Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 10;14(10):e1002399. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1002399

Table 6. Characteristics of misclassified and properly classified law-enforcement-related deaths in the National Vital Statistics System, based on incidents identified in The Counted (US, 2015).

Characteristic Misclassified cases Properly classified cases Total cases Percent misclassified (95% CI) p-Value (χ2 test of independence)1
Total sample 547 444 991 55.2% n/a
Individual-level characteristics
Age
Less than 18 years 11 5 16 68.8% (41.3, 89.0) 0.27
18 to 44 years 395 306 701 56.3% (52.6, 60.1)
45 years and older 141 130 271 52.0% (45.9, 58.1)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a
Gender
Men 526 429 955 55.1% (51.9, 58.3) 0.70
Women 21 15 36 58.3% (40.8, 74.9)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a
Race/ethnicity2
Black 162 103 265 61.1% (55.0, 67.0) 0.04
White 266 250 516 51.6% (47.1, 55.9)
Hispanic 97 67 164 59.1% (51.2, 66.7)
American Indian/Alaska Native 6 5 11 54.5% (23.4, 83.3)
Asian/Pacific Islander 8 13 21 38.1% (18.1, 61.2)
Missing 8 6 14 57.1% (28.9, 82.3)
Mechanism of death
Firearm 486 434 920 52.8% (49.5, 56.1) <0.01
Non-firearm 61 10 71 85.9% (75.6, 93.0)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a
County-level characteristics
Death investigator type
Medical examiner 320 262 582 55.0% (50.8, 59.1) 0.90
Coroner (elected) 212 168 380 55.8% (50.6, 60.9)
Coroner (appointed) 15 14 29 51.7% (32.5, 70.6)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a
Urbanization
Large metro–central 210 148 358 58.7% (53.4, 63.8) 0.32
Large metro–fringe 85 86 171 49.7% (42.0, 57.4)
Medium metro 129 94 223 57.8% (51.1, 64.4)
Small metro 35 35 70 50.0% (37.8, 62.2)
Micropolitan 37 34 71 52.1% (40.0, 64.1)
Non-core 51 47 98 52.0% (41.2, 62.2)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a
County median income (quintiles)
Q5 (highest income) 76 122 198 38.4% (31.6, 45.5) <0.01
Q4 111 78 189 58.7% (51.4, 65.8)
Q3 116 85 201 57.7% (50.6, 64.6)
Q2 124 72 196 63.3% (56.1, 70.0)
Q1 (lowest income) 120 87 207 58.0% (50.9, 64.8)
Missing 0 0 0 n/a

1p-Values are not adjusted for clustering and are therefore biased downward for county-level variables.

2Other than Hispanic, all races are non-Hispanic.

n/a, not applicable.