Table 1.
Author | Type | Study Purpose | Patients (n) | Ages | Pre‐ and Post‐operative comparison | QOL measure | Duration of benefit measured | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Jones et al. | Retrospective review and phone call survey | Evaluate pre‐ and post‐surgical symptom scores |
17 16 pediatric 1 adult |
3–30 | Yes | Non‐validated symptom questionnaire | No | Conclusion: that there was postoperative improvement in symptoms. No statistical analysis |
Friedman et al. | Prospective data collection | Compare QOL scores with pulmonary function | 51 | 7–20 | No | SNOT‐16 | No | SNOT‐16 score was predictive of FEV1 in patients <12 years of age |
Keck et al. | Prospective data collection | Compare pre‐ and post‐surgical symptom scores | 26 | 3–33 | Yes | Non‐validated symptom score | No | Improved symptoms following treatment |
Taylor et al. | Prospective cohort study | Compare pre‐ and post‐surgical symptom scores |
10 CF patients 11 non‐CF |
5–18 | Yes |
PedsQLTM SNOT‐16 SN‐5 |
No | Preoperative impairment; improvement with sinus surgery |
Thamboo et al. | Cross sectional study | SNOT‐22 to predict presence of polyps | 37 | 6–18 | No |
SNOT‐22 UPSIT |
No | SNOT‐22 score may assist is predicting presence of polyps |
Wentzel et al. | Prospective data collection | Comparison of SN‐5 score with frequency of sinusitis exacerbation or antibiotic use, missed days of school, and missed activities | 50 | 2–12 | No | SN‐5 | No | Worse SN‐5 scores were associated with more frequent sinusitis exacerbations, antibiotic use, missed days of school, and missed activities |
Chan et al. | Prospective data collection | Comparison of CRS diagnosis with SN‐5 scores | 47 | 2–20 | NO | SN‐5 | No | High prevalence of CRS with low impact on QOL |
QOL = quality of life; SNOT = sinonasal outcomes test; CRS = chronic rhinosinusitis; SN‐5 = sinonasal‐5; UPSIT = university of pennsylvania smell identification test; CF = cystic fibrosis; PedsQLTM = pediatric quality of life inventory TM.