Table 2.
Characteristics of included studies
First author | Population | Design | Age, years |
Number | Time of follow-up |
Method of dietary assessment |
Measurement of cereal consumption |
Industry funding |
Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gibson [16] | Britain | cross-sectional | 10–15 | 2,705 | 7-day weighed intakes | 4 categories of consumption |
Kellogg's | mean BMI*, energy intakes | |
McNulty [19] | Northern Ireland |
cross-sectional | 12–15 | 1,015 | diet history | 4 categories of consumption |
Kellogg's | mean BMI, energy intakes | |
Ortega [20] | Spain | cross-sectional | 9–13 | 200 | 7-day food record | obese and non- obese consumption |
Danone | cereal consumption | |
Albertson [13] | USA | cross-sectional | 4–12 | 603 | 14-day food diaries | 3 categories of consumption |
General Mills | mean BMI, % overweight, energy intakes |
|
Gibson [5] | Britain | cross-sectional | 4–18 | 1,688 | 7-day weighed intakes | 4 categories of consumption |
Kellogg's | mean BMI*, energy intakes | |
Barton [28] | USA | prospective | 9–10 | 2,379 | 10 years | yearly 3-day food records |
4 categories of consumption |
General Mills | BMI z-scores, OR for overweight |
Kafatos [17] | Greece | cross-sectional | 14–16 | 392 | 24-hour recall + frequency of RTEC consumption |
3 categories of consumption |
Kellogg's | mean BMI, energy intakes | |
Kosti [18] | Greece | cross-sectional | 12–17 | 2,008 | semi-quantitative FFQ | 6 categories of consumption |
Cereal partners | mean BMI, OR for overweight | |
Panagiotakos [21] |
Greece | cross-sectional | 10–12 | 700 | semi-quantitative FFQ | RTEC breakfast consumers vs. other breakfast |
OR for overweight | ||
Rosado [24] | Mexico | intervention | 6–12 | 147 | 12 weeks | diet not assessed | 3 intervention groups + control |
Kellogg's | mean BMI |
Williams [22] | USA, African- American |
cross-sectional | 1–12 | 1,389 | 24-hour recall | RTEC breakfast consumers vs. breakfast skippers |
Kellogg's | mean BMI, BMI for age z score, % obese, energy intakes |
|
Albertson[23] | USA | prospective | 8–10 | 660 | 7.5 years | 3 24-hour recalls each visit |
4 categories of consumption |
General Mills | mean BMI, BMI z score, energy intakes |
Deshmukh- Taskar [15] |
USA | cross-sectional | 9–18 | 9,659 | 24-hour recall | RTEC breakfast consumers vs. breakfast skippers |
Kellogg's | mean BMI**, BMI z score, % obese, energy intakes |
|
Albertson [14] | USA | cross-sectional | 6–18 | 9,660 | 24-hour recall | 4 categories of consumption |
General Mills |
Original data re-analysed by author (SG);
Data on Mean BMI supplied by author