Table 1.
Placebo-controlled, randomized, double-blind clinical trials of glutamate-modulating drugs as monotherapy or augmentation of the existing psychotropic regimen in OCD.
Study & Drug | Duration & Dose |
Adjunctive/
Monotherapy |
Subjects | Treatment Resistance at Baseline |
Endpoint Results on
Efficacy |
Side Effects | Effect on Primary Outcome: (Yes/no) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Riluzole | ||||||||||||||
Grant et al., 2014 | 12 weeks Final dose: 100 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
60 pediatric OCD patients (17 with comorbid ASD) |
Yes | No significant differences in change of CY-BOCS, CGAS, CGI-I and CGI-S scores between the placebo and riluzole groups at the end of the trial | Mainly well tolerated 1 pancreatitis case 5 transaminases elevation cases |
CY-BOCS score change: no CGI-I score change: no CGI-S score change: no CGAS score change: no |
|||||||
Pittenger et al., 2015 | 12 weeks + 2 weeks lead-on placebo Final dose: 100 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
38 adult OCD patients (27 outpatients and 11 inpatients) |
Yes | No significant difference in Y-BOCS scores change between the placebo and riluzole groups at the end of the trial Among OCD outpatients only significantly more achieved at least partial treatment response with adjunctive riluzole. |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS score change: no | |||||||
Emamzadehfard et al., 2016 | 10 weeks Final dose: 100 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: fluvoxamine |
50 adult OCD patients | Significant greater reduction of Y-BOCS total and compulsions scores between the placebo and riluzole groups at the end of the trial | Well tolerated | Y-BOCS score change: yes | ||||||||
Memantine | ||||||||||||||
Ghaleiha et al., 2013 | 8 weeks Final dose: 20 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: fluvoxamine |
42 adult OCD patients | No | Greater reduction of Y-BOCS scores in the memantine group at the end of the trial (p = 0.006) | Well tolerated | Y-BOCS score change: yes | |||||||
Haghighi et al., 2013 | 12 weeks Dose: 5-10 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
40 adult OCD patients | No | Greater reduction of Y-BOCS scores in the memantine group at the end of the trial (p = 0.005) |
Well tolerated | Not predefined Y-BOCS score change: yes |
|||||||
Ketamine | ||||||||||||||
Rodriguez et al., 2013 |
Ketamine & saline i.v. infused at least 1 week apart in random order Dose: 0.5 mg/kg |
Monotherapy | 15 adult OCD patients (2 with mild or moderate comorbid depression) |
Part of the sample | Greater reduction in Y-BOCS scores for subjects receiving ketamine as first infusion at 7 days post infusion (p < 0.01) Obsession symptoms severity (OCD-VAS score) with ketamine significantly lower at mid-infusion, 230 min and 7 days post infusion compared to the saline group |
Mild increase in blood pressure and pulse Dissociation, psychotic and manic symptoms, time perception distortion, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, headache |
Not predefined Y-BOCS score change: yes for ketamine as first infusion OCD-VAS score change: yes |
|||||||
Glycine | ||||||||||||||
Greenberg et al., 2009 |
12 weeks Final dose: 60 g/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: stable psycho- pharmacological or psychotherapeutic treatment |
24 adult OCD patients | Not specified | Reduction of Y-BOCS scores in the glycine compared to the placebo group at the endpoint showed a trend towards significance (p = 0.053) | High drop-out rate related to glycine’s unpleasant taste and nausea |
Y-BOCS score change: no (strong trend towards significance) | |||||||
Study & Drug | Duration & Dose |
Adjunctive/ Monotherapy |
Subjects | Treatment Resistance at Baseline |
Endpoint Results on Efficacy |
Side Effects | Effect on Primary Outcome: (Yes/no) | |||||||
Topiramate | ||||||||||||||
Mowla et al., 2010 | 12 weeks Dose: 100-200 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: existing treatment regimen |
49 adult OCD patients | Yes | Y-BOCS score mean decrease 32.0% in the topiramate group vs. 2.4% in the placebo group (p < 0.05) | Y-BOCS score change: yes | ||||||||
Berlin et al., 2011 | 12 weeks Dose: 50-400 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SSRI |
36 adult OCD patients | Yes | No significant treatment effect of topiramate on total Y-BOCS scores (p = 0.11) or obsessions subscores (p = 0.99) Significant treatment effect of topiramate on Y-BOCS compulsions subscores (p = 0.014). |
Due to adverse effects 28% discontinuation and 39% dose reduction in the topiramate group Weight loss, influenza-like symptoms, taste perversion, paresthesia, memory difficulty |
