125 ± 45 mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 8 h CrCl compared to estimated CrCl (CG and CKD-EPI) |
|
Baptista et al. [37], 2012 | Prospective observational | Non-ARC: 70 (52–79) ARC: 41 (32–56) |
ICU septic patients on vancomycin | 93 | Non-ARC: 71 ARC: 79 |
Non-ARC: 70 (58–104) ARC: 159 (141–194) |
The effect of ARC on vancomycin PK: ARC patients compared to non-ARC patients; measured 24 h CrCl Vancomycin dosing: A loading dose of 1000 mg if wt. < 70 kg or 1500 mg if wt. > 70 kg then 30 mg/kg/day continuous infusion |
|
Grootaert et al. [38], 2012 | Retrospective observational | 59 (48–67) | ICU patients with measured CrCl > 120 mL/min (24-h method) | 390 | 63 | 148 (132–172) mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 24-h CrCl compared with CG method (CrCl) and 4-variable MDRD method (eGFR) |
|
Udy et al. [39], 2012 | Prospective observational | 53 ± 21 | ICU | 48 | 71 | 134 ± 90 | Measured 8 h CrCl; beta lactam antibiotic concentrations measured |
|
Baptista et al. [40], 2011 | Retrospective observational (post hoc analysis) | 35 (25–51) | ICU patients with ARC | 86 | 77 | 162 (145–190) mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 8-h (Australia) or 24 h (Portugal) CrCl compared with CG, modified CG, 4-variable MDRD and 6-variable MDRD |
|
Minville et al. [41], 2011 | Retrospective observational | NPT: 58 ± 17 PT: 42 ± 18 |
ICU | 284 | NPT: 63 PT: 75 |
NPT: 85 ± 5 PT: 131 ± 5 mL/min/1.73 m2 |
Measured 24-h CrCl; compared among patients with (NPT) and without polytrauma (PT) |
|
Spencer et al. [42], 2011 | Prospective PK study | 54 ± 14 | Neuro ICU | 12 | 42 | 96 ± 32 (estimated, method not reported) | Patients received levetiracetam 500 mg iv every 12 h; levetiracetam levels measured |
|
Goboova et al. [43], 2015 | Case Report | 16 | ICU (Polytrauma and sepsis) | 1 | 100 | Method not reported Day 29: 138 Days 41–51: 340 mL/min/1.73 m2 |
Vancomycin initiated at doses of 1 g IV every 12 h then titrated up |
|
Abdul-Aziz et al. [44], 2014 | Case Report | 36 | ICU (CNS infection) | 1 | 100 | 234 | Days 1–3: Flucloxacillin 2 g IV Q4H Days 4–16: Flucloxacillin 20 g/day via continuous infusion |
|
Cook et al. [45], 2013 | Case Report | 22 | Neuro ICU (TBI) | 1 | 0 | Method not reported 153 | They described a case of ARC leading to subtherapeutic vancomycin and levetiracetam levels |
|
Lonsdale et al. [46], 2013 | Case Report | 44 | Neuro ICU (SAH with ventriculitis) | 1 | 100 | 375 mL/min/1.73 m2 | They described a case of ARC leading to subtherapeutic vancomycin and meropenem levels |
|
Troger et al. [47], 2012 | Case Reports | Pt 1: 37 Pt 2: 66 |
ICU patients with sepsis | 2 | 100 | Estimated with CG Pt 1: Initially: 138 Day 5: 276 Pt 2: Initially: 185 Later: 219 |
Described 2 cases of sepsis patients who required high doses of meropenem secondary to ARC Pt 1: meropenem 1 g IV Q8H then increased to meropenem 2 g IV Q4H Pt 2: meropenem 1 g Q8H then dose increased to1 g Q6H then to 2 g Q6H Meropenem trough target 4–10 mg/L |
|
Udy et al. [3], 2010 | Case Series | Pt 1: 19 Pt 2: 41 Pt 3: 32 |
ICU Pt 1 TBI Pt 2 Surgery Pt 3 Burn |
3 | 100 | Pt 1: 224 Pt 2: 206 Pt 3: 151 Measured 8 h CrCl |
Three case reports of patients with ARC Pt. 1: meropenem Pt 2: vancomycin + meropenem Pt 3: amikacin + ciprofloxacin |
|
Caro et al. [48], 2016 Abstract |
Phase I PK study | Range 29–50 | ICU patients with ARC (CrCl ≥ 180 mL/min estimated by CG) | 5 | 40 | Estimated using CG 282 (207–417) |
Determined the PK of ceftolozane/tazobactam in patients with ARC |
|
