Table 2.
Placebo-controlled, randomized, double-blind clinical trials of d-cycloserie as augmentation of psychotherapy in OCD patients
| Study & Drug | Duration, dose and Temporal Relationship to CBT Sessions | Subjects | Mode of Therapy | Endpoint Results on Efficacy | Side Effects | Effect on Primary Outcome: (yes/no) | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studies in adults | |||||||||||||
| Storch et al., 2007 | 12 CBT sessions with DCS 4 h prior to each session Dose: 250 mg/CBT session |
24 adult OCD patients | In person 1 session hierarchy and education, 1 session practice exposure and 9 sessions exposure and response prevention exercises |
No significant difference between the DCS and placebo groups in terms of OCD severity post-treatment. | Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
| Kushner et al., 2007 | 10 CBT sessions with DCS 2 h prior to each session Dose: 125 mg/CBT session |
25 adult OCD patients | In person Hierarchy at baseline, 10 sessions of exposure/ritual prevention techniques |
No differences in Y-BOCS scores or between the DCS and placebo groups at the end of the trial. The DCS group achieved > 50% SUDS scores reduction significantly faster and showed improved compliance. |
Well tolerated Mild gastrointestinal distress, fatigue, anxiety and dizziness |
Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
| Wilhelm et al., 2008 | 10 CBT sessions with DCS 1 h before each session Dose: 100 mg/CBT session |
23 adult OCD patients (Including patients with continuing stable psychotropic treatment regimen) |
In person 1 psychoeducational /treatment planning session, 10 behavior therapy sessions |
No significant differences in Y-BOCS scores between the DCS and placebo groups at post-treatment (p = 0.14) or 1 month follow up (p = 0.12) Significantly lower Y-BOCS scores in the DCS group at mid-treatment (p = 0.009) Significantly fewer depressive symptoms at post-treatment (p=0.04) |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: no at post-treatment or 1 mo follow up; yes at mid-treatment | |||||||
| Andersson et al., 2015 | DCS 1 h before 5 CBT tasks during a 12 weeks internet-based CBT Dose: 50 mg/CBT task |
128 adult OCD outpatients (In some stable antidepressant regimen) |
Therapist-supported internet 12 weeks of therapist-supported internet-based CBT |
No difference between the DCS and placebo group in Y-BOCS scores at the trial end and 3 months follow up In the DCS group significantly more antidepressant-free patients achieved remission at the trial’s end compared to antidepressant-medicated patients (p = 0.008). |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
| de Leeuw et al., 2017 | 6 guided exposure sessions with DCS 1 h before each session Dose: 125 mg/session |
39 adult OCD patients | In person 6 weekly guided exposure sessions |
No significant difference in the Y-BOCS score change between the groups at the end of the trial, although decrease in DCS group was numerically greater (p = 0.076). A significant effect of DCS in the “cleaning/contamination” subgroup (p = 0.033). |
Well tolerated | Y-BOCS change: no | |||||||
| Studies in children and adolescents | |||||||||||||
| Storch et al., 2010 | 10 CBT sessions with DCS 1 h before each session for 7 of the sessions Dose: weight-adjusted |
30 children and adolescents with OCD | In person 10 CBT sessions including psychoeducation, cognitive therapy, hierarchy development, and ERP |
No significant differences in CY-BOCS and ADIS-CSR scores changes at the end of the trial. | Well tolerated | CY-BOCS: no CGI-S: significant time and group, but no significant time by group interaction ADIS-CSR: no |
|||||||
| Study & Drug | Duration, dose and Temporal Relationship to CBT Sessions | Subjects | Mode of Therapy | Endpoint Results on Efficacy | Side Effects | Effect on Primary Outcome: (yes/no) | |||||||
| Studies in children and adolescents | |||||||||||||
| Farrell et al., 2013 | 9 CBT sessions with DCS 1 h before each of 5 sessions Dose: weight-adjusted |
17 children and adolescents with OCD | In person 9 CBT sessions, including 4 sessions with instruction on cognitive-behavioural techniques and 5 ERP sessions |
No significant difference in CY-BOCS between the DCS and placebo groups at the end of the trial Greater improvement from end of the trial until 1 month follow up in the DCS compared to the placebo group was detected for CY-BOCS obsessions subscale (p < 0.05), GOCS scale (p < 0.05) and CGI-S (p = 0.05). |
Well tolerated | CY-BOCS scores: no at post treatment or 2 mo follow up; yes at 1 mo follow up for some of the measures CSR: no GOCS: yes at 1 mo follow up; no at post treatment or 3 mo follow up CGI-S: yes at 1 mo follow up; no at post treatment or 3 mo follow up |
|||||||
| Mataix-Cols et al., 2014 | 14 CBT sessions, 10 of them with DCS immediately after each session Dose: 50 mg |
27 children and adolescents with OCD (In some patients stable psychotropic regimen) |
In person 14-session manualised treatment, including 2 sessions psychoeducation, 10 sessions ERP and 2 sessions relapse prevention. |
No significant differences in CY-BOCS scores between the DCS and placebo group at any time point | Well tolerated | CY-BOCS change: no | |||||||
| Storch et al., 2016 | 10 CBT sessions with DCS administered 1 h prior to 7 of the sessions Dose: weight-adjusted |
142 children and adolescents with OCD | In person 10 CBT sessions |
No significant difference in the rate of CY-BOCS scores decline between the groups. No moderation effect for antidepressant medication observed. |
Well tolerated | CY-BOCS change: no | |||||||
Abbreviations: ADIS = Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule, ASD = autism spectrum disorder, CBT = cognitive behavioural therapy, CSR = clinical severity rating, CY-BOCS = Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale, CGAS = Children's Global Assessment Scale, CGI-I = Clinical Global Impression – Improvement, CGI-S = Clinical Global Impression - Severity, GOCS = Global Obsessive-Compulsive Scale, HDRS = Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, NAC = N-acetylcysteine, OCD-VAS = OCD visual analog scale, SSRI = selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor, SUDS = Subjective Units of Distress Scale, Y-BOCS = Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale.