Table 1.
List of the reviewed studies
Article | Sample
|
Tasks
|
Group | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Number | Health condition | Age | Gender | Stature | Body mass | Direction | Range of motion | Pace of motion | ||
Paquet et al.20 | 10 | Low back pain | 41 | FB-BR | As far as possible | Slower than self-selected for normal and self-selected for patients | 1, 2 | |||
9 | Healthy | 41 | ||||||||
Gracovetsky et al.29 | 5 | Healthy | 24 | Male | BR | Up to fully bent posture | Self-selected | 4, 5 | ||
5 | Healthy | 24 | Female | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 35 | Male | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 35 | Female | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 45 | Male | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 45 | Female | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 55 | Male | |||||||
5 | Healthy | 55 | Female | |||||||
Nelson et al.30 | 30 | Healthy | 26 | Female | FB-BR | 90% of maximal FB | Self-selected | 5 | ||
Esola et al.7 | 14 | Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain | 32 | Male | 182 cm | 83 kg | FB | As far as possible | Self-selected | 3 |
6 | Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain | 24 | Female | 163 cm | 56 kg | |||||
13 | Healthy | 27 | Male | 177 cm | 78 kg | |||||
8 | Healthy | 29 | Female | 166 cm | 63 kg | |||||
McClure et al.21 | 12 | Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain | 34 | 180 cm | 79 kg | BR | Not instructed | Self-selected | 1, 3 | |
12 | Healthy | 29 | 172 cm | 69 kg | ||||||
Porter and Wilkinson26 | 15 | Patient | 27 | Male | FB- BR | As far as comfortably possible | Self-selected | 2 | ||
17 | Healthy | 27 | Male | |||||||
Tully et al.35 | 13 | Healthy | 26 | Male | 170 cm | FB | Up to touch the floor | Self-selected | 1 | |
9 | Healthy | 26 | Female | 170 cm | ||||||
Granata and Sanford12 | 13 | Healthy | 24 | Male | 171 cm | 77 kg | BR | From 90° to upright | 15, 30 and 60°/second | 1, 5, 6 |
5 | Healthy | 24 | Female | 171 cm | 77 kg | |||||
Lariviere et al.23 | 18 | Healthy | 40 | Male | 175 cm | 74 kg | FB-BR | Fully bent posture | One movement cycle lasted 5.45 seconds | 2 |
15 | Healthy | 40 | Female | 172 cm | 62 kg | |||||
Lee and Wong13 | 20 | Healthy | 20 | Male | 171 cm | 62 kg | FB-BR | As far as possible | Self-selected | 1 |
Wong and Lee14 | 20 | Healthy | 42 | 170 cm | 71 kg | FB-BR | As far as possible | Self-selected | 1, 2 | |
24 | Low back pain | 41 | Male | 172 cm | 69 kg | |||||
17 | Low back pain with restricted leg raise | 34 | Male | 174 cm | 71 kg | |||||
Pal et al.16 | 20 | Healthy | 21 | Male | 180 cm | 77 kg | FB-BR | As far as possible | Self-selected | 1 |
Thomas and Gibson15 | 8 | Healthy | 27 | Male | FB-BR | With knee flexion, to high, middle and low targets, and with knees extended, to a low target, and as far as possible | With knee flexion, self-selected, and with knees extended, twice the comfortable pace | 1, 4, 6 | ||
8 | Healthy | 26 | Female | |||||||
van Wingerden et al.24 | 29 | Low back pain with pelvic girdle pain | 33 | Female | FB-BR | As far as possible | Moderate pace | 2 | ||
22 | Low back pain | 36 | Female | |||||||
53 | Healthy | 25 | Female | |||||||
Silfies et al.22 | 23 | Healthy | 39 | Male | 170 cm | 73 kg | FB-BR | To reach a target in front of the participant’s trunk | 3 seconds reaching and 3 seconds returning | 2 |
12 | Healthy | 39 | Female | 170 cm | 73 kg | |||||
11 | Low back pain | 41 | Male | 180 cm | 85 kg | |||||
19 | Low back pain | 41 | Female | 180 cm | 85 kg | |||||
Kim et al.25 | 16 | Healthy | 24 | 169 cm | 61 kg | FB-BR | Fully flexed position, then to the initial position | 3 seconds bending, 3 seconds returning | 2 | |
17 | Low back pain (lumbar flexion with rotation syndrome) | 23 | 173 cm | 67 kg | ||||||
14 | Low back pain (lumbar extension with rotation syndrome) | 24 | 169 cm | 65 kg | ||||||
Hasebe et al.19 | 18 | Healthy | 36 | Male | 171 cm | 67 kg | FB | To touch toes | Self-selected | 1 |
Hu et al.32 | 12 | Healthy | 26 | Male | 172 cm | 77 kg | BR | Full flexion to upright | Self-selected | 5 |
Iwasaki et al.31 | 16 | Healthy | 22 | Male | BR | Not instructed | Self-selected | 5 | ||
10 | Healthy | 22 | Female | |||||||
Lariviere et al.23 | 10 | Healthy | 26 | Male | 180 cm | 80 kg | FB-BR | As far as possible | 4 seconds bending and 4 seconds returning | 2 |
10 | Healthy | 27 | Female | 168 cm | 65 kg | |||||
Phillips et al.33 | 6 | Healthy | 27 | Male | 179 cm | 79 kg | FB | To touch toes | As fast as possible, and Metronome 60 beats/minute | 5, 7 |
6 | Healthy | 27 | Female | 166 cm | 62 kg | |||||
Tafazzol et al.9 | 8 | Healthy | 25 | Male | 181 cm | 80 kg | FB-BR | To their maximum voluntary bending | Self-selected | 1 |
Hu and Ning8 | 13 | Healthy | 27 | Male | 175 cm | 69 kg | FB-BR | To 40 cm from the center of ankles | Self-selected | 5, 7 |
Hu and Ning34 | 15 | Healthy | 26 | Male | 173 cm | 77 kg | FB-BR | To 40 cm from the center of ankles | Self-selected | 7 |
Pries et al.27 | 134 | Healthy | 38 | Male | 180 cm | 75 kg | FB | As far as possible | Self-selected | 4 |
175 | Healthy | 38 | Female | 167 cm | 61 kg | |||||
Vazirian et al.11 | 6 | Healthy | 25 | Male | 178 cm | 79 kg | FB-BR | As far as possible | Self-selected, and as fast as possible | 4, 6 |
6 | Healthy | 25 | Female | 165 cm | 61 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 35 | Male | 173 cm | 81 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 35 | Female | 167 cm | 65 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 45 | Male | 180 cm | 88 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 45 | Female | 166 cm | 71 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 55 | Male | 181 cm | 85 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 55 | Female | 164 cm | 71 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 65 | Male | 178 cm | 84 kg | |||||
6 | Healthy | 65 | Female | 165 cm | 65 kg |
Letter codes under Tasks column denote: FB: forward bending, BR: backward return.
Number codes under Group column denote study of LPR are related to (1) healthy control population,( 2) current LBP, (3) history of LBP, (4) age/gender, (5) handling of external load, (6) motion pace and (7) muscle fatigue. See summary of results for details.