Table 2.
NIH BCC Domain (n) | Assessment Criteria (n) | What measured (n) | How Measured (n) | Studya |
---|---|---|---|---|
Treatment Design (0) | Assess whether intervention protocol/manuals reflect the underlying theoretical model or clinical guidelines (0) | N/A | N/A | N/A |
Training providers (2) | Assess provider skills acquisition (2) | Provider confidence to deliver intervention (1) | Provider self-report (1) | [46] |
Provider competence to deliver intervention (1) | Assessment of provider (1) | [42] | ||
Assess and monitor provider skills maintenance (0) | N/A | N/A | ||
Delivery of treatment (51) | Assess if provider adhered to intervention plan, or in the case of computer delivered intervention, method to assess participants contact with information (28) | Number of email messages delivered (1) | Researcher observation (1) | [32] |
Number of email messages/intervention materials read/received (3) | Participant self-report (3) | [32, 40, 41] | ||
Number of website log ins (4) | Automatically tracked (4) | [33, 35, 40, 54] | ||
Number of automated calls (1) | Automatically tracked (1) | [48] | ||
Time spent on website (2) | Automatically tracked (2) | [40, 47] | ||
Number of pages viewed (2) | Automatically tracked (2) | [33, 40] | ||
Number of website modules read (1) | Participant self-report (1) | [40] | ||
Provider rating of satisfaction with delivery (2) | Provider self-report (2) | [50, 52] | ||
Number of intervention sessions delivered (5) | Audio observation (3) | [33, 34, 53, 65] | ||
Researcher observation (1) | [48] | |||
Provider self-report (1) | [48] | |||
Time of intervention sessions delivered (6) | Audio observation (3) | [33, 65], [34] [53] |
||
Provider self-report (3) | [52] [36] [43] |
|||
Percentage of intervention script adhered to (1) | Researcher observation (1) | [49] | ||
Assess non-specific treatment effects (6) | Rating of provider spirit/competence (4) | Audio observation (4) | [34, 37, 48, 53] | |
Participant rating of provider support (2) | Provider self-report (2) | [36, 39] | ||
Assess whether or not the active ingredients were delivered (15) | Rating of intervention components delivered (2) | Audio observation (1) | [43] | |
Provider self-report (1) | [43] | |||
Checklist of intervention components delivered (7) | Researcher observation (2) | [33, 51] | ||
Audio observation (1) | [48] | |||
Provider self-report (4) | [38, 42, 43, 52], | |||
Number of intervention components delivered (6) | Audio observation (5) | [34, 37, 38, 48, 53] | ||
Provider self-report (1) | [36] | |||
Assess whether or not proscribed components were delivered (e.g. components that were unnecessary or unhelpful) (3) | Number of proscribed intervention components delivered (3) | Audio observation (3) | [34, 37, 48] | |
Receipt of Treatment (4) | Assess degree to which participants understood intervention (1) | Participant perceived understanding of intervention skills (1) | Participant self-report (1) | [50] |
Assess participants ability to perform the intervention skills (3) | Participant demonstration of knowledge or skills acquired (1) | Researcher observation (1) | [49] | |
Participant perceived efficacy to perform intervention skills (2) | Participant self-report (2) | [38, 50] | ||
Enactment of treatment skills (8) | Assess participant performance of intervention skills in setting in which the intervention is applied (8) | Number of participants using intervention materials (e.g. log books, worksheets, pedometers) (3) | Participant Self report (2) | [32, 41] |
Automatically tracked (1) | [48] | |||
Number of times intervention materials used (e.g. log books, worksheets, pedometers, online self-monitoring) (2) | Automatically tracked (2) | [35, 53] | ||
Checklist of participant use of specified intervention techniques (e.g. action planning, self-monitoring) (2) | Participant Self report (2) | [35, 38] | ||
Participant rating of agreement with using intervention techniques (1) | Participant Self report (1) | [50] |
aSome studies contain multiple measurement approaches