Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Oct 12.
Published in final edited form as: Int Musculoskelet Med. 2016 Nov 28;38(2):51–58. doi: 10.1080/17536146.2016.1241525

Table 1.

List of the reviewed studies

Article Sample
Tasks
Group
Number Health condition Age Gender Stature Body mass Direction Range of motion Pace of motion
Paquet et al.20 10 Low back pain 41 FB-BR As far as possible Slower than self-selected for normal and self-selected for patients 1, 2
9 Healthy 41
Gracovetsky et al.29 5 Healthy 24 Male BR Up to fully bent posture Self-selected 4, 5
5 Healthy 24 Female
5 Healthy 35 Male
5 Healthy 35 Female
5 Healthy 45 Male
5 Healthy 45 Female
5 Healthy 55 Male
5 Healthy 55 Female
Nelson et al.30 30 Healthy 26 Female FB-BR 90% of maximal FB Self-selected 5
Esola et al.7 14 Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain 32 Male 182 cm 83 kg FB As far as possible Self-selected 3
6 Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain 24 Female 163 cm 56 kg
13 Healthy 27 Male 177 cm 78 kg
8 Healthy 29 Female 166 cm 63 kg
McClure et al.21 12 Asymptomatic with a history of low back pain 34 180 cm 79 kg BR Not instructed Self-selected 1, 3
12 Healthy 29 172 cm 69 kg
Porter and Wilkinson26 15 Patient 27 Male FB- BR As far as comfortably possible Self-selected 2
17 Healthy 27 Male
Tully et al.35 13 Healthy 26 Male 170 cm FB Up to touch the floor Self-selected 1
9 Healthy 26 Female 170 cm
Granata and Sanford12 13 Healthy 24 Male 171 cm 77 kg BR From 90° to upright 15, 30 and 60°/second 1, 5, 6
5 Healthy 24 Female 171 cm 77 kg
Lariviere et al.23 18 Healthy 40 Male 175 cm 74 kg FB-BR Fully bent posture One movement cycle lasted 5.45 seconds 2
15 Healthy 40 Female 172 cm 62 kg
Lee and Wong13 20 Healthy 20 Male 171 cm 62 kg FB-BR As far as possible Self-selected 1
Wong and Lee14 20 Healthy 42 170 cm 71 kg FB-BR As far as possible Self-selected 1, 2
24 Low back pain 41 Male 172 cm 69 kg
17 Low back pain with restricted leg raise 34 Male 174 cm 71 kg
Pal et al.16 20 Healthy 21 Male 180 cm 77 kg FB-BR As far as possible Self-selected 1
Thomas and Gibson15 8 Healthy 27 Male FB-BR With knee flexion, to high, middle and low targets, and with knees extended, to a low target, and as far as possible With knee flexion, self-selected, and with knees extended, twice the comfortable pace 1, 4, 6
8 Healthy 26 Female
van Wingerden et al.24 29 Low back pain with pelvic girdle pain 33 Female FB-BR As far as possible Moderate pace 2
22 Low back pain 36 Female
53 Healthy 25 Female
Silfies et al.22 23 Healthy 39 Male 170 cm 73 kg FB-BR To reach a target in front of the participant’s trunk 3 seconds reaching and 3 seconds returning 2
12 Healthy 39 Female 170 cm 73 kg
11 Low back pain 41 Male 180 cm 85 kg
19 Low back pain 41 Female 180 cm 85 kg
Kim et al.25 16 Healthy 24 169 cm 61 kg FB-BR Fully flexed position, then to the initial position 3 seconds bending, 3 seconds returning 2
17 Low back pain (lumbar flexion with rotation syndrome) 23 173 cm 67 kg
14 Low back pain (lumbar extension with rotation syndrome) 24 169 cm 65 kg
Hasebe et al.19 18 Healthy 36 Male 171 cm 67 kg FB To touch toes Self-selected 1
Hu et al.32 12 Healthy 26 Male 172 cm 77 kg BR Full flexion to upright Self-selected 5
Iwasaki et al.31 16 Healthy 22 Male BR Not instructed Self-selected 5
10 Healthy 22 Female
Lariviere et al.23 10 Healthy 26 Male 180 cm 80 kg FB-BR As far as possible 4 seconds bending and 4 seconds returning 2
10 Healthy 27 Female 168 cm 65 kg
Phillips et al.33 6 Healthy 27 Male 179 cm 79 kg FB To touch toes As fast as possible, and Metronome 60 beats/minute 5, 7
6 Healthy 27 Female 166 cm 62 kg
Tafazzol et al.9 8 Healthy 25 Male 181 cm 80 kg FB-BR To their maximum voluntary bending Self-selected 1
Hu and Ning8 13 Healthy 27 Male 175 cm 69 kg FB-BR To 40 cm from the center of ankles Self-selected 5, 7
Hu and Ning34 15 Healthy 26 Male 173 cm 77 kg FB-BR To 40 cm from the center of ankles Self-selected 7
Pries et al.27 134 Healthy 38 Male 180 cm 75 kg FB As far as possible Self-selected 4
175 Healthy 38 Female 167 cm 61 kg
Vazirian et al.11 6 Healthy 25 Male 178 cm 79 kg FB-BR As far as possible Self-selected, and as fast as possible 4, 6
6 Healthy 25 Female 165 cm 61 kg
6 Healthy 35 Male 173 cm 81 kg
6 Healthy 35 Female 167 cm 65 kg
6 Healthy 45 Male 180 cm 88 kg
6 Healthy 45 Female 166 cm 71 kg
6 Healthy 55 Male 181 cm 85 kg
6 Healthy 55 Female 164 cm 71 kg
6 Healthy 65 Male 178 cm 84 kg
6 Healthy 65 Female 165 cm 65 kg

Letter codes under Tasks column denote: FB: forward bending, BR: backward return.

Number codes under Group column denote study of LPR are related to (1) healthy control population,( 2) current LBP, (3) history of LBP, (4) age/gender, (5) handling of external load, (6) motion pace and (7) muscle fatigue. See summary of results for details.