Y-BOCS total score change: no Y-BOCS obsessions subscore change: no Y-BOCS compulsions subscore change: yes |
|||||||
Afshar et al., 2014 | 12 weeks Dose range: 100-200 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
38 adult OCD patients | Yes | No significant difference in Y-BOCS scores between the topiramate and placebo group at the end of the study (p = 0.058) Y-BOCS scores were significantly lower in the topiramate vs. the placebo group at weeks 4 (p = 0.01) and 8 (p = 0.01) of the trial. |
2 patients dropped out due to adverse effects. Paresthesia, cognitive problems, weight loss, micturation frequency, renal stone, decreased appetite |
Y-BOCS score change at the end of the trial: no (strong trend towards significance) Treatment response: no (strong trend) |
|||||||
Lamotrigine | ||||||||||||||
Bruno et al., 2012 | 16 weeks Final dose: 100 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
40 (final sample 33) adult OCD patients | Yes | Lamotrigine was associated with greater reduction of Y-BOCS (p < 0.0001) and HDRS scores (p < 0.0001) at endpoint. Lamotrigine was associated with lower CGI-S scores at the end of the trial (p < 0.0001). |
Well tolerated Sedation, fatigue, headache, skin rash |
Y-BOCS score change: yes CGI-S score difference: yes HDRS score change: yes |
|||||||
Khalkhali et al., 2016 | 12 weeks Final dose: 100 mg/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
53 adult OCD patients | Yes | Lamotrigine was associated with greater reduction of the total Y-BOCS score (p = 0.007), as well as the obsessions (p = 0.01) and compulsions subscales (p = 0.005). |
Well tolerated Headache, skin rash |
Y-BOCS score change: yes | |||||||
N-acetylcysteine | ||||||||||||||
Afshar et al., 2012 | 12 weeks Dose: up to 2.4 g/day |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
48 adult OCD patients | Yes | Greater reduction of Y-BOCS scores in the NAC compared to the placebo group at the end of the trial (p = 0.003) Significantly more patients in the NAC compared to the placebo group were responders (p = 0.013). |
Well tolerated Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea |
Y-BOCS change: yes Treatment response rate: yes |
|||||||
Study & Drug | Duration & Dose |
Adjunctive/ Monotherapy |
Subjects | Treatment Resistance at Baseline | Endpoint Results on Efficacy | Side Effects | Effect on Primary Outcome: (Yes/no) | |||||||
N-acetylcysteine | ||||||||||||||
Sarris et al., 2015 | 16 weeks Dose: 3 g/day |
Monotherapy or adjunctive Initial treatment: existing stable treatment regimen or monotherapy |
44 adult OCD patients | Not specified | No significant difference in Y-BOCS scores changes between the NAC and placebo group at the end of the study |
Well tolerated Heartburn |
Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
Paydary et al., 2016 | 10 weeks Dose: 2 g/d |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: fluvoxamine |
44 adult OCD patients | Greater reduction of Y- BOCS total scores (p = 0.012) and obsessions subscale (p = 0.011) in the NAC compared to the placebo group at the end of the trial |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: yes | ||||||||
Costa et al., 2017 | 16 weeks Dose: 3 g/d |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: SRI |
40 adult OCD patients | Yes | No significant difference in Y-BOCS scores changes between the NAC and placebo group at the end of the study Some benefit in reducing anxiety symptoms in the NAC group |
Well tolerated Abdominal pain |
Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
Minocycline | ||||||||||||||
Esalatmanesh et al., 2016 | 10 weeks Dose: 200 mg/d |
Adjunctive Initial treatment: fluvoxamine |
102 adult OCD patients | No | Greater reduction of Y-BOCS total scores (p = 0.003), the obsession subscale (p = 0.001) and greater response rate in the minocycline group at the end of the trial |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: yes |
Abbreviations: ADIS = Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule, ASD = autism spectrum disorder, CBT = cognitive behavioural therapy, CSR = clinical severity rating, CY-BOCS = Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale, CGAS = Children's Global Assessment Scale, CGI-I = Clinical Global Impression – Improvement, CGI-S = Clinical Global Impression - Severity, GOCS = Global Obsessive-Compulsive Scale, HDRS = Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, NAC = N-acetylcysteine, OCD-VAS = OCD visual analog scale, SSRI = selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor, SUDS = Subjective Units of Distress Scale, Y-BOCS = Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale.