Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 6;7(10):e014626. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014626

Table 2.

Input data

Parameter Value Distribution Source
Demographic
 Age 25–65 based on distribution NA National Statistics (INSEE)
 CMU-c eligibility (social status) 12.2% (9.8%–14.6%) Normal National Health Insurance Data
 IndScr participation periodicity Based on frequency distribution, age and social Uniform National Health Insurance Data
 Initial Health State Based on distribution NA Based on model prediction for a cohort of 14-year-old women
Transition probabilities
 HR-HPV infection 0.03–0.15 (0.03–0.18) based on distribution Beta Estimated to reproduce known prevalence by age11
 HPV-infection regression 0.50 (0.40–0.60) Beta Riethmuller et al,18 Clavel et al,22 Boulanger et al,23 Beby-Defaux et al,24 Dalstein et al25
 HR-HPV infection→CIN1 0.05 (0.04–0.06) Beta Moscicki et al26
 CIN1 regression 0.50 (0.40–0.60) Beta Melnikow et al,27 Nobbenhuis et al,28 Sanders and Taira,29 Van De Velde et al30
 CIN1→CIN2/3 0.12 (0.10–0.14) Beta Melnikow et al,27 Sanders and Taira,29 Van De Velde et al30
 CIN2/3 regression 0.28 (0.22–0.33) Beta Melnikow et al27
 CIN2/3→pCIN2/3 0.13 (0.10–0.15) Beta Melnikow et al27
 Persistent CIN2/3→FIGO I 0.01–0.05 (0.01–0.06) based on distribution Beta Estimated to reproduce known prevalence by age1 11
 FIGO I→FIGO II 0.20 (0.16–0.24) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO II→FIGO III 0.26 (0.21–0.31) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO III→FIGO IV 0.36 (0.29–0.43) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO I→Symptomatic FIGO I 0.15 (0.12–0.18) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO II→Symptomatic FIGO II 0.23 (0.18–0.27) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO IIISymptomatic FIGO III 0.60 (0.48–0.71) Beta Myers et al12
 FIGO VISymptomatic FIGO IV 0.90 (0.67–1.00) Beta Myers et al12
 1-year cancer survival 0.43–0.98 (0.23–0.99) by stage Beta SEER13
 5-year cancer survival 0.14–0.94 (0.06–0.97) by stage Beta SEER13
 10-year cancer survival 0.05–0.93 (0.01–0.96) by stage Beta SEER13
Screening
 Participation after invitation 17.3% (10.0%–24.0%)%) Uniform Hamers et al5
 Participation after recall 12.1% (5.0%–18.0%)%) Uniform Hamers et al5
 Lost to follow-up with IndScr Based on lesion on Pap. Average 27.7% NA Hamers et al5
 Reduction in lost to follow-up with OS 0.77 (0.08–0.77) Uniform OS experimentations, INCa personal communication
 Lesions on PAP Distribution NA Hamers et al.5
 Care per lesion Distribution NA Hamers et al.5
 Primary Pap test (SE) 70.0% (57.0%–80.0%) Beta Mustafa et al14
 Confirmation Pap test after HPV+ (Se) 85.9% (76.6%–92.1%) Beta Bergeron et al8
 Primary HPV test (Se) 94.0% (89.0%–97.0%) Beta Mustafa et al14
 Confirmation HPV test after Pap+ (Se) 100.0% (NR) NA Mayrand et al16
 p16/Ki67 (Se) 86.7% (81.1%–90.9%) Beta Ikenberg et al15
 Colposcopy (Se) 100.0% (NA) NA Assumption
 Primary Pap test (Sp) 95.0% (92.0%–97.0%) Beta Mustafa et al14
 Confirmation Pap test after HPV+ (Sp) 65.9% (63.1%–68.6%) Beta Bergeron et al8
 Primary HPV test (Sp) 90.0% (86.0%–93.0%) Beta Mustafa et al14
 Confirmation HPV test after Pap+ (Sp) 61.1% (NR) NA Mayrand et al16
 p16/Ki67 (Sp) 95.2% (94.9%–95.4%) Beta Ikenberg et al15
 Colposcopy (Sp) 100.0% (NA) NA Assumption
 Conisation efficacy 95.0% NA Assumption
 Non-interpretable tests 1.0% (1.0%–3.0%)%) Uniform Hamers et al5
Costs (€)
 Pap test (IndScr) 47.78 (38.88–57.59) Gamma National tariffs
 Pap test (OS) 49.62 (40.37–59.81) Gamma National tariffs
 p16/Ki67 (IndScr) 86.77 (70.60–104.58) Gamma National tariffs
 p16/Ki67 (OS) 88.61 (72.09–106.80) Gamma National tariffs
 HPV test (IndScr) 47.70 (75.48–97.17) Gamma National tariffs
 HPV test (OS) 49.54 (49.54–71.24) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation Pap test (IndScr) 78.17 (63.60–94.21) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation Pap test (OS) 49.63 (40.38–59.82) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation p16/Ki67 (IndScr) 116.77 (78.09–99.57) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation p16/Ki67 (OS) 88.23 (71.79–106.34) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation HPV test (IndScr) 78.09 (63.53–94.12) Gamma National tariffs
 Confirmation HPV test (OS) 49.55 (49.55–71.03) Gamma National tariffs
 Colposcopy 49.82 (40.54–60.05) Gamma National tariffs
 Conisation 93.42 (76.01–112.60) Gamma National tariffs
 FIGO I CC treatment 1041.95 (847.77–1255.85) Gamma Dervaux et al11
 FIGO II CC treatment 1818.86 (1479.90–2192.25) Gamma Dervaux et al11
 FIGO III CC treatment 25 817.84 (21 006.43–31 117.97) Gamma Dervaux et al11
 FIGO IV CC treatment 30 582.83 (24 883.41–36 861.16) Gamma Dervaux et al11
 Database management+invitation dispatch 7.00 (4.00–11.00) Gamma Cost of invitation to colorectal OS (Heath Ministry data, personal communication)
 Recall dispatch 0.40 (0.40–3.25) Gamma 50% postal charges

CIN, cervical intraepithelial neoplasia; CC, cervical cancer; CMU, French Universal health insurance for low-income people; FIGO, Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics; HPV, human papillomavirus; HR, High Risk; IndScr, individual screening; INCa, French national cancer institute; NA, Not applicable; OS, organised screening; Pap, Papanicolaou; SEER, Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program.