Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 23;12(10):e0186949. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0186949

Table 2. Average dice coefficients, sensitivity and precision of the proposed method in Optima dataset.

GC [43] KGC [44] Method in [31] Method in [52] Method in [53] Prop. Method
Sub E.1 E. 2 Ave. E.1 E. 2 Ave. E.1 E. 2 Ave. E. 1 E. 2 Ave. E. 1 E. 2 Ave. Expr.1 Expr. 2 Ave.
Dice Coeff. 1 73.49 72.96 73.22 80.43 79.10 79.76 71.40 68.17 69.78 61 56 58.5 72 76 74 82.96 82.90 83.02
2 73.90 71.68 72.79 55.10 55.11 55.10 45.49 45.81 45.65 79 76 77.5 84 84 84 78.11 79.09 77.13
3 78.46 82.33 80.40 75.35 79.34 77.35 69.54 65.01 67.27 43 42 42.5 72 75 73.5 82.23 80.36 84.10
4 78.12 77.91 78.01 71.78 71.56 71.67 71.15 72.55 71.85 46 45 45.5 64 67 65.5 80.75 80.87 80.63
Ave. 75.99 76.22 76.10 70.66 71.27 70.97 64.39 62.88 63.63 57.25 54.75 56 73 75.5 74.25 81.01 80.80 81.22
Sensitivity 1 70.81 69.95 70.38 82.19 78.56 80.37 72.49 66.75 69.62 NA NA NA NA NA NA 84.43 80.94 82.68
2 96.79 92.25 94.52 99.04 94.54 96.79 70.45 64.71 67.58 NA NA NA NA NA NA 98.94 94.45 96.70
3 75.72 81.49 78.60 85.13 90.95 88.04 47.38 54.84 51.11 NA NA NA NA NA NA 85.18 90.75 87.96
4 78.78 78.54 78.66 80.59 80.22 80.40 77.79 77.56 77.67 NA NA NA NA NA NA 84.49 83.70 84.09
Ave. 80.52 80.55 80.54 86.73 86.06 86.40 67.02 65.96 66.49 NA NA NA NA NA NA 88.26 87.46 87.85
Precision 1 93.00 95.71 94.36 85.06 86.55 85.81 54.87 59.61 57.24 NA NA NA NA NA NA 84.03 87.53 85.78
2 74.36 74.45 74.40 54.18 54.14 54.16 51.12 51.34 51.23 NA NA NA NA NA NA 78.48 78.58 78.53
3 94.89 96.10 95.49 79.88 79.96 79.92 30.93 37.99 34.46 NA NA NA NA NA NA 85.45 85.48 85.47
4 96.97 97.24 97.11 88.62 88.99 88.81 54.98 59.50 57.24 NA NA NA NA NA NA 93.20 93.58 93.39
Ave. 89.80 90.87 90.34 76.93 77.41 77.17 47.97 52.11 50.04 NA NA NA NA NA NA 85.29 86.29 85.79