Goboova et al. [49], 2016 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | Mean 42 ± 14 | Patients treated with gentamicin | 204 | 78 | Method not reported ARC Patients: 166 ± 28 mL/min/1.73 m2 |
Identification of the influence of ARC on gentamicin dosing |
|
Morbitzer et al. [50], 2016 Abstract |
Prospective observational | 63 (56–71) | Neuro ICU (Hemorrhagic stroke) | 17 | 27 | 131 (108–216) mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 8-h CrCl compared with CG method; vancomycin trough concentration determined |
|
Morimoto and Ishikura [51], 2016 Abstract |
Prospective observational | Not reported | ICU (Japan) | 33 | Not reported | Not reported | CrCl measured (method not reported) |
|
Dunning and Roberts [52], 2015 Abstract |
A survey | N/A | N/A | 123 | N/A | N/A | A survey of 123 ICU physicians about antibiotic prescribing and renal function assessment |
|
Baptista et al. [53], 2014 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | Not reported | ICU | 477 | Not reported | Not reported | CrCl measured by 8 h urine collection |
|
May et al. [54], 2014 Abstract |
Prospective observational | Not reported | Neuro ICU (SAH) | 20 | Not reported | 326 ± 135 mL/min/1.73 m2 | Measured 24-h CrCl determined; Monte-Carlo Simulation for levetiracetam doses to achieve trough levels ≥ 6 mg/L |
|
Vermis et al. [55], 2014 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | Not reported | Patients with hematological malignancies | 96 | Not reported | CrCl estimated using CG ARC pts: 147 Non-ARC pts: 79 |
Aimed to determine the prevalence of ARC in a hematological population; Vancomycin continuous infusion: loading 15 mg/kg, maintenance 30 mg/kg given and titrated based on levels Vancomycin trough target: 20 mg/L |
|
Weigel et al. [56], 2014 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | 55 | ICU patients without renal replacement and receiving vancomycin infusion | 287 | 69 | ARC: MDRD eGFR > 130 Non ARC: MDRD eGFR < 130 |
A vancomycin loading dose of 20 mg/kg was given then adjusted by Therapeutic drug monitoring to target 20–25 mg/L; Vancomycin levels compared in patients with various degrees of eGFR using MDRD |
|
Neves et al. [57], 2013 Abstract |
Prospective observational | 55 ± 13 | ICU | 54 | 72 | Mean: 138 | Measured 8-h CrCl compared with CG method |
|
Grootaert et al. [58], 2012 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | 66 (56–75) | ICU patients with measured CrCl available | 1317 | 63 | Not reported | Measured 24-h CrCl |
|
Drust et al. [59], 2011 Abstract |
Retrospective observational | Not reported | ICU patients with CrCl > 120 mL/min | 15 | Not reported | >120 | Meropenem plasma concentrations measured |
|
ANP = atrial natriuretic peptide; APACHE II = Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation; ARC = Augmented Renal Clearance; CG = Cockcroft Gault equation; CKD-EPI = Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology; CN = controlled normothermia; CrCl = creatinine clearance; GFR = glomerular filtration rate; ICU = intensive care unit; IQR = interquartile range; MDRD = modification of diet in renal disease method; MIC = minimum inhibitory concentration; PK = pharmacokinetic; PT = patient; PTA = probability of target attainment; SAH = subarachnoid hemorrhage; SAPS II = Simplified Acute Physiology Score SCr = serum creatinine; SIRS = systemic inflammatory response syndrome; SOFA = sequential organ failure assessment score; TBI = traumatic brain injury; TH = therapeutic hypothermia. Age and CrCl reported in median (IQR) or mean ± SD.