Table 1.
ASD vs. schizophrenia vs. normal controls | ASD vs. schizophrenia | ASD vs. normal controls | Schizophrenia vs. normal controls | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Whole brain | g×BA | F82, 4797=2.20, p<0.0000001 (0.0005)* | F41, 2583=1.57, p<0.01 (0.35) | F41, 3157=2.23, p=0.00001 (0.005)* | F41, 3813=2.60, p<0.0000001 (0.01) |
Frontal lobe | ME | F2, 117=4.91, p=0.009 | F1, 93=9.88, p=0.002* | ||
g×BA | F20, 1170=2.54, p=0.0002 (0.002)* | F10, 930=5.38, p<0.0000001 (0.0036)* | |||
Parietal lobe | ME | F2, 117=3.36, p=0.04 | F1, 77=4.51, p=0.037 | ||
g×BA | F14, 819=3.47, p=0.000002 (0.000005)* | F7, 441=1.99, p=0.055 (0.09) | F7, 539=3.43, p=0.001 (0.000009)* | F7, 651=5.70, p=0.000002 (0.00015)* | |
Occipital lobe | g×BA | F4, 234=2.52, p=0.04 (0.05) | F2, 186=3.90, p=0.02 (0.09) | ||
Hippocampus | ME | F2, 117=9.71, p=0.0001* | F1, 77=13.76, p=0.0004* | F1, 93=18.22, p=0.00005* | |
Hypothalamus | ME | F2, 117=4.08, p=0.02 | F1, 63=7.05, p=0.01 | F1, 93=6.26, p=0.007 | |
Mammilary bodies | F1, 63=4.38, p=0.04 | ||||
Thalamic nuclei | |||||
Lateral posterior | ME | F2, 117=6.35, p=0.002* | F1, 63=3.84, p=0.055 | F1, 93=10.85, p=0.001* | |
Ventral posteromedial | ME | F2, 117=2.59, p=0.08 | F1, 93=5.10, p=0.026 | ||
Ventral posterolateral | ME | F2, 117=4.34, p=0.015 | F1, 93=7.93, p=0.006 | ||
Pulvinar | ME | F2, 117=4.06, p=0.02 | F1, 93=7.62, p=0.007 | ||
Mediodorsal | ME | F2, 117=2.50, p=0.09 | F1, 93=4.07, p=0.047 | ||
Caudate subdivisions | g×R | F4, 234=10.15, p<0.0000001 (0.000035)* | F2, 154=6.41, p=0.002 (0.01) | F2, 186=18.64, p<0.00000001 (0.000007)* | |
Head of the caudate | ME | F2, 117=2.64, p=0.08 | F1, 93=4.92, p=0.03 | ||
Tail of the caudate | ME | F2, 117=10.87, p=0.00005* | F1, 77=9.69, p=0.003* | F1, 93=25.79, p=0.000002* | |
Putamen | ME | F2, 117=6.18, p=0.003* | F1, 77=5.76, p=0.02 | F1, 93=11.62, p=0.001* | |
Medial globus pallidus | ME | F2, 117=4.18, p=0.02 | F1, 77=7.80, p=0.007 | ||
Lateral globus pallidus | ME | F2, 117=4.83, p=0.01 | F1, 77=8.52, p=0.005 | F1, 93=4.67, p=0.03 | |
Claustrum | ME | F2, 117=10.36, p=0.00007* | F1, 77=13.14, p=0.0005* | F1, 93=16.86, p=0.00009* | |
Amygdala | ME | F2, 117=4.87, p=0.009 | F1, 77=7.48, p=0.008 | F1, 93=8.09, p=0.0055 |
For all higher-order ANCOVA interactions (i.e. other than the main effects) univariate p-values are followed by multivariate Wilks’ λ p-values in parentheses; p-values at trend level of significance (<0.1) are italicized. Abbreviations: ME – main effect of diagnostic group, g×R – group-by-region interaction, g×BA – group-by-Brodmann area interaction.
MANOVA interactions that met the Bonferroni correction are indicated by asterisks. The frontal and parietal lobe group×Brodmann area interactions met the Bonferroni criteria for four brain lobes and two hemispheres (0.05/8=0.00625). We chose all ANOVAs (three diagnostic groups and the 3 paired comparisons by four lobes, 4 x 4=16) as a divisor, but note that this correction could be considered to be spuriously failing to replicate published findings in schizophrenia and autism literature. For the 16 subcortical regions, at the p<0.05 level the three-group main effect was significant for 15 out of 16 tests, the main effect of group for healthy controls vs. schizophrenia comparisons was significant in 14 out of 16 tests, and the main effect of group for healthy controls vs ASD comparisons was significant in 9 out of 16 tests. The Bonferroni correction criterion for 16 subcortical regions was 0.00315 (0.05/16).